Sonny Gray signed with the Twins for a $55 million, two-year deal that includes a full no-trade clause, and allows him to opt out after the 2027 season.
Would you, were you in charge of the Braves, have done that deal?
Gray is, at this point, a highly effective elder statesman of a starter. He turned 37 earlier this month, and has been between 3-4 fWAR in each of the last three seasons, albeit with a not-unexpected decline in pitching quality (2024-2026 featured progressive xFIP-s of 70, 75, and then
89). Though in many cases, a projection’s central estimate will reflect something along an average of the last few seasons, Gray’s age is clearly being baked in to the early Steamer release we have: Gray projects for 3.0 WAR over 29 starts (the same start total he managed in 2026).
This creates a bit of a weirdness, as I talked about when I put together those big free agency under/overvalued tables. On paper, a 3-win starter should probably get more than $55 million over two years, opt-out or whatever. But, Gray’s age seems to create a kink in terms of overall expectations, such that it, in theory and in practice, scared teams away from committing what they would to a different three-year starter born a few years later. To wit, before Gray signed, his contract forecasts/guesstimates were:
- $25 million, one year, from Ben Clemens;
- $52 million, two years, from the FanGraphs crowdsource; and
- $55 million, two years (ding ding ding), from MLB Trade Rumors.
Gray clearly couldn’t leverage a third year at a similar annual rate. He did get the no-trade and the opt-out, but not that.
I think I would have made that deal without thinking too long about it. Would you?













