The 2026 Atlanta Braves had the potential to have the best catching duo in MLB this season, pairing reigning Rookie of the Year Drake Baldwin with hampered-by-injured-but-previously amazing Sean Murphy.
When healthy (2022-2023), Murphy was a top three catcher in MLB. Over the 2021-2023 period, he led all catchers in fWAR (barely edging out J.T. Realmuto despite having about 150 fewer PAs). But, injuries tanked his post-2023 career, and even when on the field, Murphy hasn’t quite looked like his healthy self.
So, there was definitely the potential for a top-flight catching situation, but Murphy would have to show substantial improvement over his 2024-2025. Did he? Not so much.
How Acquired
It feels like everyone has these facts seared on the inside of their eyelids, given how often it comes up. December 12, 2022, featured a (now incredibly maligned) three-team trade between the Brewers, Athletics, and Braves. The Braves got Murphy from the Athletics. The Athletics received Kyle Muller, Freddy Tarnok, Royber Salinas, and Manny Piña from the Braves, and Esteury Ruiz from the Brewers. The Brewers received William Contreras and Justin Yeager from the Braves, and Joel Payamps from the Athletics.
This was a blockbuster at the time. Though the kvetching has increased exponentially after 2024, there were clear reasons for the Braves and Brewers to agree to the swap as it happened, while the Athletics came away with very little. With the benefit of hindsight, Murphy’s repeated injuries have really sapped the value the Braves got from the deal, while Contreras has been a cost-controlled and highly productive catcher for the Brewers. Over the last three years, it is now Contreras that’s been a top-three (actually top two) catcher.
What were the expectations?
This was a toughie. Murphy’s prior career featured him leading all catchers in fWAR since ascending to a full-time starter role. He hit well (115 wRC+ with substantial xwOBA underperformance), and played incredible defense, with great framing and blocking to go with decent throwing.
But, after another incredible season in 2023 (nearly a .400 xwOBA, 5.0 fWAR in just 438 PAs), things fell apart. Apparently addled by a debilitating hip injury that he didn’t disclose, plus an oblique issue in 2024 and a ribcage fracture in 2025, those seasons weren’t so great for Murphy. He put up 0.9 fWAR with a 79 wRC+ as a result of a massive xwOBA underperformance in 264 PAs in 2024, and then 2.0 fWAR in 337 PAs in 2025 with a league-average batting line before calling it quits and getting the hip repair he needed.
Put those things together, and prognosticating his 2026 was a nightmare. Would he be healthy? What would his bat look like after an earlier career of hitting well, and diminished league-average-ish hitting in 2024-2025? Projection systems were still drawing in 2023 and earlier a fair bit, seeing him as a 4-WAR-per-season guy or thereabouts, albeit one kinda-sorta repeating 2025 by only playing for about half a year. ZiPS saw even more offensive upside, and was the most sanguine, bumping him up to more like 5-WAR-per-season (albeit again, only playing half time and earning 2.6 WAR).
2026 Results
In the end, despite the whole “he finally fixed his hip issue” thing, it was another lost-ish season for Murphy. A big reason for that? He somehow played even less than in 2024-2025, clocking just 121 PAs in 33 games — both were career lows for him since his debut season (where he was a September callup). The injuries were also more diversified: after missing a bunch of time with core and hip issues, Murphy spent much of the season on the shelf after fracturing his finger on a catcher’s interference (bat meet glove with unhappy ending) just eight days after he was reinstated from the Injured List from hip surgery recovery.
It wasn’t just a lack of playing time, though. While on the field, Murphy put together a by-far-career-worst 55 wRC+, and also a by-far-career-worst .273 xwOBA. He would’ve finished below replacement level if not for his catcher defense, which, to be honest, also took a step back from his elite peak, albeit in a very small sample.
In the postseason, Murphy appeared in four of the Braves’ seven games, got 12 PAs, and was one of the team’s standout offensive performers, with a 149 wRC+ (.392 wOBA, .357 xwOBA). He hit a key homer, but it wasn’t enough to yank the team out of its offensive doldrums.
What went right?
Making it back onto the diamond after all the injuries is win in and of itself, but not much else went right for Murphy. He didn’t hit in the few games before breaking his finger, and he didn’t hit after. There was one really good stretch of six games between August 26 and September 4, where he put together a 308 wRC+ and .471 xwOBA, hitting three homers in 25 PAs, but that was about it. Those were his only three homers of the regular season, and he collected nearly half of his regular-season hits (nine of 20) in those six games.
