David Bednar accepted the Yankees’ qualifying offer on Tuesday, as first reported by The Athletic’s Tyler Kepner. The deal reunites the Yankees with their lockdown closer on a one-year, $23.15 million deal.
Bednar has excelled during his year and a half in pinstripes, posting a 2.39 ERA along with 45 saves in 52 opportunities across 86 appearances. His 2.7 fWAR ranked eight-best among all relievers during that period. Before joining New York, Bednar made two All-Star teams as Pittsburgh’s closer.
The veteran turned 32 last month.
The qualifying offer is a collectively bargained tool to support teams losing high-value players to free agency, allowing them to extend a one-year deal equivalent to the mean salary of MLB’s 125 highest-paid players to certain impending free agents. Had Bednar declined the offer, whichever team signed him would have forfeited a combination of draft picks and/or international bonus pool money based on their previous year’s payroll. The team losing their qualified player in free agency receives an additional draft pick as well; given the fact that the Yankees exceeded the competitive balance tax threshold, they would have received a pick after the fourth round.
With Bednar returning to the Bronx, none of these implications will come into play. Instead, alongside Twins catcher Ryan Jeffers, he becomes the 19th player and first reliever (not counting swingman Nick Martinez) to accept the qualifying offer. Critically, a player can only receive a qualifying offer once in their career, meaning Bednar’s services would not be tied to draft pick or international bonus pool compensation should he hit free agency again after the 2027 season. It’s unclear if the Yankees would entertain an extension before that point or whether they will be content to let Bednar play out his new, one-year deal. If he keeps his current deal, Bednar will certainly be among the game’s highest-paid relievers on a per-year basis; the most richly rewarded bullpen arm in baseball, Edwin Díaz, is making an average of $23 million annually over the course of his three-year deal with LA.
The re-signing represents a coup for a team desperate to rebuild its late-inning formula. Yankees GM Brian Cashman identified augmenting the team’s bullpen as “our main priority” after last week’s GM Meetings in Las Vegas. In addition to Bednar, Paul Blackburn, Tim Hill, Ryan Yarbrough, John Schreiber, and Michael Fulmer all became free agents at season’s end, while the 36-year-old Fernando Cruz is a non-tender candidate as he continues to deal with a partially torn ulnar collateral ligament. Cashman brought Hill back into the fold with a one-year contract of his own on Sunday (albeit at a much more manageable $2.25 million price tag). Blackburn remains a likely target, as does lefty Adrian Morejon, who declined a qualifying offer from the Padres on Tuesday.













