MLB Rumors: Dustin May and the Chicago White Sox have agreed to terms on a three year, $52.5 million deal, per multiple reports.
Right after this broke I saw Jon Tayler say “Is there another better Dustin May who was also a free agent htis winter that I wasn’t previously aware of”, and that pretty much sums up my reaction to this deal.
Now, we are dealing with the era of MLB deals where its like reacting to NFL contract announcements — in the NFL, we have to wait and see what the new and guaranteed
money is, while in MLB we have to see what deferrals, options, etc. are in play. But still, this is a hefty deal for a guy who missed most of 2021-24 due to injury issues, and who hasn’t been good the past two years when he has been healthy.
As you may recall, May burst on the scene in 2020, pitching well for the Dodgers in the truncated regular season* and drawing notice for his big time stuff and big time hair in the postseason. He then made 20 appearances from 2021-23, covering 101 innings due to 2021 Tommy John surgery and 2023 flexor tendon surgery and Tommy John revision that also cost him the 2024 season.
May was in the Dodgers rotation for much of 2025 before being traded to the Red Sox at the deadline, for whom he made five starts and a relief appearance. All told, he put up a 4.96 ERA and 4.88 FIP in 25 appearances covering 132.1 innings. He signed with the Cardinals for 2026, made 21 starts for them before being sent to Milwaukee at the deadline, and totaled a 4.70 ERA in 145.2 innings covering 31 appearances, although with a 3.63 FIP. May put up a 5.20 xERA in 2025 and a 4.45 xERA in 2026.
The projections generally had him getting one or two years in the $12-15 million per year range, about what you’d expect for a guy with average strikeout and walk rates who tends to give up loud contact but you figure can round out your rotation and maybe offer up some upside. That seems like more than I’d want to pay for Dustin May. Three years at $17.5 million, though? That’s way more.
My assumption is that the White Sox feel that they can get some improvement from May — I can’t imagine they’re paying him this thinking he’ll put up the 84-85 ERA+ he has the past two years — and that if they do, the extra years at $17.5 million will look like a bargain. And its not like they are laden with big contracts — there is no one with a guaranteed deal past 2027 on the roster, and this only pushes them to about $115 million in payroll for 2027, counting arb-eligibles and minimum salary guys.
Jon Heyman just said that this sets the market for a mid-rotation starter. Dustin May doesn’t appear to be a mid-rotation starter, and I’m skeptical that other pitchers similar to May will get this sort of money this offseason.