Other than that, and the fact that his blocking remained great even as his framing and throwing took a step back, there isn’t much to highlight. He was aggressive at ABS challenges, something that Drake Baldwin struggled with, but didn’t have a success rate that really made the high rate of challenging feel great.
Despite the nothingburger offensive season, Murphy found a way to be involved in some big plays, even though he was only around for like a month. On September 11, he played a huge role in one of the season’s key wins — his single to left-center, that was then bungled by the Phillies’ Derek Hill, ended up being a game-tying hit (scoring a runner all the way from first) with one out in the ninth.
Separately, his homer off Tarik Skubal in Game 1 of the NLDS was the Braves’ first run of the series, and gave them dreams of a comeback win as it halved their deficit… until the Dodgers scored three in the bottom of that inning.
As a result, Murphy finished with positive WPA in both the regular season and the playoffs, which is kind of amazing considering how bad his batting line in the regular season was.
What went wrong?
When pretty much everything is a career-worst, a lot went wrong. The only real saving grace is that a month of play and 120 PAs just isn’t much of a sample to conclude anything.
A lot of issues can be chalked up to poor contact quality — a .118 ISO was by far the worst of his career, and his .347 xwOBACON didn’t even approach league average (for the first time in his career). Part of that was him hitting more grounders and fewer fly balls than ever before — instead of pulling fly balls in the air, he pulled a bunch of grounders instead. He also chased a ton, which was a separate issue, but one that more or less doomed his batting line.
His bat speed was similar to 2025, which seems like an issue if he were playing without hip issues this year, while suffering from pain the prior year. It’s clear that Murphy’s offensive success was always predicated on taking gigantic hacks, but given that he did that way less often in 2026, it’s not clear what a path to offensive success even looks like for him at this point, unless he goes back to “old Murphy.” Some stuff about his small-sample 2026 is also outright confusing, like the fact that he moved up towards the pitcher, but also backed up off the plate a fair bit — it’s not clear what all these things, combined with diminished bat speed, are trying to accomplish.
On top of all that, the once-vaunted defense was, well, a lot less vaunted. Murphy posted below-average defensive value via the baseline Statcast metrics for the first time since his September callup in 2019. Though he also struggled with framing and throwing in a small sample in 2024, he didn’t make up for it with insane blocking performance like he did that year. Murphy has generally been an elite low-in-the-zone and across-the-body framer, but for whatever reason, he was terrible at framing low pitches in 2026, while succeeding at getting higher pitches called strikes. It’s not a large sample, but it’s something to watch.
Arguably Murphy’s worst game of the season was on August 7, his second game back after returning from the finger injury. Starting against former batterymate Max Fried at Yankee Stadium, Murphy went 0-for-4 with two strikeouts and two groundouts against his old pal and two Yankees relievers in a very close game, with the big blow being a groundout to short as the first batter in the top of the tenth; the Braves didn’t score the free runner, and lost thanks to a Tyler Kinley implosion in the bottom of the inning.
2027 Outlook
We can tell ourselves that Murphy has a track record of needing consistent playing time to do well, and he did not get it this season. That story is actually a lot more complicated than just “needing consistent playing time,” but clearly recovering from multiple injuries and then being thrown into a new catching environment didn’t help matters. Maybe we’ll see a better Murphy when he’s healthier, but he keeps getting injured, so it’s not clear whether we can bank on that.
The Braves have Murphy signed through 2028, with a team option for 2029. He looks like the backup to Drake Baldwin at this point; whereas in 2025-2026, we sometimes pontificated on how to maximize playing time and usage for both, it seems clear that the Braves will just bench Murphy at this point. That makes the consistent playing time thing harder.
As a result of his 2026, and really, his offensive collapse since 2023 — along with his inability to stay healthy — projections now have him as a 2-3-win-guy-over-a-full-season, but with the expectation that he’ll play a half-season at most — making him more of a “adds 1 WAR to team guy.” It’s up to him to prove them wrong and get back to something resembling his 2023 self. But, given his bat speed issues, the framing blip we saw in 2026, and the idea that perhaps “Murphy’s Law” describes the phenomenon where he’s always injured… there’s a long road ahead of him and the Braves.













