The 2027 Baseball Hall of Fame Ballot is out, with voters getting 14 newcomers along with 13 holdovers to choose from.
Former Texas Rangers Joakim Soria and Asdrubal Cabrera are among the players who are on the ballot for the first time, along with Rangers nemesis and Ranger player brother Kyle Seager.
The other first timers are:
Jake Arrieta
Jay Bruce
Starlin Castro
Wade Davis
Brett Gardner
Jon Lester
Andrew Miller
Buster Posey
Pablo Sandoval
Ervin Santana
Ryan Zimmerman
Other than Posey, none of the first timers
seem to have a legitimate shot at getting elected, and it wouldn’t be shocking if only Posey crossed the 5% threshold to stay on the ballot past this year, although an overall weak pool of candidates could mean that guys like Lester, Soria and Gardner could stick around.
The holdover candidates, with their vote percentage from last year, are:
Chase Utley — 59.1%
Andy Pettitte — 48.5%
Felix Hernandez — 46.1%
Alex Rodriguez — 40.0%
Bobby Abreu — 30.8%
Jimmy Rollins — 25.4%
Cole Hamels — 23.8%
Dustin Pedroia — 20.7%
Mark Buehrle — 20.0%
Omar Vizquel — 18.4%
David Wright —14.8%
Francisco Rodriguez — 11.8%
Torii Hunter — 8.7%
I suspect Utley and Posey get elected this year. In terms of bWAR, Posey is 16th among catchers all time, with the only ones ahead of him not to make the Hall being Wally Schang, Gene Tenace and Thurman Munson. The bar for catchers has historically been high, and Posey’s career was relatively short, which hurts his counting numbers, but he has three rings, a Rookie of the Year Award, an MVP Award, and overall respect from the baseball community that likely means he gets in — if not this year, then next year.
Utley saw a spike in his vote percentage last year, his third on the ballot, as after jumping from 28.8% to 39.8% his first two years on the ballot, he captured 59.1% of the vote last year. I’m guessing that he gets in this year — particularly in light of how weak the overall choices are.
This is Vizquel’s last year on the ballot, and Pettitte’s next-to-last year on the ballot. Pettitte has also seen a big uptick in the past two years — after hovering in the teens in his six years on the ballot, he went to 27.9% in 2025 and 48.5% in 2026 — but his PED use likely is going to leave his ceiling below the 75% mark.
Felix Hernandez is the other candidate who I could see making a big jump this year. He went from 20.6% in 2025 to 46.1% last year. I don’t think he’ll hit the 75% threshold in this year’s vote, but it wouldn’t surprise me if he makes it in two or three years from now, which will give me the opportunity to rant again about Johan Santana dropping off after one year.













