The Kansas City Royals look to enter 2026 with a much-improved outfield over the, shall we say, less-than-stellar 2025 outfit. But they could still use another bat, preferably a right-handed hitter who could be a platoon guy as there’s a drive into deep left field by Castellanos.
Kauffman Stadium has been home to a few defining moments over recent memory that only tangentially related to the team. Miguel Cabrera hit his 3,000th career hit there. Remember Trevor Bauer losing his mind and yeeting a baseball
over the fence rather than give it to Terry Francona? That was fun. It happened at Kauffman, too.
And yet Kauffman Stadium was also home to one of the weirdest and most fascinating baseball moments of the 21st century: Nick Castellanos hitting a home run off Greg Holland in the middle of Thom Brennaman apologizing for saying a slur on a hot mic earlier in the evening. In an empty stadium due to the pandemic, it is pure, hilarious performance art. And some see a connection between Castellanos home runs and other negative news incidents. I mean, how many other random home runs have a Wikipedia entry? This one does.
Castellanos had a bit of a down year in 2020 (I mean, who didn’t?) but otherwise was in the middle of a six-year stretch where he’d hit .286/.338/.515 and whack 142 home runs. That performance earned him a five-year, $100 million contract with the Philadelphia Phillies.
Well, time catches up with all of us, and Castellanos started to decline. He hit .250/.294/.400 with 17 home runs in 147 games last year, worth -0.8 rWAR. He hit just .230/.267/.367 away from Citizens Bank Ballpark. A few days ago, the Phillies released Castellanos from their service, swallowing their pride and $20 million to have the man who made it a habit of hitting home runs during somber broadcast monologues play for somewhere else.
The upshot of this all is that Castellanos can be had at the league minimum salary. As a right-handed outfield bat with some pop, it’s a low-risk move for a team like the Royals, who certainly need right-handed outfield bats with some pop. In Philadelphia, Castellanos averaged 20 homers a year and put up an even 100 OPS+. For $20 million a year? Not great. For 1/20th of that price? And considering what Kansas City had last year? Ehhhh?????
Unfortunately for Nick, he is also a Zamboni in the outfield grass. Over the last four years, Castellanos has been arguably the worst defender in Major League Baseball. In his right field home, he’s accrued -45 Statcast Fielding Run Value in right field and -41 defensive runs saved. It’s been an issue that has dogged him his whole career, but his defensive woes are accelerating as he decelerates due to age—he’ll be 34 in March. I’m 34 right now, I have certainly decelerated due to age, and the only thing I have to patrol is my basement looking for cat vomit.
There’s also this:
Ultimately, I think the Royals have improved their outfield enough that the addition of Castellanos, as fun as it would be to reminisce about that August evening in 2020 every time he plays, would not move the needle. Castellanos had an on-base percentage of .294 last year. He is, basically, Hunter Renfroe wearing one of those old-timey mustache disguises, and that’s no fun to watch for anyone.
