Sitting in the postgame press conference at Ohio Stadium, David Braun repeatedly said how special this Northwestern team is. He repeatedly said that he wants to honor this group the right way.
Well, after Northwestern’s 28-19 loss to No. 20 Ohio State, the ‘Cats have lost three straight, and the season is spiraling out of control. Here’s a look into the key factors that defined Northwestern’s performance.
Stock up
Marchiol’s (serviceable) Magic
Look, Nicco Marchiol isn’t Aidan Chiles. He’s not a Heisman-level
quarterback. He’s not going to singlehandedly win you a football game.
Still, he did a more-than-passable job of going into The Shoe and keeping Northwestern in the game.
To put it simply, Marchiol wasn’t the reason Northwestern lost. In fact, he might have been the reason the ‘Cats were in it midway through the fourth quarter.
Marchiol’s third-down magic led to Northwestern’s two field goals in the first half. Early on in the game, he converted a third-and-8 via a 12-yard dart to tight end Alex Honig. He did so again via a 20-yard sling to Joseph Himon II. In a later possession, Marchiol rolled out to his right and lofted the ball over the top to Luke Dehnicke for 24 yards to move the chains on third-and-9.
Northwestern converted six third downs largely due to Marchiol’s creativity and playmaking. He managed the game well and consistently hit open receivers to keep drives alive. Northwestern had more time of possession in the first half, trailing in total game possession by under six minutes.
Marchiol’s issues came when trying to cap off drives with touchdowns. Offensive penalties or untimely sacks nagged the ‘Cats all game long and prevented them from keeping up with the high-octane Buckeyes.
So, sure, it wasn’t always pretty, but Marchiol did the job he was asked to do. There were other reasons Northwestern lost by nine points.
Depth of the Wildcats’ repertoire
Northwestern’s offense looked stagnant for most of the game, but there were glimpses of fluidity. There were several sequences of plays where the ‘Cats chained together positive gains to threaten a flimsy Buckeyes defense.
This spotty success came from NU’s variety of weapons. Seven Wildcat receivers caught a pass on the day, and Marchiol had plenty of options. Dehnicke led the pack with five catches for 88 yards and a touchdown, but Himon, Honig and many others made meaningful contributions in big moments of the game.
Several of the receivers, notably Wilde for a majority of the first three quarters, struggled to get open throughout stretches, but it seemed there was always someone new streaking open in purple and white. Marchiol didn’t always have the time to find his artillery, but the wideouts, tight ends and running backs all made plays in the passing game.
Stock neutral
Special teams
In the week in which Ohio State fired its special teams coordinator Robby Discher and transitioned to a group-led approach, special teams seemed to take the spotlight in Columbus.
First, it was the two 40-plus-yard field goals that NU’s Jackson Kleather nailed through the middle of the uprights.
Then, Ohio State muffed a punt late in the third quarter of a one-possession game, giving Northwestern the ball right back after a three-and-out.
Finally, it was Northwestern’s Drew Wagner fumbling a punt midway through the fourth quarter to give the ball to a struggling OSU offense in the red zone. The Buckeyes scored in three plays to push their lead to 15, ending NU’s hopes of an upset.
Both teams had ups and downs on special teams, so it’s hard to declare whether it was a positive or negative for Northwestern. Yet, in a game in which it was a huge underdog on the road, you’d have hoped NU could have taken advantage of the little things and play a clean game to pull off the upset.
Stock down
Everything about the secondary
Every single person in the stadium knew Ohio State’s offensive plan heading into the game. Well, maybe every single person except Tim McGarigle. It’s no mystery that the Buckeyes live and die with Jeremiah Smith.
Despite the transparency of the Buckeyes’ one-man offense, Smith finished the game with 11 catches for 117 yards and a touchdown, setting the all-time Big Ten receiving yards record in the process. For a majority of the game, Northwestern defended Smith with man-to-man coverage and a safety favoring his side over the top. The ‘Cats’ strategy kept the Buckeyes in front, but it failed to account for the full scope of the likely No. 1 pick in the NFL Draft’s route tree. Smith repeatedly beat the ‘Cats’ single-man coverage off the line, and Fahey quickly delivered the ball before Northwestern’s safety could intervene. Ohio State was perfectly happy tick-tacking its way down the field via intermediate completions to its star wide receiver.
It’s obviously easier said than done to stop such a generational player, but it could’ve been better. Smith had 17 targets on the day.
In addition to the failure to limit Smith, NU’s secondary again showed an inability to wrap up and finish plays. Whenever an OSU runner reached the second level, the ‘Cats struggled to make open field tackles and prevent chunk plays. The Buckeyes rushed for 168 yards, and a lot of that came after contact. Fahey wasn’t close to perfect and finished the game 21-for-32, but completions to Smith and short-yardage routes or runs busted for bigger gains allowed OSU’s offense to dominate.
Rushing attack
It seems to be all or nothing for this Northwestern rushing attack. Some days Caleb Komolafe and Himon seem like one of the best rushing duos in the country, and other days they are barely heard from.
Today was the latter. NU rushed for 53 yards on the day, failing to break off any long runs to put the Ohio State defense on its heels. The ‘Cats averaged 1.8 per attempt as the offensive line couldn’t consistently create holes and, when they did, the running backs couldn’t find them. The Buckeyes’ defense has struggled mightily this season, yet NU’s ground game still couldn’t generate any momentum.
It was Northwestern’s second time this season failing to surpass 100 yards via the ground – its 32 yards in a losing effort at Indiana being the other – as the only chance of moving the ball was Marchiol’s left arm.
Due to the lack of creativity from his backfield mates, Marchiol was forced into several short-yardage runs, which didn’t help the rushing numbers either. Marchiol has a tendency to get happy feet in the pocket and lunge forward for two or three yards; it’s better than a sack but puts Northwestern behind schedule and leads to third-and-longs.
Northwestern’s dreamy season
Northwestern’s 2026 season was supposed to be the stuff of fairytales. It was supposed to be a season of shattered records, historic achievements and a long-awaited emergence on a national scale.
And, for most of the season, it was.
The debut of the new Ryan Field. The additions of Aidan Chiles and Chip Kelly. David Braun’s ascendancy as an inspiring face of the program. A 6-1 start leading to a top-20 ranking in the AP Poll and thoughts of making the College Football Playoff.
Through seven games, Evanston was a vibrant and ecstatic college football town.
However, that’s all changed. The sudden cold weather has pushed Northwestern students back into the dark halls of the library as the ‘Cats’ spark seems to be gone. After its loss to Ohio State, NU has dropped three in a row and. At 6-4, its playoff aspirations of just three weeks ago seem like a fever dream.
While a lot of the losing coincides with the absence of Chiles, one injury doesn’t alter the story of the season. With games against Minnesota and Illinois left on the schedule, the ‘Cats would be lucky to win one and tumble into the postseason at 7-5.
So, I must ask, did things really change? Did the ‘Cats close the gap with the top of the Big Ten? Is the new Northwestern any different than the old?
Head coach David Braun remains confident that the Northwestern football program has changed. He said it’s a group with unquestionable resolve at the postgame press conference.
The ‘Cats have two regular season games and a bowl game left to prove Braun right.













