The Silver Slugger Award is given to the best offensive player at each position in the NL and AL, and this year’saward winners were announced on Tuesday. Kyle Schwarber won his second Silver Slugger as a Phillie (and also the second of his career), beating out Shohei Ohtani in the DH category.
He becomes the third current Phillie with multiple SS awards since signing here, joining Bryce Harper (3) and J.T. Realmuto (2). Harper and Realmuto each also won once with their previous teams. Before this
current group, the last Phillie to win the award was Chase Utley in 2009. Utley won a total of 4, and the only other Phillies with multiple awards have been Mike Schmidt (6) and Manny Trillo (2):
It may be somewhat surprising that Schwarber has only won twice, but it’s worth remembering he’s been a better hitter as a Phillie (.857 OPS, 132 wRC+) than he had been previously (.836 OPS, 119 wRC+), and he has also had the misfortune of competing with some of Ohtani’s best seasons at the plate.
The other time Schwarber won the award was in 2022 as an outfielder. Calling the top vote getters “finalists” began in 2023, and he wasn’t among the outfield finalists that year. Nor was he a finalist in his first season as a DH in 2024, when both Ohtani and Marcel Ozunahad much better seasons. He hit 56 HRs in 2025 and had the best season of his career, but Ohtani was still better, with 55 HRs and much higher OPS and wRC+.
The Phillies could have easily had two winners this year. Matt Olson was voted the winner at First Base, though by any comprehensive hitting stat he was not one of the NL’s 3-4 best hitters at the position in 2026.
Jake Bauers was arguably the NL’s best-hitting first baseman, but he also played enough at multiple other positions (left and right field) to qualify as a “utility” player, a position category that was added for the award in 2022. He deservedly won a Silver Slugger award, but it was at that Utility spot.
Bauers led all NL first basemen in wRC+ (143), and OPS (.874), but since he won as a Utility player, these were the leaders among the other first basemen:
wRC+: Rafael Devers (136), Harper (135), Alec Burleson (125), TJ Rumfield (124), Olson (122)
OPS: Devers and Harper (.865), Rumfield (.843), Olson (.823), Burleson (.816)
Harper and Devers were essentially tied at the two key comprehensive stats, but Harperled all first basemen (including Bauers) in Runs Created, and Runs Above Average.
Coaching staffs saw most of the players on the ballot at most 6 or 7 times this year, so presumably they based their votes on their impressions from that handful of games, buzz about their seasons, and presumably most voters also looked up their stats at the end of the year. Assuming stats were a substantial factor in the voting, managers and coaches apparently dig the long ball, especially when it comes to First Base. Olson’s 41 HRs led all NL first basemen, 4 ahead of Devers. It also helped Olson that his best hitting was in the first half (.873 OPS and 135 wRC+), which propped up his season’s stat line and the buzz about his season even as he struggled in the second half (.751 and 102).
Olson did not deserve the Silver Slugger as the best hitter at the position — either Harper or Devers did.
To be fair, a similar argument could be made for Shohei Ohtani over Schwarber. Ohtani had the higher OPS (.889 to .857) and higher wRC+ (139 to 130).
Harper’s 2026 was only slightly better than the 2025 season that prompted Dave Dombrowski’s comments about him being “elite” — he raised his OPS from .844 to .865, and his wRC+ from 130 to 135. Both were still below his career averages of .902 and 140, though that’s not unexpected for a 33-year-old player, even a highly paid one.
Nevertheless, Harper was good enough to win the NL’s Silver Slugger Award.













