One of the big needs for the 2027 Baltimore Orioles is starting pitching. They need two pitchers to round out their starting rotation, which currently consists of Kyle Bradish, Shane Baz, and Brandon Young. Their starting pitching wasn’t the worst thing about the 2026 team, but the potential loss of Trevor Rogers would be huge.
One possibility to fill a spot is right-handed pitcher Nick Pivetta. Pivetta, who turns 34 years old on Valentine’s Day, is coming off of two seasons with the San Diego Padres,
after five seasons with the Boston Red Sox.
Pivetta was disappointing in his time with the Red Sox. He had good strikeout numbers, decent fastball velocity, and good peripheral stats. But he struggled with walks and home runs and never got his ERA out of the 4’s. He became a free agent after the 2024 season with a 4.29 ERA in 131 games with Boston. In five seasons, he gave up 103 home runs, which is 1.5 home runs per nine innings. That’s a lot.
Before the 2025 season, the Padres signed Pivetta to a four-year, $55 million contract. The final two years were options. The Padres declined his 2027 option a couple of weeks ago, once again making him a free agent.
The declination was not based on performance. Pivetta was fantastic with the Padres. In 2025, he made 31 starts with a 2.87 ERA. He cut down his home run total quite a bit and also got his walks under control. He just allowed fewer baserunners, period. His WHIP came in just under 1.
Then came 2026. Pivetta missed most of the season with an injury. He made four starts in March/April and four starts in September. In between, he missed five months with a flexor strain in his right elbow. That’s not great. But his results didn’t suffer after his return. In those four September starts, Pivetta allowed just three earned runs in 18.2 innings (1.45 ERA). He made two starts in the postseason, one each against the Cubs and Brewers. The Padres won both games.
There was some surprise initially when the Padres declined Pivetta’s option, but it was reported to be because the Padres were concerned about his elbow and didn’t want to commit. The reports were also that the Padres may be interested in signing him to a new deal that gives them more protection in the event the injury pops up again.
MLB Trade Rumors predicts he will get a two-year, $26 million contract. But they noted that he may end up settling for a one-year contract due to his age and injury concern.
So why is Pivetta a good option for the Orioles? First, the Orioles need to add multiple starting pitchers for next year and the free-agent pitching class isn’t especially deep. The idea of signing Pivetta to a short-term deal would go hand in hand with the Orioles acquiring another, longer-term pitcher. The Orioles can’t, or won’t, sign multiple starting pitchers to long, expensive contracts. There are just too many other investments that Orioles need to make.
If a pitcher of Pivetta’s caliber can be had for a two-year contract, it’s a risk worth taking. He pitched like a top-half-of-the-rotation pitcher with the Padres and would instantly elevate the Orioles’ rotation. And if he misses time with injury or pitches more like he did with the Red Sox, there will be fewer resources tied up in his contract. That ideally would give the Orioles flexibility to pivot to a new solution if necessary.
On top of his on-field performance, Pivetta has experience pitching for winning teams. It’s debatable how valuable that is, but with the talk about the Orioles and their team chemistry, knowing how to win, etc,. he could serve as an important veteran presence.
It seems most likely that Pivetta will return to the Padres. He found his success there and the Padres are reportedly interested in bringing him back. But nothing is done until it’s done, and it would behoove the Orioles to go after a guy like Pivetta. It would be one check box in the long list of needs the Orioles have this winter.













