After toiling in the Red Sox system for a few years, Chase Shugart made his major league debut in 2024. He was then traded to the Pirates for whom he served in a middle/long relief role in 2025 and was generally decent at it. The Phillies must have liked what they saw, as they traded lottery ticket minor leaguer Francisco Loreto to Pittsburgh to obtain Shugart.
He didn’t make the major league team out of Spring Training but was called up in April and spent most of the season on the roster, appearing
mostly in low-leverage situations.
The stats: 46 games, 53.1 IP, 2-1 W-L, 4.02 ERA, 59 K, 20 BB, 0.8 WAR
What went right
The highlight of his season came at the end of April, where he earned a win in both games of a doubleheader against the Giants. (He’s a modern-day Sam Malone, who earned the nickname “Mayday” by earning a save in both games of a doubleheaderagainst the Orioles.)
Aside from that, Shugart was mostly used to absorb innings in games that had gotten out of hand or when the Phillies needed to preserve their higher leverage relievers. He generally did an adequate job of this, with the occasional “fuel on the fire” outing mixed in.
Shugart was quietly very good in September. He had a 0.93 ERA in nine games. He did blow an extra inning save against the Braves, but it wasn’t really his fault. He gave up a routine ground ball followed by a routine fly ball, and the ghost runner scored. (This is my biggest complaint about the ghost runner. A pitcher can get two easy outs and blow a save.)
What went wrong
He wasn’t the worst pitcher the Phillies put out there, but his biggest problem is that he simply allows too many baserunners. He’s a fly ball pitcher who sees too many of those fly balls go over the fence.
The future
He will likely be back in camp next season, fighting for one of the team’s final bullpen spots. Maybe his strong finish indicates that he’s capable of taking on a bigger role next year, but considering he’s already 30, it is difficult to have much faith in that happening.
Final grade: C
He was fine for what he was.













