Tonight, we will discover if the Guardians will tender Matt Festa a contract. Should they do so, based on his 2026 season?
Festa was good, actually, in 2025. He had a 3.14 FIP and a 9.22/2.47 K/BB/9. In 2026, Festa had a 3.61 FIP and a 9.32/2.84 K/BB/9. So, Festa is, actually, still a solid middle relief options. Well… maybe. In September, Festa had a 4.60 FIP and a 6.75/4.82 K/BB/9 in September and his strikeout rate declined and walk rate increased throughout the year. Was that random reliever volatility
or was it a sign of the decline mid-30’s relievers often experience?
Festa’s four-seamer averaged 0.6 mph more than in 2025 and it, his sweeper and his cutter remain above average pitches by Stuff+. However, his groundball rate declined by about 5% and it went to his flyball rate which increased by about 5%. That difference and the run-value decline on his sweeper would be where I would focus in were I the Guardians. Can Festa reliably get back to using his sweeper as an out pitch? Can be assumed to get back to a groundball rate close to 40%? If the answer to these questions is “no”, then he probably doesn’t get tendered a contract tonight. If the answer is “yes”, then I don’t see any reason not to keep him as a 5th-6th inning option for the time being. For what it is worth, Baseball Savant has Festa’s sweeper as better in vertical and horizontal break in 2026 than it was in 2025, so the poor results may be more bad luck than anything else, leading me to think he’ll be tendered.
Stephen Vogt seemed very reluctant to use Matt Festa in the playoffs after his rocky September. Was that a sign of a growing doubt in the player or a temporary blip in the usage of a guy who has kind of been Vogt’ version of Terry Francona’s Bryan Shaw? We will find out at 5PM today.













