The Baseball Hall of Fame ballot for 2027 was just announced and you’d better believe that time comes for us all because Buster Posey and Pablo Sandoval, two players who were instrumental to the championship era of San Francisco Giants Baseball, are among the new group of 14.
Buster Posey is, of course, a Hall of Fame-caliber catcher who will almost certainly get in on this first ballot. Pablo Sandoval, who just announced his retirement from professional baseball yesterday, won’t be getting in, but
that doesn’t lessen his impact on the franchise.
He’s been the best international free agent signing of the 21st century by the Giants to actually play for the Giants. Back in 2024, Grant Brisbee did a deep dive on the matter and after doing a simple WAR analysis of international players signed, kept, and traded away concluded:
If not for a cherubic, switch-hitting catcher who wasn’t considered a top prospect before the 2008 season, the Giants would have almost nothing to show for their international efforts since Juan Marichal left. As is, they still have almost nothing to show for it. This is no way to build a modern team, and the Giants are keenly aware of that.
(Technically, pitcher Luis Castillo has amassed the most WAR of any Giant international signing since 1973 — 22.3 — but Sandoval’s 20.3 for the Giants leads all international players who wound up playing for the major league team.)
Obviously, his 1,130 career hits for the Giants and .285/.337/.457 slash in the regular season are important and memorable, but he also hit .344/.389/.545 (167 PA) in the three postseasons from 2010-2014. He’s the Kung Fu Panda in San Francisco who hit three home runs in a World Series Game in 2012, caught the final out of the 2014 World Series, and was generally the straw that stirred the drink.
I’m giving him a bit of a short shrift here because he was basically the energy the team needed. Immature, but talented and — at least as a Giant — a winner. So much so that when he came back in 2017 after a miserable stint in Boston he hit the walk-off home run on the final day of the season that knocked the Giants out of the first pick in the following year’s draft.
He and Buster Posey might not go into Cooperstown together, but they’ll forever be together because of those championship years and this Lookout Landing post from the 2010 NLCS.
But back to Buster Posey, who will soak up all or most of the attention — and, if all goes well, will be inducted the summer of 2027 along with his manager, Bruce Bochy and another key Giant, Dusty Baker — and rightfully so. Although Buster Posey is currently the worst top baseball executive the franchise has ever had, that doesn’t matter at all when it comes to his Hall of Fame career.
He was the Giant that brought the Giants back to relevance in the post-Bonds era and led a group that was far more serious than any of the teams during that time, when it really was Barry Bonds and some help (with all due respect to Hall of Famer Jeff Kent). He was as much a part of the pitching success as the actual pitchers, set the tone defensively, and on top of that was the middle of the order bat. There were many stretches from 2010-2014 when I thought they were asking too much of him by making him the cleanup hitter! Turns out Buster could handle it.
We’ll have plenty of time to discuss Posey’s illustrious career as it’s a near-certainty he gets in when the tally is announced in January. There’s the Joe Mauer comp as a recent example, but Posey also has three championships, which could be a meaningful enough measure to close Posey’s obvious gaps from a counting stats perspective. His 1,500 career hits are just 35th on the career catching register. He has fewer home runs than Terry Steinbach and Yadier Molina. It’s also worth mentioning that he didn’t amass all of his counting stats as a catcher. He played 229 games at first (31 as a DH). But, he is 1 of just 12 catchers in MLB history to win an MVP Award. He has a Rookie of the Year Award, a Gold Glove, five Silver Slugger awards, two Comeback Player of the Year awards and 7 All-Star appearances to go along with it.
He was one of the faces of the sport for a time there, too. He’s certainly a top, what, six player in the entire history of one of baseball’s crown jewel franchises? Listing his accomplishments barely feels like he does him justice. Between Buster Posey and Pablo Sandoval — and even Tim Lincecum, Madison Bumgarner, and Matt Cain — it felt like the Giants could do anything.
