When Ryan McMahon jammed his left thumb sliding into second base on Wednesday night, the Yankees seemed hopeful that the third baseman would be able to avoid the injured list. Alas, it seems that the team has decided to use an abundance of caution: prior to tonight’s game, the Bombers announced that they had placed McMahon on the 10-day injured list with a left thumb sprain, recalling Max Schuemann from Triple-A Scranton to take his spot on the roster.
Ahead of yesterday’s game, reports indicated
that initial X-rays had come back clean, although McMahon — who had injured the thumb in the second inning, but remained in the game until the eighth — indicated that it was “still sore” and remained “swollen.” He was set to undergo additional imaging upon the team’s return to New York today, and clearly, that didn’t go quite as well as hoped.
With McMahon on the shelf, the Yankees have a number of options to man the hot corner, none of which are particularly exciting. The recently-recalled Schuemann has not played well in 40 games in the Majors so far this season, slashing just .194/.333/.361 slash line (94 OPS+) accruing -0.4 rWAR; against lefties, though, he has a .211/.333/.395 line. Amed Rosario has been better at the plate, even if he has struggled against southpaws this season, but has been an absolute butcher defensively. José Caballero has had an up-and-down season at the plate, although he has been hitting well since becoming a part-time player after George Lombard Jr.’s promotion at the beginning of August, slashing .227/.393/.500 in 29 plate appearances.
Chances are, in truth, the Yankees will use a combination of the three, depending on matchups, at least for the next few days; with Cody Bellinger currently on a rehab assignment with the RailRiders, Schuemann might well be back in Scranton before too long (though Spencer Jones could also be optioned if they prefer Schuemann’s versatility).
McMahon’s injury adds to what has been a brutal season for the Bombers, who have sent a whopping 16 players to the IL, including both key minor leaguers and players who began the year on the shelf: Aaron Judge, Giancarlo Stanton, Bellinger, Jasson Domínguez, Caballero, Austin Wells, George Lombard Jr., Anthony Volpe, Gerrit Cole, Max Fried, Carlos Rodón, Clarke Schmidt, Luis Gil, Angel Chivilli, Carlos Lagrange, and Kervin Castro.
