Tyler Tolbert is one of the more fascinating Royals of the last couple of years. I say that because I think he is one of the more polarizing players on the team.
I don’t say that to demean Tolbert, I think he’s a wonderful teammate and person from everything I’ve ever seen. It has to be hard prepping to play seven different positions, (yes that includes pitching), while also trying to constantly stay ready to pinch-run late in games. Toss in trying to scout opposing pitchers’ moves and timing to the
plate and all that. Maybe Tolbert has one of the hardest jobs on the team, oh and throw in that he might get a start or a two a week depending on how Matt Quatraro feels and he might have to prep staying ready to hit.
That being said, Tolbert will be 29 years old by the start of the season. He was drafted by the Royals in the 13th round of the 2019 draft out of the University of Alabama-Birmingham. For reference, he was the only 13th round pick from that draft that played in the Majors last season. So, I’d say that the Royals got good value on that investment.
In 142 career games, Tolbert is a 0.6 WAR player, with 43 stolen bases, while slashing .283/.340/.389. Granted that’s only 180 career at bats, but that’s not too shabby for a guy that might bat once every 8-10 days against live action. Tolbert has only been caught stealing six times in his career. The issue is he was picked off three times this season. That doesn’t seem like a lot necessarily, but you factor in that usually it’s when the game is tied or the Royals were down one, it was a massive out. Personally, I think that is the biggest knock against Tolbert. Otherwise he’s a rather solid utility player.
This past season, Tolbert played seven different positions, the only positions he didn’t play were first base and catcher. He made five relief appearances as a pitcher, throwing 4.2 innings, allowing 17 hits, 13 runs, 4 homers, 3 walks with no strikeouts. For what it’s worth, Tolbert was a 0.3 WAR player last season, if you take out the -0.4 from his pitching, he was a 0.7 WAR player this past season, making his career WAR number, 1.
At the plate, Tolbert had 130 at bats, hitting .285/.347/.392, 3 homers, 12 walks, and 22 stolen bases. He also tied an MLB record, recording 12 straight at bats with a hit. He recorded back-to-back five-hit games in that span, the first player since Roberto Clemente to accomplish that feat.
Outside of that, he had some clutch moments at the plate as well, like this game-tying single against the Athletics in August.
Defensively, he only made three errors this season, which is honestly somewhat impressive for a guy that played seven different positions. He was great in the outfield and at third base but had an error at second and a pair of them at shortstop. His fielding run value on Baseball Savant is a -1, while his Outs Above Average was +1. He doesn’t rate as having great arm strength, but I’m not sure how that factors outfield versus infield numbers. I think he’s a solid utility defender for the whole diamond, not great, but not bad. He had a pair of great plays that stick out in my mind though.
I think Tyler Tolbert is a valuable utility and bench player for the Kansas City Royals. I think he deserves more of a chance to prove himself, because in the small looks, we’ve gotten, he looks like an above average ballplayer.
How would you grade Tyler Tolbert’s 2026 season?













