The Pittsburgh Pirates were better in 2026. Their 82 wins were the most for the club since 2018. And while they fell short of the playoffs, the offense was much-improved, even if the team’s starting rotation let them down a bit. Well, one popular analytics site has the Bucs pegged for a much better outcome in 2027,as FanGraphs and their ZiPS rating has the Bucs as a Wild Card team next season.
Here’s what FanGraphs has to say about the Bucs after finishing just four games off on their Pirates prediction
for 2026.
“When it came to projecting the Pittsburgh Pirates’ 2026 season, ZiPS was grumpier than most other public systems and the FanGraphs staff, forecasting the team for just a 79-83 record in the final preseason standings. The Pirates beat that mark by three wins, finishing at 82-80, for the team’s first winning record since 2018. Unfortunately, that wasn’t enough, as the Pirates finished six back (realistically seven because of tiebreakers) of the Philadelphia Phillies, who grabbed the National League’s final Wild Card spot. However, despite not having snuck into October the way that many thought they would, ZiPS likes the Pirates significantly more this time around.”
The ZiPS rating apparently likes both the offense and the pitching staff, saying this about the plate production in Pittsburgh:
“Going through the lineup, there really isn’t much to hate, though there isn’t much to absolutely love, either. ZiPS still sees age as a big downside risk for Bryan Reynolds and isn’t (yet) buying Esmerlyn Valdez as a 130 wRC+ guy. I think re-signing Brandon Lowe would be a pretty big deal for this team, as he still gets the best WAR projection of anyone on the offense. As with the Brewers, ZiPS believes that Pittsburgh has good depth in the upper minors, though the Pirates lack bonafide future stars on the level of Jesús Made. The projections suggest that the team would be best-served by letting Murf Gray seize the third base job as soon as possible. Plus, Murf Gray sounds like the name of an 1880s superstar who tried to run over Arlie Latham in a Flocken Elektrowagen.
Given their good second- and third-tier talent, if the Pirates are willing to spend some money this offseason — not always a given — I hope they concentrate it in one or two good players rather than spreading it around to veteran memberberries as they have in recent years. I’m just not sure what signing Andrew McCutchen (sorry), Carlos Santana, Marcell Ozuna, or Tommy Pham could have realistically accomplished. If you want to crib from the Brewers, sign a reclamation projection or an interesting 28-year-old, and try to catch lightning in a bottle rather than buying a bottle that’s already free of electricity.“
And they think the pitching staff is due for a rebound and are very high on Mason Montgomery out of the bullpen.
“ZiPS sees the Pirates with a middle-tier offense, but it really likes the pitching staff. I can’t exactly claim that the system is going out on a projection limb, however; our Depth Charts, which are currently Steamer-based, have the Pirates as the game’s no. 3 pitching staff by WAR, behind just the Phillies and Dodgers. Paul Skenes will very likely have a better 2027, and you know you’re a good pitcher when people are down on a 4.2-WAR season. Braxton Ashcraft is a perfect no. 2 starter, and ZiPS puts Jared Jones and Bubba Chandler both safely over the 100 ERA+ line. Even Mitch Keller’s 4.50 projected ERA is a good bit better than his disappointing 2026, and certainly better than par for the fifth-best starter in your rotation.
The bullpen isn’t full of name-brand relievers, but ZiPS still pegs the group as easily among the top 10 in baseball. Mason Montgomery is terrific, and Luke Weaver should be better than he was in his brief Pirates stint this summer. ZiPS thinks Carmen Mlodzinski is just as good as Weaver when used as a reliever, and when deployed exclusively in relief, ZiPS sees the whole ‘pen with ERAs in the 3.00s until you get to Antwone Kelly and Evan Sisk, and even they just barely land on the wrong side of 4.00. Seth Hernandez probably isn’t ready just yet, but ZiPS sees Hunter Barco, Connor Wietgrefe, and Khristian Curtis as reasonable back-end fill-ins, and possibly more if they hit their upside.“
And finally, the prediction for a Wild Card run:
“It’s still early, but as they’re constructed right now, ZiPS sees the Pirates as being in a strong position to make a Wild Card run, even though they’re a tier down from the Brewers and Cubs in the NL Central.“
So what do you guys think of the FanGraphs ZiPS projection? Are they right on? Or way off base? Tell us in the comments what you’re thinking and also your projection for the Pirates in 2027.













