The results are in from the latest SB Nation Reacts poll, which launched on March 25th, the doomed Opening Night. Regardless of that game and the one that followed, San Francisco Giants fans remain bullish about the teams chances going forward.
Well, okay, maybe not bullish. Positive. 55% of the vote went away from 86 or more wins, but the overwhelming majority of voters predict the team will wind up better than .500 or thereabouts: 82%, unless you also want to include that 80-82 range since, technically,
82 wins is above .500. That would mean basically all respondents think the Giants are likely to have a winning season.
That’s important (to me, anyway), because the most important story of this 2026 season (again, to me, anyway) is that never in the franchise history have they gone more than four years without a winning season. When I wrote about this last week, commenters were quick to point out that a .500 season isn’t a losing season, and so by that measure, the Giants aren’t in any danger of breaking this streak.
While I concede that saying “the team has never had five consecutive losing seasons” is improper wording for the point I was trying to make, the point I was trying to make remains valid. The Giants have been very successful throughout their history. They’re in danger of hitting an historic low point with another bad season. Fans, probably by virtue of rooting for a team that has never had more than four consecutive non-winning seasons in their lifetimes, are understandably hopeful about the team’s chances this year.
But given how the first series of the season went, it’s tough to see right now how this squad gets to a win tally that starts with an 8 (or better). Not only does it look like Tony Vitello needs to be quicker with pitching changes and pinch hitting decisions, but their upcoming schedule is daunting:
@ Padres (3) — Padres haven’t lost the season series to the Giants since 2021. Giants are 10-19 in Petco since 2022
Home vs. Mets (4) — supposed to be challenging for the NL East
Home vs. Phillies (3) — also an NL East challenger, always a tough team
@ Baltimore (3) — improved pitching, scary lineup that now features Giants killer Pete Alonso (13 HR and an .872 OPS in 39 career games against)
@ Cincinnati (3) — good pitching, scary lineup, and always a tough sereies
@ Washington (3) — This one might not be too difficult
Home vs. Dodgers (3) — Dodgers are 18-10 at Oracle Park since 2022
Home vs. Marlins (3) — Marlins Death Fog
@ Phillies (3)
@ Rays (3)
Home vs. Padres (4) — San Diego is 19-10 at Oracle since 2022
Home vs. Pirates (3) — Pittsburgh has won the series in SF in 2 of the last 4 seasons
@ Dodgers (4) — Giants 8-22 in LA since 2022
@ Athletics (3) — No guarantee this will be easy
@ Diamondbacks (3) — Giants 10-18 in AZ since 2022 (two series wins)
A fresh off the quad manager coupled with a group of veteran hitters still trying to get their timing down is a tough combination to start the season and it’s already an uphill battle. On the other hand, if Baseball is Baseball no matter who’s managing the team or whatever philosophy is driving Baseball Operations, then, yeah, you’re going to probably want to bet on circumstances leveling out over the season. This might be as bad as the team looks all season.
The other part of this week’s polling was about… ahem… the, um, the… the Dodgers. Everyone’s favorite topic, I know. SB Nation Reacts had a two-part question about them:
Nearly 1/3 of respondents think the Dodgers have a three-peat in them, but the good news is that the majority of fans who participate in the voting do not. For these fans, the Dodgers still might go very far, though, given the responses to the other question:
Do three American League teams on this list indicate a belief that the Dodgers will still win the NL pennant or is the voting body composed more of American League fans? Specifically, Jays, Mariners, and Yankees fans? The Jays and Yankees already took their shots and missed. The Mariners getting to the World Series sure would be something, though.
By the way, if you’re interested in being a survey participant, you can sign up for SB Nation Reacts polls here.
