No media source is without bias, but when a ticker-tape news site like MLB Trade Rumors announces your new free-agent signing as “surprising,” it might be time for a ruh-roh.
Broken by Robert Murray of FanSided and confirmed by player agent Craig Rose to the always credit-counting Jon Heyman of the New York Post, the White Sox have shoved tar into a pothole of their rotation by jumping the market to sign Dustin May to a three-year, $52.5 million deal.
May has been around forever, it seems, but is just
now entering his age-29 season. His results outside of a terrific 2020 pandemic season (10 starts, 1.5 WAR) have been … really, really bad? May is a pitcher to sign in an Erick Fedde role, for Erick Fedde money (say, a year or maybe two, $10 million?), not as (in relative White Sox terms) your ace.
Between May and Luis Castillo, the White Sox have $41 million locked into two apparent rotation arms for 2027 who combined for … -1.2 WAR in 2026.
Beyond the outrageous decision that a “small market” team plunge significant money and years into an awful pitcher — hell, even Jaime Navarro was coming off an average season for the Cubs in 1996 — it’s bizarre that lockout hawk Jerry Reinsdorf would authorize a “big” deal to a player heading into a 2027 that seems increasingly likely to see regular season games lost.
Just one year ago, May signed a one-year, $12.5 million deal with the St. Louis Cardinals that might best be depicted as a prove-it contract — and May proved nothing but the fact that he might be washed, running up just 0.6 WAR despite a solid 4.38 ERA/3.15 FIP with the Cards before being shipped to Milwaukee at the trade deadline. The righthander cratered with the Brewers, pitching to 5.65/5.06 and -0.3 WAR, finishing completely out of gas by averaging 22 pitches in his final three September starts. May was solid enough in the postseason (14 appearances in Milwaukee’s sprint to the title), but never saw more than three innings of work in a game.
In other words, on a roster with plenty of arms but little efficiency, May will fit right in.
It’s a surprisingly strong deal for May. The White Sox are placing a notable bet on the right-hander’s relative youth — he’ll pitch next season at 29 — and power arsenal, while looking past his lengthy injury history and middling bottom-line results when healthy in each of the past two seasons.
May, who made his debut in 2019 with the Los Angeles Dodgers, has been slowed by significant injuries this decade. The first was Tommy John surgery in 2021, which took him out of action from May 2021 to August 2022. The second, just as serious, was a combo platter: torn flexor tendon and esophageal tear, keeping him out for all of 2024.
To May’s credit, after averaging just 65 innings per season through 2024, since then he’s taken on what passes for a “full” load in today’s baseball, 132 ⅓ innings in 2025 and 145 ⅔ last summer.
But while the durability issues may not be as glaring today, May’s performance sure is. His performance screams fifth starter at best, and to paraphrase our staffer David James for a player with a lot of movement, it seems impossible he could be so frequently rocked:
As James also points out, May doesn’t even “know” how to pitch, in that his release point has moved every season:
Unless you’re Satchel Paige, that ain’t gonna play.
These could be good things, in that May has the movement to be an All-Star, and that the Brian Bannister “lab” may force May into a consistent release point that would seem to be a basic building block of success in the majors. On the other hand, the Brewers could not fix May, albeit amidst a furious end of season and playoff run that might have seen their coaching staff’s attentions diverted by having to figure out how to embarrass the Cubs and Dodgers on a bimonthly basis.
The best you can say about May is that he’s roughly an average starter, with upside that could push him toward the front of a rotation. For the White Sox to have plunged so much into a mediocre and historically fragile arm (let’s face it, the White Sox have just burned roughly half of their offseason spending on a No. 5 starter) indicates there’s something the staff sees that they can unlock in May.
Recent experience (see Castillo, Luis) indicates the White Sox do not have much rope left regarding their hunches.
It’s a big play, and on the surface it seems an impossibly dumb one.
Welcome to Chicago, Dustin!













