Welcome to our series grading every member of the San Diego Padres’ 40-man roster. The roster being evaluated is current as of Oct. 18, prior to the end of the World Series. Because of that, it will include players who will be free agents once the postseason concludes. Each player will be graded on their performance in the 2026 season, including the playoffs. That performance will be weighted based on how much time the player spent with the team (availability is the best ability).
Nick Pivetta
When the Padres
signed Pivetta heading into the 2025 season, he was the last solid starting pitcher left on the free agent market. No other reliable options remained. San Diego signed him to a backloaded deal in order to maintain payroll flexibility. Pivetta turned in the best season of his career, earning some down-ballot Cy Young votes. He was expected to anchor the rotation alongside Michael King in 2026.
Overall Grade: C-
Things didn’t go according to plan. Pivetta made just four starts before hitting the injured list and remaining there for almost five months. He exited a start against the Colorado Rockies early and was later diagnosed with flexor strain in his throwing elbow. He ended up making just eight starts in total for the Friars due to several setbacks during his rehab assignments.
But, when he was on the mound, it was a thing of beauty. Pivetta pitched to a 2.86 ERA in those eight starts (34.2 IP). He was even better after returning from the IL, posting a 1.45 ERA in the month of September. His overall ERA was only so high due to a rough Opening Day performance (6 ER, 3.0 IP). Removing that first outing, Pivetta holds a 1.42 ERA across 31 2/3 innings of work.
He just didn’t pitch enough. The injury concerns led the Padres to decline his $14 million club option for the 2027 season. Reportedly, the two sides are still seeking a reunion. Had the Friars picked up Pivetta’s 2027 club option, he would have acquired an $18 million player option for 2028. San Diego probably didn’t want to be on the hook for that much if Pivetta’s arm gave out a second year in a row.













