We had only about two and a half months with Jo Adell in Cleveland – what did we learn?
The Guardians landed Jo Adell at the trade deadline to add some needed thump to their lineup, especially against LHP. Adell ended up playing almost every day, as the Guardians elected not to give Kyle Manzardo or Cooper Ingle a second look to play DH against RHP, and, instead, chose to see what Adell could offer in a full-time role. How did it turn out? Adell was an incredible addition vs. LHP – he had a 206 wRC+
and a .358/.443/.660 slashline during the regular season which carried into the playoffs where his wRC+ was he had a 219 wRC+ vs. LHP. Adell mashes lefties and that is something the Guardians needed and continue to need. BUT Adell put up a 66 wRC+ against RHP and a .197/.273/.315 slashline with Cleveland, which carried into a 34 wRC+ and a slashline of .176/.216/.286 against RHP in the playoffs. Adell is a career 81 wRC+ against RHP and a 125 wRC+ against LHP, and this isn’t a small sample now with over 2,300 plate appearances.
I have two big questions for the Guardians and Adell as we approach tomorrow’s non-tender deadline. First, with Adell projected to receive $9 million in arbitration, are the Guardians willing to pay that much for a player who is most likely a weak-side platoon option with extreme defensive limitations? Cleveland repeatedly chose to play a (clearly) physically limited Chase DeLauter in right field over Adell in the playoffs, illustrating their lack of trust for him in the corner outfield. Second, has Cleveland seen enough to conclude that Adell is a lefty-masher who should get around 350-400 plate appearances, rather than the 660 he received between the Angels and Guardians last season? Finally, is Adell ok with this adjustment in his role?
I am a firm believer that the Guardians SHOULD bring Jo Adell back for 2027 (if a season takes place). In their incredibly left-handed hitting-heavy lineup, Adell serves an incredibly useful role. I also suspect that the $9 million figure is a litle inflated, and they’ll get him somewhere around $7-8 million. But, it is important that the team 1. admits that Adell is a platoon player, 2. has a plan to pair him with a good partner who hits from the left-side of the plate, and 3. has communicated to Adell about this plan for the upcoming season.
I have long enjoyed watching Adell and it was very fun to see him enjoy playing on a winning team and come up with some big moments:
With that said, I am thoroughly convinced that bringing him back with the anticipation of him being a full-time hitter would be a mistake. Embrace that Adell is an incredible option as a lefty-masher and utilize him in that role to the fullest extent. I suppose there is a chance that Cleveland, as a new organization for Adell, sees an adjustment he can make that he did not make in Anaheim to increase his effectiveness against RHP, but I don’t want this to be plan-A for the team as a full-time DH. Let it be plan-B and something that Adell can earn through capitalizing on limited opportunities against RHP early in the season. But, with all that said, I will be very disappointed if the Guardians non-tender Adell tomorrow; he has a very useful skill of demolishing southpaws. Keep that on hand for as long as you can swing it.













