There’s no Packers game today, but that gives us plenty of time to crack open the history books and find some weirdness. We don’t have to look too far, either. On this date in 2020, the Packers found themselves on the wrong end of a high-flying game in Indianapolis.
The Packers rolled into Indianapolis at 7-2 but in a bit of an inconsistent funk. They’d come out of their Week 5 bye flat against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers and got slapped around, losing 38-10 in a grim foreshadowing of how their season
would end. They beat the Texans, but fell to the Vikings at home 28-20 in an odd, wind-shortened game that saw both teams split a grand total of 15 possessions including a single-play kneeldown drive to end the first half. Then they’d handled the San Francisco 49ers, but struggled with the Jacksonville Jaguars. All in all, it was a confusing five-game stretch.
It wouldn’t get better against the Colts.
The Packers turned the ball over twice in the first quarter, but the defense held off Philip Rivers (in his first Colts stint) and the Indianapolis offense long enough for Aaron Rodgers and company to find their feet in the second quarter. They reeled off three straight touchdown drives to take a 28-14 lead into halftime.
But true to form for that year, the offense bogged down in the third quarter. They went three and out twice in their only two third quarter possessions. Then, after return man Darrius Shepherd fumbled on a kickoff return early in the fourth quarter, the Packers would go on to turn the ball over on downs on their first drive of the final period.
All of that opened the door for a Colts rally. They scored three field goals and a touchdown on four straight second-half drives to take a 31-28 lead early in the fourth quarter. And then things got really weird.
Taking possession with just over eight minutes to go, the Packers navigated their way to the Colts’ 34-yard line, but decided not to play for a tie when facing a 4th-and-1 play. But Aaron Rodgers’ pass to Jamaal Williams fell incomplete, and the Colts had a golden opportunity to put the game away.
But as is so often the case, the men in stripes had different thoughts.
The Colts were flagged five times on their ensuing drive, including four holding penalties and one for illegal motion. But lest you think the refs were being one sided, the Packers were also flagged twice on the same drive, once when Preston Smith jumped offside and then, bizarrely, for having too many men on the field after the dead ball caused by Smith’s offside. At one point, there were penalties on one team or the other on five straight plays.
Eventually, the Colts’ drive bogged down and the Packers took over for one last, desperate drive on beginning on their own six-yard line. Rodgers threw incomplete on first and second down, but facing a 3rd and 10 with just over a minute to go, he launched a moon shot to Marquez Valdes-Scantling, who somehow hauled it in for a 47-yard gain. Back in business, the Packers managed to get all the way to the Colts’ eight-yard line but couldn’t find the end zone. Mason Crosby converted a 26-yard field goal to tie the game, though, and the contest headed for overtime.
The Packers won the toss, but it didn’t take long for everything to come undone. After a completion to Aaron Jones on first down, Marquez Valdes-Scantling fumbled a short pass, turning the ball over deep in Packers’ territory. Four plays later, the game was over.
Valdes-Scantling’s fumble prompted a pointed, if a bit overly dramatic, question. “How can you live with Marquez Valdes-Scantling?” asked a beat writer of Matt LaFleur. The question did little but reflect fan outrage after the costly mistake, and make no mistake, fans were incensed. MVS reported receiving death threats after his costly mistake, which is a curious reaction considering the Packers wouldn’t have even made it to overtime had he not been the one responsible for a high-difficulty catch near the end of regulation.
But nobody ever claimed being a sports fan is logical. And after a game as odd and disjointed as the one they witnessed that November day, you can at least understand why fans may have come out of it feeling a bit raw.
Still, don’t threaten players. That’s too far.













