Just wow, man.
Monday was about as brutal as it can get for a high-major college basketball program.
The Wildcats were embarrassed on their home floor in a 75-53 loss to Columbia, marking the program’s first loss of 20 or more points to a mid-major since 1999, when NU fell 48-26 to Evansville.
It also marked Northwestern’s second straight loss to a non-conference opponent, following the ‘Cats’ 67-47 loss to DePaul on Friday.
After such a rattling loss, where do the Wildcats stand?
Kussh Mital and Benjamin
Levy have put their heads together to provide five takeaways from Northwestern’s historic defeat.
Collins is on the hot seat
Head coach Chris Collins is a program legend. He is the second-winningest coach in Northwestern history with a record of 212-209. He has led Northwestern to three appearances in the NCAA Tournament, including the program’s first, in 2017. Northwestern finished tied for second in the Big Ten in the 2022-23 season, which earned Collins Big Ten Coach of the Year and the Jim Phelan National Coach of the Year Award.
He’s coached multiple talents in his time, including the program’s all-time leading scorer, Boo Buie. Northwestern had back-to-back NBA Draft picks for the first time, with Brooks Barnhizer and Nick Martinelli being drafted in 2025 and 2026, respectively. He even received a contract extension in April 2025 that has him tied to the program through 2030.
A loss to Columbia is inexcusable. Having nine players leave in the transfer portal this offseason is inexcusable. Not making the NCAA tournament in the last two seasons with the talent on the roster is inexcusable.
Players who didn’t have much success under Collins left and found it elsewhere, such as Jayden Reid, who is now averaging 23.2 points and 5.5 assists per game for a Memphis team that has wins over Iowa State and Louisville. Utilizing and retaining this talent is necessary for a team to succeed.
Sure, Collins convinced Jake West to stay and recruited Jayden Hodge and Jeremiah Profit, but what is keeping them in Evanston if the losing continues? The answer is nothing. The era of Collins building rosters based on longevity and continuity is no longer viable. The inability to keep talent or to evaluate players who could contribute at a high level hurts the program.
It is obvious the university needs to invest more in the basketball program as it has with the football team, but that cannot be an excuse for a loss to an Ivy League school that doesn’t even give out athletic scholarships.
Collins has to be better at getting the most out of his roster, keeping and finding players in the portal and consistently finding success. Otherwise, fans could start chanting for a new head coach. – Kussh Mital
This team has a depth problem
Columbia’s defensive game plan was simple: make anyone but West score. On ball screens, the Lions blitzed and trapped West, daring someone else to beat them offensively.
Using this strategy, Columbia shut down West, holding him to just nine points on 4-for-12 shooting after he’d scored 20 or more in every other game. It also limited his playmaking. West had just four assists in the game, well below his average of 6.75 coming in.
In the first four games of the season, the offense went through West and was fairly successful. But with West neutralized, the Wildcats needed to find someone else to pick up the slack. They couldn’t.
Northwestern averaged 14.5 assists per game to start the season. Against Columbia, it had eight. Jack Karasinski got several open looks from three but missed them. West will continue to get double-teamed and shut down by good defenses across the country, and without someone who can help out offensively, this offense will keep stalling. – Benjamin Levy
The transfers need to step up
Northwestern’s transfers haven’t solved the depth problem.
I have been holding out hope throughout the first five games that just one of the incoming transfers would show promise. After these last two losses, however, I am concerned that Northwestern went 0-for-8 in the transfer portal.
For a second, I thought guard LA Pratt would make an immediate impact, but he has struggled lately. Against DePaul, he scored 10 points on 5-for-13 shooting. He shot better from the field against Columbia (3-for-5) but took just five shots and scored seven points.
Karasinski was inefficient against Columbia, shooting 3-for-14 from the field and 1-for-8 from deep. Okku Federiko has been put in an unfair position, having to play as an undersized center with Luke McEldon and Ryan Soulis both out indefinitely. He grabbed a season-high nine rebounds against Columbia, but he recorded just one block.
Reserve forwards Colin Smith and Aleksej Kostic were brought in as shooters. Both shot over 36% from three-point range last season, including Smith over 40%. But this season, Smith is shooting 33% from deep, and Kostic is 0-for-7 from three.
The transfers need time to adjust, and I hope they prove my concerns wrong, but right now they need to start producing. – Kussh Mital
Single-digit wins are possible
It may sound crazy, but this Northwestern team has to play every game as if the season were over with a loss.
Using last season’s NET rankings, Northwestern has just three Quad 4 games left in its non-conference schedule: Northeastern, Mercyhurst and Chicago State. Even if the ‘Cats take these three games, which is not a given, that’s six wins. Now, do I believe that Northwestern can squeeze out four more wins? Yes. Yes, I do. Am I confident about that? No. No, I am not.
With non-conference games against Virginia Tech, Dayton, BYU and Oklahoma State, I struggle to see the Wildcats winning any of these matchups. The difficulty of the Big Ten is well known too. Matchups against Michigan, Illinois, Michigan State, USC, UCLA and Nebraska are all likely losses. Many other games against teams like Purdue, Washington, Minnesota, Wisconsin, Ohio State and Indiana are unlikely to be competitive. This leaves few places for Northwestern to find wins.
Iowa is off to a slow start, but I’m confident it will turn things around and beat the ‘Cats comfortably. Maryland appears to have returned to form after a disappointing last season, taking No. 4 Virginia to the wire in an 87-83 loss, so I don’t expect a Northwestern upset there either.
That leaves Rutgers, Oregon and Penn State. If the ‘Cats win those three, that’s nine wins, although those games aren’t guarantees. Of course, nothing is a given in college basketball. If the Columbia game is evidence of anything, it’s that upsets happen. For that reason, the possibility that Northwestern finishes the season with nine or fewer wins is just as possible as it isn’t. – Kussh Mital
It is still early
The good news for this team is that the season is still young.
This Northwestern team has played just seven games together (including exhibitions), so it may take more time for a team with only three returners to find its footing. That’s the point of the non-conference schedule. The ‘Cats have two weeks and three non-conference games before their Big Ten opener to build chemistry and learn how to respond when West gets double-teamed.
If Northwestern’s coaching staff can use this time wisely, this team can improve quite a bit before it plays Wisconsin on Dec. 1. – Benjamin Levy













