In last week’s rundown of the Brewers’ roster, we looked at how the Brewers appear to be, in general, pretty set in their starting rotation. As a quick review, here’s who the Brewers have to choose from, with their 2026 numbers:
- Jacob Misiorowski: 30 games started, 174 2/3 innings, 1.80 ERA, 2.17 FIP, 5.73 K/BB, Cy Young
- Logan Henderson: 18 GS, 98 1/3 IP, 2.47 ERA, 3.32 FIP, 5.79 K/BB
- Robert Gasser: 20 GS, 109 1/3 IP, 3.87 ERA, 4.23 FIP, 2.94 K/BB
- Kyle Harrison: 24 GS, 115 2/3 IP, 4.20 ERA, 4.03 FIP, 3.92 K/BB
- Quinn Priester: 0 IP in 2026, but 157 1/3 IP, 3.32 ERA, 4.01 FIP, 2.64 K/BB in 2025
- Shane Drohan: 33 G/19 GS, 124 2/3 IP, 4.19 ERA, 3.73 FIP, 2.84 K/BB
- Chad Patrick: 57 G/6GS, 106 IP, 3.40 ERA, 4.17 FIP, 1.98 K/BB
- Brandon Sproat: 19 GS, 97 IP, 5.57 ERA, 5.21 FIP, 1.94 K/BB
- Aaron Ashby: 75 G/1 GS, 89 1/3 IP, 3.12 ERA, 3.11 FIP, 2.83 K/BB
- Coleman Crow: 19 GS, 105 1/3 IP, 3.59 ERA, 2.91 K/BB in Triple-A
- Colton Gordon: 23 GS, 124 2/3 IP, 4.11 ERA, 3.68 K/BB in Triple-A
That’s a lot of options, and the only player who had any sort of real role in the Brewers’ rotation who isn’t returning is Dustin May, who was acquired at the trade deadline and entered free agency after the season. At least one of these is also speculative—despite rumblings
that Ashby could be tried in the rotation, something I feel like we hear every year, I’m skeptical of that until I see it happen. He’s just too valuable to this team out of the bullpen.
This group does lack any sort of veteran presence—none of these 11 pitchers is over 28 years old, and Misiorowski’s 174 2/3 innings in 2026 are the most that any of them have ever thrown in a season. That led me to speculation that the Brewers could poke around a free-agent innings eater type, someone who could reliably keep the pressure off of the younger arms. So, we’ll take a look at some of the free-agent arms that are available and whether they could fit with the Brewers.
There’s also been some discussion in our comments about whether the Brewers might go big for a starter, given that it’s reasonable to expect some level of regression from Henderson and questions over whether Harrison and Priester can replicate their past success. While I don’t really see this happening, for fun I will at least do a quick look over the league to see if there are any difference-making, controllable starters who could, conceivably, be available in a trade at the right cost.
Free Agents
We can safely assume that the Brewers are not in the Tarik Skubal sweepstakes, but I think we should probably extend this to the next level of free agent starting pitcher, the guys who are likely to command either short, expensive contracts or longer ones that could be at or near $100 million in total dollars. This probably rules out Michael King, Trevor Rogers, Sonny Gray, and Freddy Peralta, who I expect will be the next four guys on the market. Nick Martinez is also coming off an All-Star season, and despite his age (he turned 36 in August), will probably command more money than the Brewers are going to spend.
A few of the more prominent pitchers who could conceivably be Brewers targets in the “innings eater” role could include someone like Kevin Gausman or Matthew Boyd. Boyd was an All-Star in 2025, but that was the first season he’d reached 100 innings pitched since before the pandemic, and he wasn’t especially healthy in 2026. Gausman has a long track record as a good pitcher, but he also turns 36 soon and has been starting to trend in the wrong direction. There’s still probably enough here that he’ll have no shortage of suitors, and while I expect the Brewers would sniff around on a one-year deal, I’d be surprised if he can’t get two or three years from someone.
There are some other interesting names. Nick Pivetta wasn’t healthy this season, but he was great in 2025 (and good when he pitched in 2026, which wasn’t often). Though his history prior to 2025 shows a pretty average-ish pitcher, he’ll probably get a nice deal from someone looking for upside. The same goes for Casey Mize, whose history as a blue-chip prospect (he was the first overall pick in 2018), flashes of success (he was excellent in the first half of 2026), and relative youth (he’s not 30 until May 1st) will make him a flashy target. The same is probably true of Kris Bubic, also 29, who was an All-Star in 2025 and is a former first-rounder; the early reports suggest there’s a lot of interest in him even though he only managed 55 innings in 2026. Michael Soroka kind of belongs to this group as well, and is coming off a pretty good season with the Diamondbacks.
Clay Holmes has been solid each of the last two years since switching from relieving to starting, probably solid enough that he’ll get a bigger deal than I expect the Brewers to be interested in. Tyler Mahle was lights out for the Braves after the trade deadline, but was a disaster in the first half. He might be the kind of player the Brewers could sniff around if they like his stuff, but I’d be surprised.
Brady Singer? He’s young-ish (30) and has a few decent-to-good seasons under his belt but he was awful for Cincinnati in 2026. Maybe the Brewers see something they can fix? The upside might be too tempting for a team that would pay more than the Brewers would. Jack Flaherty was a hot name in 2024 but he’s not been very good the last two seasons and wasn’t fully healthy in 2026.
Lucas Giolito is a bounceback candidate that interests me a bit but he missed most of last season with elbow stuff, and while no major surgery was needed that’s not a good sign for a 32-year-old who missed all of 2024 with elbow problems. I’ve seen Zac Gallen’s name bandied around with the Brewers a bit as a potential guy they could fix on a one-year deal… maybe, but it’s difficult to overstate how quickly things have unraveled for him. He went from a third-place Cy Young finish in 2023 to a guy who had a 6.07 ERA and couldn’t strike anyone out in 2026. He’s not old (31 in 2027) and he’s throwing just as hard as he did when he was one of the best pitchers in the league, so I wouldn’t hate it on the right deal (cheap!) just to see if the Brewers could fix him. This ship may have sailed, though.
