The Phillies have been eliminated from the playoffs. I didn’t expect anyone to be happy about that, but it certainly seemed like some fans had a bit of a “I told you so” skip in their step about their failings. Even if you dislike the president of baseball operations, hoping that his moves fail is bizarre behavior. (I assure you that calling Dave Dombrowski “Dumbrowski” is extremely clever, but you don’t have to constantly remind us of how clever you are by doing it every time you talk about him.)
Obviously, the team wasn’t good enough this season, and that ultimately falls on Dombrowski’s head. But it feels like people are a little off on why they’re angry with him. The biggest criticism I’ve seen is that they took a team that failed the previous four seasons and “ran it back.”
They mostly did run it back, but that’s because they are largely locked into their core. Really, most people didn’t actually want to break up the core. Instead, they wanted to turn over much of the supporting cast like J.T. Realmuto, Bryson Stott, Alec Bohm, Brandon Marsh, Jose Alvarado, Orion Kerkering, and others.
The problem is, replacing over half the lineup and revamping almost the entire bullpen in one year isn’t really feasible. I suppose it is feasible, but the problem is that the presumption is that you’d replace those players with better players, and that’s the tricky part.
Free agency was largely a wasteland this past offseason. For example, nobody besides Realmuto’s agent liked the team giving him a third year, but he certainly looked like the best option at catcher heading into 2026. Don’t think I don’t remember the “Sign Victor Caritini and platoon him with Rafael Marchan” talk.
I know some people wish the team had signed Pete Alonso and moved Bryce Harper to right field. But after seeing Harper play right field the past two months, does anyone – including Harper – want that to be the norm over the next five years? And there’s also a strong possibility that Alonso’s five-year contract ages poorly.
The same issue existed with Luis Arraez. Arraez did have a good year defensively, but he also showed us why a multiple-time batting champion was readily available in free agency.
Next, take a look at the outfielders who were available in free agency, and you see it wasn’t a pretty picture. The big-ticket guys were Kyle Tucker and Cody Bellinger, and it seems like both of them were heart set on going to the Dodgers and Yankees respectively. You could make the case that the Phillies should have made a press to sign Bellinger instead of re-signing Kyle Schwarber and maintain some positional flexibility. But does that swap change much in the big picture?
Aside from that, the available players largely consisted of veterans like Austin Hays, Harrison Bader, and Rob Refsnyder.
Perhaps the Phillies could have been clever with trades, but they were sorely lacking in viable trade chips. Both of their top prospects – Andrew Painter and Aidan Miller – had some red flags attached, and they were already counting on both Painter and Justin Crawford to fill spots on the major league roster.
That brings us to the real problem: The farm system is not providing them with nearly enough. It would have been nice to plug in a home-grown player into one of the outfield spots and have him be a positive contributor, but instead, we got Crawford. (I know Crawford has his defenders, and this merits a separate article. But ask yourself this question: What is Crawford good at?)
Andrew McFarlane was a great addition to the bullpen, but the Phillies needed far more than just him from the farm. What we got was Gabriel Rincones, Jr., Alan Rangel, and Felix Reyes.
When Dombrowski was hired, he had two missions: Get the major league team back into the playoffs and rebuild the farm system that was a disjointed mess before his arrival. He succeeded on the first part, but it sure doesn’t look like he accomplished the second. And unless he can make progress on that front soon, his successor may soon be hired with the same directives.
