Unlike the Yankees, who couldn’t muster enough grit after falling behind two games to none, the Guardians have scratched and clawed their way back from the brink of elimination to force Game 5. They won both games in Chicago in decisive fashion, scoring nine runs on consecutive nights to send the series back to Cleveland where the winner will take all on Saturday.
ALDS Game 4
Cleveland Guardians 9, Chicago White Sox 4
(Series tied, 2-2)
You want your stars to shine on the brightest stage, and while Aaron Judge
couldn’t recover from a calf strain in time to make the ALDS roster, José Ramírez has almost single handedly dragged his team from certain elimination to parity in the series. 2026 was by far the worst full season for the consistently excellent Ramírez. It was the first year he posted below league average production since putting up a 72 wRC+ in 97 games in 2015, his 92 wRC+ more than 40 points below the 135 mark across the last ten seasons, while his 12 home runs were his fewest since he hit 11 in 2016. One of the league standards when it comes to posting, Ramírez missed 37 games after fracturing the hamate bone in his left hand in June, and his production never recovered in the regular season.
The White Sox held him hitless in the first two games in Cleveland, but he has looked a man possessed in these last two games at Rate Field. Wednesday night, he spearheaded the Guardians’ first win of the series, going 2-for-4 with a double, a triple, a walk, two RBIs, two runs scored, and a stolen base. In Game 4, he went 2-for-5 with a home run and three RBIs to make sure his team’s season stayed alive for at least one more game.
Chicago used yet another opener and it almost backfired spectacularly, Hagen Smith walking the bases loaded in the first while recording just two outs. That forced Will Venable to call on Erick Fedde earlier than he would have liked, but the 33-year-old journeyman stranded the bases loaded and gave the White Sox 3.2 innings of two-run ball to stabilize what looked like a rapidly sinking ship.
The Guardians handed the ball to phenom rookie starter Parker Messick. The hard throwing lefty finished the year 12-9 in 32 starts, with a 2.56 ERA (161 ERA+), 3.07 FIP, and 193 strikeouts in 186.1 innings, his 4.9 fWAR trailing only Kevin McGonigle among all rookies and eighth among all qualified pitchers as he will likely finish second behind the Tigers infielder in AL Rookie of the Year voting.
Messick cruised through the first two innings before running headfirst into the White Sox’s uber-patient approach in the third. Colson Montgomery singled to lead off and advanced to third on a Chase Meidroth double. Back-to-back walks drawn by Miguel Vargas and Munetaka Murakami loaded the bases and then forced in a run to drive Messick from the game after just 2.1 innings. Reliever Shawn Armstrong immediately surrendered a sac fly to Sam Antonacci to make it a 2-0 game before retiring Brayan Rocchio to stand runners on the corners.
The Guardians responded to Chicago’s small ball with some fireworks in the fifth. Patrick Bailey crushed a pinch-hit, leadoff home run, and Steven Kwan singled with one out to end Fedde’s night. That brought J-Ram to the plate against flame-throwing reliever Jordan Hicks, and Ramírez launched an elevated 100 mph heater over the wall in right-center for the go-ahead two-run homer.
Chicago’s disciplined approach yielded an immediate response in the bottom half. Stephen Vogt opted to use starter Tanner Bibee out of the bullpen, but he lasted just three batters after walking Meidroth and Vargas. Tim Herrin’s first act out of the ‘pen was to yield a single to Murakami to load the bases. Antonacci finished second with 29 hit-by-pitches and he wore the most important one of the season to force in the game tying run. Brenton Doyle then lifted a sac fly to right to restore the White Sox lead, 4-3.
Things truly came off the rails for the Chicago in the sixth as starter Anthony Kay and reliever Grant Taylor combined to cough up six runs. Kay plunked Angel Martínez with one out, who then stole second before scoring the tying run on a Travis Bazzana double to right. Bailey then drove in the go-ahead run with a single off Taylor, and then the floodgates opened. Rocchio and Kwan drew back-to-back walks to load the bases. Ramírez hit an RBI infield single as the runners went station to station. Chase DeLauter followed with an RBI single of his own before Jo Adell blew the game open with a two-run single to make it 9-4, Cleveland.
If the White Sox do indeed become the fourth team in playoff history to squander a 2-0 lead in a best-of-five where they won the first two games on the road, then their pitching strategy is going to come under quite a bit of scrutiny. Part of it is just that they don’t have the horses and that’s why they were such an unlikely success in 2026 after three consecutive 100-loss seasons, but that’s just how it goes.
After Cleveland failed to increase their lead in the ninth stranding runners on the corners, the White Sox had one last gasp effort at a rally. Facing Cleveland’s ace closer Cade Smith (who had already pitched the eighth), Vargas led off the bottom of the ninth with a home run to cut the deficit to four. Smith then walked Murakami and allowed an Antonacci single as the White Sox had the tying run in the on-deck circle, but starter Gavin Williams entered to slam the door by retiring the next three batters to seal the Guardians victory, 9-5.
Cleveland lives to fight another day, the series returning to Progressive Field where the winner will advance to the ALCS to take on the Rays. First pitch of Game 5 is scheduled for 8:00 pm ET Saturday night. The Guardians will attempt to become the first team to rally from down 0-2 in a Division Series to win it since the 2017 Yankees did the same trick to them.
