Carson Kelly, who’s been very good behind the plate for the Cubs the last two years, is a free agent.
So the Cubs need another catcher to pair with Miguel Amaya.
Personally, I’d just take Kelly back for another year, maybe sign him to a deal with an option for 2028/buyout clause.
If Kelly won’t go for that, I think the Cubs need to examine the FA market, because the team’s top catching prospect, Owen Ayers, has played only 33 games at catcher above Double-A and likely needs some more Triple-A experience
before joining the Cubs full-time.
So let’s look at Ryan Jeffers, another free-agent catcher. Jeffers was the Twins’ second-round pick in 2018 out of UNC-Wilmington and has spent his entire seven-year MLB career with Minnesota. In 2026, he put up pretty good offensive numbers, batting .256/.353/.461 with 14 home runs in 92 games. The missed games were due to a hamate bone fracture in his left hand. Those injuries can occasionally sap a player’s hitting ability, and Jeffers’ numbers did go down from .295/.408/.541 in 37 games pre-injury to .231/.317/.410 in 55 games after his return. The pre-injury numbers were a bit of an outlier compared to previous years so I’d say Jeffers’ overall slash line of .242/.327/.426 is probably more representative of what he’ll hit going forward.
Jeffers is about league average in throwing out runners, and won 62 percent of ABS challenges — but didn’t make many, just 13, winning eight of them. He turns 30 in June, so he’s about three years younger than Kelly.
MLB Trade Rumors projects Jeffers at four years, $75 million and The Athletic has him at three years, $45 million. I think the latter is more realistic for a catcher of Jeffers’ age and abilities. Personally, though, I’d rather have Carson Kelly back. This article in The Athletic says the Twins have “genuine interest” in a reunion with Jeffers.
What do you think?













