Was this one of the worst results we’ve had in recent years? Probably, yes. With all due respect to Bromley, a home game against any newly promoted, badly struggling side – especially when Reading have serious ambitions of being promoted this season – should be a nailed-on Royals victory.
Was this one of the worst performances, however? Certainly not, and honestly, if we’d won this game 4-1 or 5-1, I don’t think too many people would have said that outcome was an unfair reflection on the match.
So
was this one of the unluckiest outcomes? Also no – that would be to overlook the interminably passive, dispirited way in which Reading tried to turn the game around in the final half an hour or so.
All in all then, this was a game with various, conflicting flavours. Some good, some bad and some… well, you can probably finish that yourself. Undoubtedly though the lasting taste is a particularly sour, bitter one that won’t be washed away quickly or easily.
Reading (4-2-3-1): Pereira; Godwin-Malife, Knight, O’Connor, Dorsett; Wing, Rinomhota; Kyerewaa, Earthy, Williams; Marriott
Subs: Stevens, Fraser, Savage, Stokes, Jones, Brown, Reid
The good
This was, on paper, one of the most one-sided Reading games you’ll see for quite some time (primarily based on the 58 minutes before the goal, anyway).
The Royals racked up 29 shots overall (13 on target), equating to an xG of 3.11 (via FotMob). Bromley returned four, two and 0.65 respectively. And this wasn’t just stat-padding: a lot of those Reading chances were genuinely good ones.
In the first half, Josh Knight (header) and Jack Marriott (hit from distance) had shots very well saved by Bromley ‘keeper Shamal George, who was probably Man of the Match. FotMob and WhoScored certainly thought so, giving him 9.51/10 and 9.7/10 respectively (although those scores are based on data rather than factoring in the eye test).
Also before the break, Daniel Kyerewaa put a header just wide, while Marriott flicked a finish agonisingly past the far post and also cleared the bar with a lob from far out, with the ‘keeper stranded. A sitter missed? By his lofty standards, unfortunately so.
Joining in on the action was Earthy, who was impressive all round in his return to first-team action. He failed to hit the target with a right-footed volley from inside the area and probably could have done better with a stabbed effort from a low cross that George parried wide.
That momentum continued into the start of the second half. Kyerewaa should have done better when the ball dropped for him in the area after a Randell Williams cross (not troubling the goalie with his finish), while Williams himself came close with a deflected long-range effort and Marriott had a header blocked from a Williams corner.
The issue in the first 58 minutes wasn’t Reading’s creativity. On the contrary, there were chances galore in that period: six for Marriott, one for Williams and Knight, and three a piece for Lewis Wing, Earthy and Kyerewaa.
The bad
Which brings us, of course, to what we did with those chances: nada. Zero. Zilch.
This was an especially wasteful Reading attacking display. While creating opportunities is great, that’s only one part of it – you do actually need to put the ball in the net too. And the Royals collectively fluffed their lines in front of goal today.
You’ll struggle to find many better finishers than Marriott in English football, and even though he ended the game with seven chances (we’ll come back to this number later), none of them found the net. To be fair, if anyone’s deserving of an off day in front of goal, it’s him.
But at that point we needed others to step up, rise to the importance of the situation and chip in with goals, which simply didn’t happen. As Ross pointed out in the Player Ratings, Kyerewaa ended the game with an xG of 0.92, but his xGOT (which is measured after the ball has been struck, thereby essentially quantifying the quality of the finishing – rather than the initial chance) was just 0.05.
On the one hand, it’d be tempting to say that having our best two wingers in the team (Kyreece Lisbie and Paddy Lane) would have sharpened us up in front of goal. But then again, Reading were so lacking in ruthlessness across the board today that perhaps they’d have struggled too.
There isn’t a huge amount to say about what happened down the other end, even though it did strictly speaking yield the most decisive moment of the game. Bromley managed one effort of note all game, but if you allow a dangerous low cross into your box, lose track of Adeboyejo (as Paudie O’Connor did) and present him with a glorious opportunity, no complaints can be made when it’s taken.
I’m not mad about conceding. I can also get over Reading’s profligacy before that goal was scored. What really left a sour taste in the mouth however…
The ugly
…was the response.
Even for the very best teams in the very best runs of form, things go wrong. It happens. What really counts at that point is what you do to put things right, and the inability to do that – hell, the appearance that Reading weren’t all that arsed about trying to do that in the last half an hour or so today – is what really grates.
Let’s not be naive, breaking Bromley down in this period of the game after they’d just earned a lead to protect was never going to be easy. But instead of Reading being jolted into action and upping their efforts, we saw a passive, limp display that made you wonder if the team actually believed they could score twice and win the game.
While the Royals had been able to create various quality chances in the first 58 minutes, those largely dried up when they were needed the most. I’ll return to that Marriott stat from earlier to illustrate the point: before the opener, his teammates created six chances for him. After it? Just one, in the 70th minute.
It says a lot that Reading’s own highlights include just one attempt from the Royals at 0-1 down. That chance? A long-range hit from Charlie Savage, tipped over the bar.
Yes, Earthy being withdrawn in the 62nd minute so that his game time could be managed after returning from injury was a blow for our attacking threat. He’s our best creative player in the squad, so of course losing him hurt the attack.
But that still left Savage (his replacement), Marriott, Williams, Wing and Jacob Brown (who came on for Kyerewaa) on the pitch for at least the final 20 minutes. Which of those players made it clear to the fans watching that they were willing and able to take responsibility for turning the game around? None, to my mind. That’s not to say they don’t want to win – of course they do – but actions and output are what count the most.
This shouldn’t excuse Leam Richardson, who must take blame on a couple of fronts.
In the bigger picture, it’s a worrying mark against him that the way the game played out late on was far from unfamiliar. Reading have generally struggled to take points from losing positions this season (three against Barnsley, one against Bradford City) and matches fizzling out with a whimper has too much precedent: most prominently when losing to a relegation-battling side (Wigan Athletic) and when 2-0 down in a local derby.
And today, his interventions from the bench weren’t good enough.
Withdrawing Earthy can’t be faulted in the circumstances, but not opting for a specialist number 10 as his replacement can be. And why Richardson waited until the 86th minute for his final roll of the dice, swapping Jamie Reid and Jerae Jones on for Andy Rinomhota and Jeriel Dorsett, I do not know.
(To be fair, taking Kyerewaa off for Brown in a straight swap on the right wing made sense.)
So then, freak result or not?
It depends on which part of the game you focus on. Based on the first 58 minutes, Reading created more than enough to win the game comfortably, let alone narrowly. On another day (one of the most bittersweet phrases in football analysis), the Royals break the deadlock first and then kick on to seal the points at a canter.
But it’s hard to put this down entirely as a freak result when Reading’s flaws were so recognisable. This isn’t the first time this season we’ve seen the Royals concede from a cross and then lose its attacking oomph and desire late on, and I fear it won’t be the last either.
Especially when the manager’s post-match comments miss the mark. Richardson said he “can’t question the lads’ effort, desire, intent with the performance” – but that was exactly the glaring issue in the latter stages of the game today.
Reading do at least now have a clear week on the training ground to make improvements before next Saturday’s trip to Sheffield Wednesday. Top of the priority list has to be working on finishing and addressing the inability to respond to going behind.













