If I told you the San Francisco 49ers offense rode Deebo Samuel and Christian McCaffrey en route to a win, you’d probably assume I was talking about the 2023 season.
Unfortunately for the Dallas Cowboys, it happened on Sunday, and the 49ers needed every bit of McCaffrey and Samuel, helping the 49ers edge Dallas in a 46-40 slobberknocker.
It looked for a bit like the 49ers would run away with things on Sunday, but a 21-point fourth quarter allowed by the 49ers’ defense kept things closer than they needed.
At the end of the day, the 49ers offense outpaced the defense.
With the offense outplaying the defense, it makes sense all three stars are from that side of the ball:
3rd star: WR Deebo Samuel
Sunday was as vintage of a game as you can get from Samuel.
Samuel opened the scoring for the 49ers in typical Samuel fashion: a quick screen going untouched for a touchdown. With San Francisco chasing an early field goal, the offense went to work for the first time, putting together an eight-play, 78-yard drive ending with Purdy swinging a pass out to Samuel, who used some blocks from Colton McKivitz and Dominick Puni to walk into the endzone to put the 49ers up 7-3.
His next score would be on the ground and might become one of the most memorable play calls of the Kyle Shanahan era. With the 49ers clinging to a five-point lead early in the third quarter, San Francisco took advantage of another massive play. On the third play of the drive, Shanahan reached into his bag of tricks and pulled out a reverse.
Kaelon Black would take a toss to the right, but pitch it to Samuel going right-to-left. As Tom Brady pointed out on the broadcast, when Samuel had the ball going to the left, ten Cowboys defenders were still following Black in the opposite direction. With all the space in the world and a couple blockers in front of him, Samuel played the sideline perfectly, tight-roping his way for a 70-yard score.
With the two scores on top of 109 total yards, Samuel is deserving of Sunday’s No. 3 star.
2nd star: RB Christian McCaffrey
It took McCaffrey a while to get things going in the run game on Sunday. However, with just the performance he put together in the passing game, his rushing wasn’t really relevant.
McCaffrey led all pass-catchers with 161 yards on four catches, with two game-breaking scores to swing momentum the 49ers’ way. The first one we will get into more detail with our No. 1 star, but McCaffrey was the beneficiary of the play. With the 49ers facing a third-and-8 late in the third quarter, Purdy hit McCaffrey, who had plenty of space to take the short pass 74 yards to put the 49ers up one.
His second receiving touchdown wasn’t as long, but it won the 49ers the game. Dallas cut what was a 38-19 San Francisco lead to 38-32 in the span of eight minutes. With the 49ers clinging to the six-point lead, Purdy again would find McCaffrey with an entire field’s worth of space in front of him, and this time McCaffrey would go 66 yards to put the 49ers up 14 and put the game out of reach.
McCaffrey sandwiched a rushing touchdown between his receiving scores, finishing with three total touchdowns
1st star: QB Brock Purdy
Without Purdy, there is no Samuel or McCaffrey performance on Sunday.
Purdy earned Sunday’s No. 1 star with the play that completely swung momentum the Niners way, but it was his whole performance that stole the show. The quarterback used both of McCaffrey’s big plays with a few others to throw for a career-high 389 yards with three touchdowns and no interceptions. And not only did Purdy have a career day, but he may have made the best play of his already impressive highlight reel.
With Dallas taking a 16-10 lead in the second quarter, San Francisco’s following drive got off to a less than ideal start. Purdy was sacked to lose six yards but would cancel it out with an eight-yard pass to Kittle to set up a third-and-8. That’s when Purdy magic struck.
Purdy started the play by avoiding a Caleb Downs sack and rolled right. The quarterback might have had the angle to scramble for the first down with Shemar James bearing down. Instead, Purdy pulled up and found a wide-open McCaffrey 10 yards in front of him, and McCaffrey did the rest to give the 49ers a 17-16 lead.
Oh, you thought that was the highlight play I was referencing? Not at all. The highlight I was talking about was Samuel’s 70-yard end-around.
One of those blockers ahead of Samuel was none other than Purdy. The 49ers quarterback kept with the play the whole way, joining Trent Williams and Jordan Watkins as part of the convoy. It was actually Purdy who made the last “block” (more like got in the way) 40 yards downfield to give Samuel the space to finish the run.
After a few weeks of his play stabilizing after a hot start, Purdy put together an MVP-level performance when the 49ers needed it the most.
Throughout the season, we will track the three stars of the season by tallying points for each star award using a complex scoring system: three points for being the first star, two for the second, and one for the third. Through Week 10, the standings are:
- QB Brock Purdy – 10 points
- WR Mike Evans – 8 points
- RB Christian McCaffrey – 7 points













