Vic Saier had five really good years for the Cubs, including receiving some downballot MVP votes twice, and you probably have never heard of him.
This is partly because his career neatly fit into a Cubs interregnum. He debuted for the Cubs in 1911, one year after they finished their run of four NL pennants in five years, and was done by 1917, the year before they again were NL champions.
In 1913, Saier, a first baseman, batted .289/.370/.480, led the NL in triples with 21, and stole 26 bases. Incidentally,
Saier is the most recent Cub to have 20+ triples in a season (the only other one is Frank Schulte, who had 21 in 1911, when he was league MVP, and we’ll see Schulte later in this series). The only Cub who’s approached 20 since 1911 is Ryne Sandberg, who had 19 in his 1984 MVP season.
Saier also got downballot MVP votes in 1914, but his numbers weren’t quite as good: .240/.357/.415, but with 18 home runs, which was second-best in the NL that year. That was a tremendous number of homers in the Deadball Era, too. Per Saier’s SABR bio:
Four of those homers came against the great Christy Mathewson, who said that Vic had hit some of the hardest balls ever hit against him. The Cubs had fallen apart into warring camps—they weren’t the most harmonious bunch even in the days when they were winning pennants—but in the midst of all the turmoil, the Chicago newspapers lauded Saier as “The Quiet Star.” Vic had a self-effacing personality and went about his business with a minimum of fuss and bother.
Saier suffered a leg injury in 1915, though his numbers were still decent, and he was a solid 2.3 bWAR player in 1916, too. But his career basically ended after this injury in early 1917:
In a game against the St. Louis Cardinals on April 14, 1917, Saier broke his leg in a collision at home plate when he tried to score from second on a single. His season was over after just six games. Vic might not have been ready to come back even in 1918, but we’ll never know for sure because he elected to work at a defense plant to help the war effort instead of playing baseball. The Cubs sold Saier’s rights to the Pittsburgh Pirates, with whom Vic attempted a comeback in 1919.
Saier batted .223/.306/.313 in 58 games for the Pirates in 1919, then left baseball and returned to his hometown of Lansing, Michigan, where he died May 14, 1967, aged 76. Saier posted 15.0 bWAR in seven Cubs seasons.













