After the offseason exits of Nolan Arenado and Brendan Donovan from the Cardinals organization, it opened up a pathway for Nolan Gorman to take advantage of everyday opportunities. However, that hasn’t quite come to fruition. The Cardinals optioned Gorman to Triple-A Memphis in June and put him through a vigorous rework of his swing and approach at the plate. Since his recall on August 25th, Gorman is 4-for-31 with a slashline of .133/.161/.300 -> .461 OPS, .248 xwOBA, and a 22 wRC+. Gorman’s overall
season numbers look like .186./.265/.316 -> .581 OPS, .275 xwOBA, and a 61 wRC+. I was someone who advocated for Gorman’s recall after a really encouraging hot streak from the middle of July to Gorman’s return in late August. Of course, as I write this sentence, he hits a home run in Colorado.
Overall, it would appear as though Gorman is not a preferred option moving forward. He has shown positively on the defensive side of the ball, posting a +2 DRS (defensive runs saved) and a +1 OAA (outs above average), which both measure impactful defense and range. The Cardinals could potentially look to recoup some value for Gorman from a 3rd-base-needy club that would be willing to bet on the power potential and the improved defensive acumen at a 5 million-ish rate for 2027.
In 2026, the Cardinals hoped to gain clarity and answers on their controlled big-league players to find out if they’re long-term pieces. Sometimes a negative answer is still an answer, and it appears Gorman isn’t one. So, who could be next to throw their hat in the ring of fire, or hot corner, or whatever euphemism you’d like to use?
Blaze Jordan
Almost certainly, a severe sprained ankle suffered in the Baltimore series has ended Blaze Jordan’s season prematurely, even though he was starting to show positive signs of improvement at the plate. If that is in fact the case, Jordan finishes the season with a .247/.276/.382 -> .658 OPS, .284 wOBA, and a 79 wRC+. Blaze Jordan showed that he is currently a capable platoon option, producing a 124 wRC+ against LHP and, unfortunately, a 51 against RHP. Manager Oliver Marmol noted that his career minor league numbers didn’t indicate any severe platoon splits, which likely means he will see opportunities against all types of pitching in 2027. Jordan also posted a +2 DRS and +1 OAA, like Gorman, though that number was a +4 through his first 30 or so games and began to backslide during the month of August. Jordan is most likely a 1B/DH long-term, but for 2027 he can probably continue to get opportunities at 3rd if no one else can take hold of the opportunity.
Thomas Saggese
Since Saggese’s recall, all he’s done is hit! Coming into Sunday’s performance .550/.577/.1.100 in his last 7 games. 11-for-26 this past week with 3 HR, 2 doubles, 8 RBI, and 2 SB. He then followed last week up with another 2-hit game in Sunday’s finale in Colorado, with another 2-hit performance including another double and 2 runs scored. Still at only 24 years old, I think a lot of fans had already written off what Saggese was capable of. If you think back to 2023, the season he won the Texas League MVP, he slashed .306/.374/.530 -> .903 OPS in 139 Games between Double-A and Triple-A. That season also included 26 HR, 34 doubles, 111 RBI, and 12 stolen bases. When you consider not only Saggese’s age, but also some of his minor league pedigree, it’s not a stretch to conceive that he walks into 2026 as the favorite to take the first chunk of the season at minimum with the 3rd base spot and his name penciled in there.
Jesus Baez
When you think about what JOSHUA Baez has accomplished in his short time in the big leagues and how impressive his flashes of excitement have been, he might not even be the best BAEZ in the system. Jesus Baez, acquired from the New York Mets in the Ryan Helsley trade in 2025, has made an absolute mockery of Double-A and should begin 2027 at the Triple-A level; his electric play will be knocking on the big-league door. With Gold Glove SS Masyn Winn entrenched at the position, Baez will likely need a near-term move to the hot corner for a quicker route to the big leagues. This season, in 53 games at Double-A, Baez has 22 HR and 60 RBI and is slashing .247./.300/.489 -> .789 OPS with a 144 wRC+. Baez has a slick glove and the ability to make all the throws from the left side of the diamond, as well as the ability to flash well above average thanks to his raw athleticism. If the other two mentioned options above fail to take the opportunity and run with it for the full season, expect Baez to get his shot sometime in the last half of the season as the future of Cardinals baseball continues to evolve and the excitement of young athleticism continues to ascend.
Outside addition?
Until we know more. I do want to leave open the idea that perhaps the Cardinals could pursue an outside addition. I wouldn’t dream of getting your hopes up over some Jose Ramirez-level player that’s not realistic, though he’d be extremely fun to add to this Cardinals group, don’t ya think? If Gorman is moved out of St. Louis and all of these ascending bats primarily hit right-handed, one could posit that a little bit of balance might be required to help Manager Oliver Marmol to navigate a 162-game season. I present an interesting outside option for your consumption. Detroit Tigers 3B/1B/DH Colt Keith. In 129 Games this season, Keith has a .260/.321/.402 slash -> .723 OPS .319 wOBA, and is a 103 wRC+ on the season. Colt would be a really solid platoon partner for Blaze Jordan, producing a 111 wRC+ in 368 PA against RHP in 2026. Keith signed a pre-debut extension before the 2024 season and will be owed 4.3 million in 2027, 5.3 million in 2028, and 5.3 million in 2029, before he has 3 consecutive club options that gradually increase to $ 10 million in 2030, 13 million in 2031, and $ 15 million in 2032. Allowing for cost certainty and little long-term risk, consider that the real weight of the contract is in the club options, thus giving the team the majority of the power in the situation. Probably a comparable defender to Gorman/Jordan, grading as a -1 DRS and a 0 OAA at 3rd base in 2026; he is, however, rated as a +2 in baserunning value. He is capable of doing some things really well and could be another quality piece of the mix if the Cardinals wanted to go this route.
The Cardinals will maintain flexibility and options for this spot on the roster going into 2027. The good news is that they aren’t forced to one thing over another and can be afforded the opportunity to be opportunistic if something that really fits becomes available. If they chose to go the Saggese route, I’d be in favor of it. If they chose to give Blaze Jordan more run next season and to see what adjustments he could make in the offseason, I’d understand it. If they went out and brought in a Colt Keith to work alongside a Blaze Jordan, I’d be really intrigued to see what that would look like, and if none of those options panned out and Jesus Baez ascends and is just an electric factory of play on the field, I’d be really amped to watch that play out as well! I think ultimately any route that doesn’t include running it back with Nolan Gorman, now that we all should probably know better, would be a welcome direction at the hot corner.
-Thanks for reading
