As the L.A. Rams evaluate their options regarding Puka Nacua and a possible contract extension, the question is not necessarily how much a number one receiver costs these days, but whether the value meets the price.
In many recent cases, it hasn’t. So the Rams must think twice before paying Nacua top dollar.
The highest-paid receivers of 2025
Looking into what the success rate was for the top-paid wide receivers from the 2025 season, many of them and the teams paying them fell way below expectations. This is especially a consideration
for the Rams and Nacua, given his injury history, to say the least.
These were the ten most expensive cap hits for receivers in 2025, per Spotrac:
Is that self-explanatory enough?
Which teams had success?
I think the lowest bar we can use for measuring success in the NFL is making the playoffs, and out of these top ten contracted wide receivers, only two of their teams made the playoffs: Philadelphia and Chicago. The players from those teams, AJ Brown and DJ Moore, were both traded after the season. What does that say about the confidence those teams had in the contract numbers they had agreed to with those receivers?
Furthermore, of the top 15 salaried receivers, including Moore and Brown, only three of their teams made the playoffs.
If you look closely at this list, you’ll see a couple of teams that seemingly disappoint their fans year after year: the Dallas Cowboys and the Cincinnati Bengals.
You’ll notice that Tee Higgins and Ja’Marr Chase are the highest-paid receiver duo in the league, and yet the team consistently misses the playoffs, mostly because their QB is injured so often. Moral of the story: not only can a great receiver not carry the team, but even two great receivers can’t.
The best duo that money can buy still can’t buy wins in the AFC unless they have a Pro Bowl quarterback.
The sweet spot
As I mentioned, only three of the top 15 on this list helped their teams make the playoffs, but those numbers change dramatically when you look at spots 16-23.
Eight of the nine teams represented here made the playoffs last year, but even then, many of these players weren’t really instrumental in that happening, with Tutu Atwell and Brandon Aiyuk jump off the page as non-contributors.
The Patriots have released Stefon Diggs, and Jauan Jennings was not re-signed by the 49ers.
If you want to measure the ultimate success of the top-paid players, you have to go to the Super Bowl. Both teams had players in the top twenty of the pay scale, but Cooper Kupp (20th) would have to be considered a bit player over the course of the year, when compared to the performance of Jaxon Smith-Njigba (49th), and Diggs was only able to account for 37 yards receiving in the big game.
So what does it mean for Puka?
Looking at the number of players being traded or released after the season, even after having relative success, I think the league is looking at contracts for receivers as more of a temporary or transient thing than as a long-term commitment. Teams aren’t necessary looking for long-term relationships anymore, but just short-term settlements.
The Eagles extended A.J. Brown in 2024 and traded him two years later, a full year before his new contract is set to begin. On the other side of the ball, the Jets extended Sauce Gardner to a four-year contract last summer, then traded him to the Colts only months later.
If the Rams are looking to extend Puka Nacua soon, they could make an agreement that settles the situation now, but does not necessarily prevent Les Snead from looking for other options in the near future if L.A. thinks they need to find a way out.
Given Nacua’s talent as a receiver and importance to Matthew Stafford, a contract extension is reasonable. Given Nacua’s balls-to-the-wall physical playing style that often gets him hurt, and potential for distractions, a deal that gives the Rams options to part ways would be prudent.