We also can’t ignore two familiar names: Brandon Woodruff and Dustin May. The Brewers targeted May for a reason, and he’s one of the younger free-agent pitchers out there. There’s plenty of interest elsewhere, and things didn’t always seem rosy in Milwaukee, but he fits the profile and the team is familiar with him. It’s not out of question, but I don’t think the fans would be all that happy.
While most of the fanbase (and probably the league) has given up on Woodruff and think he might even retire, Woodruff’s own words have told us he’s not done—and that was even back when he still thought he needed another major shoulder surgery. I think he’ll pitch somewhere in 2026 on an incentive-laden deal. What if the Brewers offered, like, $2 million with $500k bonuses every 25 innings pitched, or something like that? The Brewers aren’t looking for someone to carry the staff, they’re just looking for a veteran presence, maybe one with some upside. Woodruff fits that bill, and everyone already likes him.
Trades
I am not going to spend time trying to guess what lesser-known pitcher the Brewers could trade for—your guess is as good as mine. They certainly could make a Ryan-Walker-like deal for a starter, and I’d almost be surprised if they didn’t do something like that. But predicting those trades is nearly impossible, so I’m not going to bother.
However, I will do the fun part of making up crazy trades, so let’s get a little crazy with what sorts of top-of-the-rotation types could potentially be available. I’m trying to keep this “realistic” in the sense of “this is a player who the other team probably would trade in the right deal,” but that doesn’t mean I think any of these are remotely likely.
Normally I’d start by looking at bad teams, but… let’s kind of go in reverse for a second. What about Drew Rasmussen? The Rays picked up his club option at $20 million, which is an astronomical number for that franchise, they almost never pay anyone anywhere close to that much. It might be too rich for the Brewers, too, but hey, they were willing to pay Jake Bauers more than that. Rasmussen is a free agent after the season so this would be a one-year pickup and the prospect cost would be very high, but he’s a heck of a pitcher and it wouldn’t be surprising to see him on the market.
Speaking of Florida, we always need to look at the Marlins as potential sellers, not because they’re bad, but because they are constantly trading away their good players as soon as they get remotely expensive. Both Eury Pérez and Max Meyer hit arbitration this season. Both were big-time prospects. Meyer was awesome in 20 starts in 2026, and while Pérez hasn’t quite hit his stride since his 2024 Tommy John surgery, he’s also still only 23 years old and is one of the hardest-throwing starters in the league. It would take a behemoth offer to get Pérez and probably close to that for Meyer, but hey, dream big.
I think everyone in the AL Central thinks they can win the division, so I don’t expect any of those guys to sell… but Joe Ryan will be a free agent after the season and my guess is the Twins would rather get a haul for him than hang on to him. But I don’t think they’d be selling especially high at the moment, so I don’t think this one is going to happen right now—maybe one to revisit at the deadline.
This guy would not be a major acquisition but I need to mention it because I think he needs to be traded and I find him intriguing: Nick Lodolo is a free agent after the season and the Reds are a mess. Lodolo was quite bad in 2026, but he’s had some success in the past and I’m not totally sure why he was so bad last year. Seems like a fun buy-low guy, but the Reds probably don’t want to sell low, and at last year’s deadline they seemed to just kind of forget that trades are things that they are allowed to do, so I’m not going to hold my breath.
There are rumors constantly swirling about whether the Mariners might unload one of their starters, particularly now that Kade Anderson has made the jump to the show. But who do you really want, here? I’m not really interested in Emerson Hancock or Bryce Miller. Bryan Woo, George Kirby, and especially Logan Gilbert are more alluring, but Seattle has probably convinced itself that those guys are better and worth more than they actually are. Plus, Gilbert and Kirby are both getting close to free agency (one more year for Gilbert, two for Kirby). Don’t really see a match, but I’d poke around.
As long as the Angels are bad, and they will be bad for some time, Reid Detmers will be a popular name. He’s only two years from free agency at this point so you’re not getting a long-term solution here, but of all the pitchers who I’d say are likely to be traded in 2027, he’s probably the best one. I’d also love to take Walbert Ureña off of the Angels’ hands, but he’s not a free agent until after the 2032 season and that just seems too far away. Gotta build around someone.
The last guy I’ll mention is Logan Webb, who has two more years on a relatively affordable contract ($23 and $24 million the next two years). But he led the league in innings three years in a row from 2023-25 and then took a significant step back in 2026, and that seems like a warning sign to me, even if there was some bad luck baked into his subpar numbers. I think it’s reasonable to expect Webb to be good the next two years, but I also wouldn’t be remotely shocked iff the wheels just fell off; he’s thrown 980 innings over the last five years, which is, you know, like, what a normal #3 starter might have thrown in a five-year stretch in the early 2000s.
Final Thoughts
I’m not expecting to see any big moves. My official guess is that they’ll trade for someone who has barely pitched above Triple-A, if at all, like Drohan and Gordon when they were acquired last season. I’d be on board with a low-risk move for Gallen, but I’m having a hard time seeing any of the other free agents I mentioned above being a fit in Milwaukee. It’s possible that they could wait out the market and let someone fall to them on a one-year prove-it deal, but the lockout is going to really mess up the free-agency timeline, so I don’t think we’re going to see a whole lot of that kind of thing this year.
Maybe Woodruff? Maybe nothing. Maybe see how Priester and Harrison look and reassess in March or April or June or whenever spring training happens.