The rest of the new names are fun to go through, both for their connection to this championship era of Giants Baseball and lack of connection. But also, all of these guys are still in my active memory, so going through the list is as much about convincing myself that I’m getting old and about to die as remembering some guys:
Jake Arrieta really turned into one of the top pitchers in the sport for a time, but was just 5-5 with a 4.18 career ERA against the Giants. He held them to 2 runs in the 2016 NLDS in a game the Cubs would eventually lose. That was part of a 2-year stretch (2015-2016) where he posted a 1.03 ERA in 4 starts (26.2 IP) against the team, though. In 2015, he helped the Cubs sweep the Giants in a four game Series at Wrigley for the first time since the 70s. In 2017, he opined on the Hunter Strickland-Bryce Harper brawl:
“I thought it was awesome. Every once in a while, it’s refreshing to see two teams emotionally charged getting after it. And when something like that happens versus continuing to chirp and talk about it, why don’t you go out there and see somebody? That’s exactly what happened in the game.”
Wow, remember when the Giants were relevant enough to be discussed by players on other teams? Doubt we’ll be alive to see that happen again. Anyway, Arrieta was 115-93 in 285 career games. A 3.98 ERA in 1,612.1 regular season innings. He also won NL Cy Young in 2015.
Jay Bruce was on that 2012 Reds team the Giants turned the tables on and was the second out of that scary 9th inning in Game 5 that Sergio Romo had to navigate in order to secure the Giants’ 6-4 win. He also hit 319 home runs in a 14-year career.
Starlin Castro was a four-time All-Star who hit .284 in 61 career games against the Giants. His final game as a major leaguer was against them in 2021 (he went 3-for-4).
Wade Davis was one of the dominant backend relievers the Kansas City Royals threw at the Giants in the 2014 World Series. In 2014, he had a 1.00 ERA in 71 games (72 IP) and got Cy Young votes as a non-closer. He was worth 3.1 fWAR, which has to be one of the greatest reliever seasons of all time. He struck out 10 Giants in 5 World Series innings in 2014. He did allow an unearned run in the Giants’ Game 5 win.
Jon Lester was a 5-time All-Star who won 3 championships (two with Boston, one with the Cubs) and famously found Buster Posey to be weird when the Giants tried — and failed — to sign him in the 2014-2015 offseason.
Andrew Miller became a dominant left-handed reliever in the American League, but never wound up facing the Giants in the postseason. Indeed, his first matchup against them was as a starter for the Marlins in 2009. He’d go 7 years before seeing them again, but as a reliever in 2016 for Cleveland.
Kyle Seager hit 242 home runs in 1,480 career games, all with the Mariners. He’s Corey Seager’s brother.
Asdrubal Cabrera was in the American League for most of the Giants’ championship era but was a part of the 2019 Nationals championship team. The switch-hitting shortstop is most famous to me for writing a homophobic slur on his eye black. I mean, it’s probably unfair to boil down a 15-year career to that, but it’s what I do remember most about him. Not the 15-season career where he won a Gold Glove and two Silver Slugger awards.
Ervin Santana I remember as being a pretty good Angel, but he was an All-Star for the Twins as well in 2017. He threw 2,486.2 innings!
Joakim Soria was an ace reliever on the Royals but was gone before the Royals’ 2014-2015 run. He had 229 career saves across 14 seasons.
Brett Gardner was Mr. Yankee, playing all of his 14 seasons with them after being drafted in the 3rd round in the 2005 draft. He had 1,470 hits in 1,688 games. A .256/.342/.398 line wit 274 stolen bases. He had just 24 plate appearances against the Giants, his second-fewest versus any opponent (22 against PIT). He was 3-for-21.
Ryan Zimmerman was Mr. Washington National. Probably Brett Kavanaugh’s favorite player, if he had to pick one. He was their 1st round draft pick (#4 overall) in 2005 and played his entire 16-year career with them. 1,846 career hits in 1,799 games. .277/.341/.475 line with 284 home runs. The Giants kept him pretty well in check during the championship era (17-for-84 with 1 home run).













