It was a while back when I posted something in the Feed asking for your hot takes for the rest of the Phillies season.
In the middle of a supremely cold streak is not usually the time to hope for optimism and joy, so naturally a lot of the responses were of the negative variety. Still, it was awesome that so many of you decided to partake, so let’s go through a few of them and talk about them.
In the weeks since the post was put up, Harper has hit .315/.415/.667 with five home runs, 14 runs batted
in over 65 plate appearances. He is currently 11th in baseball with a 159 wRC+, 11th with a .405 wOBA, all while doing with so with a pedestrian .279 BABIP. The parameters for what makes one “elite” in the game today likely combine some offense and defense, an issue for a player like Harper that the defensive metrics mostly agree is having a down season to this point. Yet if there was someone on the team that I would consider affixing that label to, Harper is near the top of that list.
Nola? Well, I’m not sure a sub-3.50 ERA is near his future, but getting it under 4 at this point would be a feat unto itself. Crawford was never going to be an All-Star for the National League this season, let alone the starting option.
It’s the Aidan Miller part of this take that caught my eye. Trading him this season is likely off the table. First of all, he’s injured with a mysterious back injury, which torpedoes any value the team might think they could get back in a trade in the first place. Second, he’s still an important part of this team’s future once they are able to get him back onto the field. Without knowing what is going on specifically, it’s hard to determine what that future actually looks like. The team has been hesitant to say out loud what the specific injury is, citing potential HIPAA violations, which leads to speculation. That kind of speculation can be dangerous. Amongst the TGP writing staff, the name “David Wright” is getting bandied about, and not in the good sense. So while there is the theoretical idea that Miller could be moved for something at the trade deadline, the plain truth is that the team isn’t going to do that.
Woooo baby. It’s only fair to link the rest of the post here, too large for a single screenshot to take care of it, but I can also throw it in in another picture for you.
Now, let’s get down to brass tacks here.
Bryce Harper isn’t getting traded by the team. Not now, not ever. Do whatever it is you need to do to flag this, but he’s not going anywhere. Any trade idea that includes his name is just not worth the time. From the reasoning that was taken here, the idea was to do something that would shake up the clubhouse in the midst of a long losing streak, a streak that has since been broken with the assistance of Harper himself.
Now, to the broader idea of shaking up the clubhouse if the team does not advance far enough in the potential postseason, that’s still a viable idea. At some point, the front office is going to have to acknowledge that the group they have assembled needs a refresh, that new faces need to be included. Thus far, Crawford and Andrew Painter have added to that mix, but maybe they will see that something new is indeed necessary. Aidan Miller is theoretically ready to take over for Bohm, but the rest of the roster, as has been written over and over and over, really can’t go anywhere else. Their contracts have sort of anchored them to this team. Would it require creativity? Sure, but that’s why front offices are paid what they are paid.
Here’s another one.
Adolis Garcia.
Where to begin? Is he good or is he not good? Is he part of the team’s future, or is he part of the ever growing list of right fielders that are taking up the space for the Phillies? He’s been a godsend in the outfield for the team, particularly when compared the stone footed Nick Castellanos, but the bat has been lacking. There are some good under the hood things happening – getting his walk rate back in line, hitting the ball very hard – but it hasn’t resulted in extra base power that the team was hoping he’d find again. There is next to no chance the team moves away from him this season as there isn’t much of anything viable enough to replace him at the moment.
He’s just been….fine. Nothing more, nothing less. Do we wish there was improvement? Of course we do. We’re almost 200 plate appearances into the season though. Is that leap coming? Not quite sure that it is.
