When it comes to the Colorado Rockies and the Trade Deadline, expect the unexpected. The perennial cellar-dwellers have at times conducted the types of fire sales familiar to teams without a shot at the ostseason, attempting to restock their prospect pool while punting on the current group. But they’ve also had deadlines where they hedged, most infamously in 2021 when they held onto Trevor Story and Jon Gray, two valuable assets on expiring contracts who ended up leaving in free agency after the season.
Perhaps with Paul DePodesta now leading baseball operations, they will take a more normal approach. Assuming the Rockies do, in fact, sell, they have some pieces.
A trio of veteran starters — Kyle Freeland, Michael Lorenzen, and Tomoyuki Sugano — are on expiring deals. Freeland and Lorenzen have been dreadful, but given the Coors effect and a constant need for starting pitching around the league, they might have low-end value. Sugano’s been more encouraging in his first year in Colorado, pitching to a 102 OPS+, and could be a viable rotation piece for a contender.
Given their roster construction, it’s more likely the Yankees will target one of Colorado’s relievers. Longtime starter Antonio Senzatela has been a revelation in his first year pitching out of the bullpen, posting a 3.07 ERA and 160 ERA+ in 44 innings. Taking advantage of shorter outings, his fastball is up two ticks. Senzatela’s also transformed his cutter from an afterthought into his secondary pitch, to great effect (opponents are hitting .196 against it). The 31-year-old will be a free agent after this season and is a virtual lock to be moved.
Another option is Jimmy Herget, a journeyman who’s caught on in Colorado and pitched at a high level in a year and a half there. The Yankees have swung deals for two Rockies relievers (Jake Bird and Angel Chivilli) in the past year and, while neither has panned out thus far, that shouldn’t hold GM Brian Cashman back from kicking the tires on Senzatela and Herget.
On the other side of the ball, veteran utilityman Willi Castro holds value and is under contract through 2027. He’s picked things up after a slow start, slashing .292/.388/.472 in July. He could be on the Yankees’ radar, though his skill set is a bit redundant to Amed Rosario’s. Mickey Moniak, also under team control through next year, could be moved as well. After grading out as one of the worst outfield defenders in baseball last year, he’s stabilized a bit this year. But it’s his bat that plays — the lefty has a .990 OPS against right-handed pitching this year.
The biggest question mark for the Rockies is whether they’ll shop Hunter Goodman. The 26-year-old broke out last year, making the NL All-Star team while taking home a Silver Slugger at catcher. Goodman has been just as dominant offensively this year; his 27 home runs are seven ahead of the next-best catcher.
While the jury’s still out on him defensively, and his below-average framing rate flies in the face of the Yankees’ well-established philosophy at the position, their catchers have struggled so mightily at the plate that they’d have to ask after Goodman if the Rockies make him available. The bigger wrinkle is that, with three more years of club control after this season, Colorado make take their best player off the table, at the very least preferring to hold onto him until he’s closer to free agency.
As we approach the deadline with so few teams truly out of contention, those teams will garner more than their fair share of attention. Count the Rockies, on pace for their fourth straight 100-loss season, squarely in that group. If the Yankees link up with them on a trade, the most likely scenario is that they acquire one of their veteran relievers, with Hunter Goodman lurking as a higher-impact dark horse.
