As Broncos fans, in our lifetime, we’ve had the absolute privilege of watching some of the best quarterbacks in football play for the Denver Broncos… and the frustration of having to watch the not-so-great struggle. Needless to say, Broncos fans know how to measure quarterback play, both good and bad, when they see it.
That’s what’s so frustrating about the Bo Nix debate that has emerged this season. How could someone be ‘an insult to the quarterback position’ while simultaneously willing his team
to victory every single week, breaking and setting records in the process? With the bye week nearly behind Broncos Country, it’s time to take an in-depth at just who Bo Nix is through the lens of Broncos quarterbacks past, the good, the bad, and the universally disliked.
John Elway represents the gold standard for quarterback play in Denver. If you need explanation of how fundamentally important he was to the Denver Broncos, I question your Broncos Country citizenship (but welcome you anyway).
The best part of Bo Nix just so happens to be the best of John Elway. They both share that ‘never-say-die’, ‘they ain’t licked us yet’, ‘we got them right where we want them’ mentality once the 4th quarter starts. It doesn’t matter what the score is. Call it Mile High Magic, persistence, dedication, or whatever you wish, but when the 4th quarter begins, fans know that the Broncos are never out of it so long as these special quarterbacks were/are under center.
It’s hard to come up with a negative for the eternal face of the franchise, but there is one. At the time of his retirement, John Elway had thrown 226 interceptions – bringing him in all-time at 11th in NFL history (currently 17th all time). Bo Nix is different from Elway in that he does a better job of protecting the football. Throughout his young 43-game career, Nix has thrown just 27-interceptions compared to Elway’s 52 over the same number of games. Sure, Nix may throw passes 2 or 3-yards shorter than other quarterbacks, but he he just doesn’t throw the interceptions others do. No fan needs to be told how important limiting turnovers are, so no fan should need to be told how central Bo Nix’s ball control has been to the Broncos recent success.
Jake Plummer was the first real spark of hope in the post-Elway era. Sure, Brian Griese had his moments, but not only did Griese never win a playoff game, he never played in one. Plummer was a fan favorite for his explosive plays, crazy beard, and unpredictability that stacked enough wins to go deep into the AFC playoff race during the 2005 season.
Like Plummer, Bo Nix was the breath of fresh air after a long period of less-than-stellar Broncos football. Coming after the likes of Gus Ferrotte, Steve Beuerlein, Jarious Jackson, and Bradlee Van Pelt, Broncos Country embraced the confident (and successful!) quarterback that arrived as a free agent from Arizona. Here are two quarterbacks that had/have a deep understanding of what their arrival meant to the Broncos and the city of Denver as a whole. They have both risen to the occasion and grew into leaders that took their teams to AFC Championship games.
Because Nix was drafted by the Broncos and not an unrestricted free agent acquisition like Plummer was, Nix benefits from a total franchise buy-in at least for another year (and likely longer). After losing the AFC Championship game in the 2005 season to the Pittsburgh Steelers, coach Mike Shanahan drafted Jay Cutler. Following a miraculous season, Denver suddenly had the supposed ‘quarterback of the future,’ on the bench and it was a fatal blow to Plummer’s security and confidence. Throughout the Bo Nix media saga this year, there has been nothing but unwavering support from inside the Broncos facility. No murmurs. No whispers. No attempts to find someone better. Why would there be? All he does is win. Who knows what the future holds, but it’s hard to not believe in a quarterback who consistently stacks wins like Bo Nix.
Jay Cutler is a _________. You fill in the blank. It’s no secret that Broncos Country has intense feelings about him that are anything but positive.
Like Jay Cutler, Bo Nix was one of the few Broncos quarterbacks actually drafted by the franchise. Although Cutler didn’t start until the inaugural Thursday Night Football game in 2006 (then on NFL Network), hopes for both quarterbacks’ careers were at the franchise’s highest when they debuted. They both could extend plays with their feet, generate highlight reel passes for touchdowns, and generally invigorated the franchise with the promise of youthful energy.
Bo Nix is not like Jay Cutler in that he’s a likable, mature, quarterback who clearly has a desire to win above all else. Cutler, quite frankly, had none of those qualities. His body language would tell anyone all they needed to know about how things were going in Cutler’s head. In the face of adversity, Cutler would pout and mentally check-out when things got tough. When former coach and documented cheater Josh McDaniels took over in 2009, it was the threat of (checks notes) QB Matt Cassell that sent him into a full-blown tantrum, tailspinning him in a trade to the Chicago Bears. Bo Nix has thrown no tantrums. When things are tough, he locks in and, more often than not, finds a way to win. He has the maturity and drive that Jay Cutler never had and, sadly, never will.
Peyton Manning is the only quarterback that could ever, or likely will ever, challenge Denver’s devotion to John Elway. In 2013, early in his Broncos career, Manning set records for single-season passing touchdowns (55), single-season passing yards (5,477), single-season passing yards per game (342.3), tied the single-game passing touchdowns record (7), total touchdowns in a season (56), and more.
Like Manning, Bo Nix has had his fair share of records set, bested, or broken. Nix has the highest single-game completion percentage by a rookie (89.7%), most home passing touchdowns by a rookie (19), most games with 2+ passing TDs and 0 interceptions as a rookie (7), most games with 300+ passing yards, 4+ passing TDs, and a 140.0+ passer rating by a rookie (2). As for Denver Broncos franchise records, Nix stands alone with the longest rushing touchdown by a quarterback (62-yards), most passing yards by a rookie (3,775), most passing touchdowns by a rookie (29), most completions by a rookie (376), and most wins by a starting rookie QB (10). Before the bye, in the Broncos week 9 victory over the Carolina Panthers, Nix’s Broncos set the record for most consecutive 1-score games in NFL history (16).
Unlike Peyton Manning’s time in Denver, Bo Nix has the benefit of youth on his side. The tragedy of the Peyton Manning era, that he didn’t get to Denver sooner. He toiled with the Colts for 14-season before landing in Denver and so, sadly, age and then injury caught up with Peyton after that record-shattering 2013 season. During his final year, the Super Bowl 50 2015 season, Manning missed 6-games to injury. As for Bo Nix, he’s never missed a regular season game due to injury and has only missed that one, crucial AFC Championship start to end last season.
While it seems like everyone has been micro-analysing Bo Nix’s performances this season for reasons why he’s not ‘it,’ most people have overlooked the wealth of evidence that he is ‘it.’ Every quarterback that has strapped on the orange and blue has had their talents and their flaws. Never before has there been this level of scrutiny on a Broncos quarterback who has had so much success, especially coming off a decade of embarrassingly awful football in Denver. I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again, don’t be so focused on identifying what Bo Nix isn’t that you miss all that he is. When you look at him through the lens of quarterbacks past, it’s hard to see anything more than a passionate quarterback who can will his team to victory, no matter how stacked the odds are against the Broncos. As Broncos fans, we are tremendously lucky to have him.













