Gerry McNamara took his team down to Madison Square Garden for their first regular-season test against a ranked team in St. John’s, and it was a good test. It showed if this Syracuse team can hang with the best, and what they need to work on if they want to consistently be in national conversations.
So what were the positives in this game? Well, the first half is the obvious part where the Orange took a lead into halftime. The team shot 58% from the field in the first twenty minutes, and throughout
their many turnovers managed to stay competitive using that and their dominance in the paint. They had effectively slowed down St. John’s holding them to 33 points.
However, Syracuse came out in the second half and got shredded if you put it bluntly. A Rick Pitino halftime talk will certainly do that for a team, and the Red Storm translated it into an onslaught on the way to a 79-62 win to give the ‘Cuse their second loss of the season and in a row.
The biggest factor of that was turnovers, the final tally of Orange turnovers was 21 and St. John’s got 32 points off all of those. It is known how difficult top end defenses are, and the Pitino system is a prime example of that. Syracuse just was not up to the task when it came to facing a top team for a full 40 minutes.
Syracuse is not ready to compete constantly among the elite in college basketball, they have plenty to work on before they can cement themselves as a true competitor with teams like St. John’s. I’ve already mentioned the turnovers, but there are some more pieces that contributed to their performance.
Another main problem that this team has is inconsistent shooting, and that can not exist if you are a team looking to be at the top of the game. Compared to the 58% the team shot in the first half, they only shot 33% in the second half where they fumbled the game away. On top of that, after a quality three-point display against Indiana, the Orange only made 4 three pointers this entire game. That just can’t happen throughout the entirety of the season, you need to be able to be consistent so you can build your identity.
The last thing that stands out to me that holds back the Orange is, who is the main guy? Who is going to be the leader of this team on the floor and be the night in and night out scorer you can count on? Coming into the season, it was thought to be Aiden Tobiason, but his hamstring injury meant that Sadiq White and Gavin Doty would have to pick up the slack. While White has been scoring the ball well, Doty has had major problems adjusting to the high major level. He put up big numbers against New Haven and Central Connecticut, but only scored 7 combined against Indiana and St. John’s, shooting 3-15 in that span.
It is getting closer to the time of questioning if Gavin Doty is made for power conference play, and there are reasons pointing to him not being cut out for it. Kiyan Anthony has provided off the bench very well, but another starter preferrably has to step up and be the missing piece to a duo that guides Syracuse.













