The scoreboard can often lie. On Sunday, the final between the Dallas Cowboys and San Francisco 49ers read 46-40 in favor of the visiting Niners, but anyone who watched the game knows that it was in no way that close.
It is a stretch to call Dallas’ flurry late in the game “garbage time,” but it all came when San Francisco was clearly ready to get on a plane and head home. The point is that nothing felt seriously in doubt.
You only lose games so soundly, regardless of what the scoreboard said as noted,
because of a collective failure from people involved. It should come as no surprise that our stock report is filled with more downs than ups as a result of it all.
Let’s begin.
Stock Down: Brian Schottenheimer
We say it every week. What more is there to say?
The scoreboard is a liar as noted, so it is in no way like Brian Schottenheimer had his team ready to play. What’s more is that he saw them take another third quarter off so that the game got out of hand, and then everybody started caring as time was running out in the fourth quarter.
Maybe if the Cowboys were better we’d give Schotty a pass for this being the big, bad San Francisco 49ers. But you know what? They are the big, bad 49ers. Someone has to stand up and make Dallas respectable to a team they were once proper and legitimate rivals with. Someone has to be the head coach that has a second winning streak before Thanksgiving of his second season.
Those people were not Brian Schottenheimer this week.
Stock Down: Christian Parker
It is Kyle Shanahan. We know that. But goodness.
The Dallas Cowboys defense appeared to be taking a few steps these last few weeks, but we were cautious because of the quality of opposing quarterbacks they played. It turns out that context mattered.
I’ve long been against moving on from Parker because the defense needs consistency at some point. But what is there to hang your hat on? How can you justify what is happening? In what world?
Stock Down: Caleb Downs
This was far and away Caleb Downs’ worst game as a professional. It unfortunately came a week after his best.
I guess that’s what happens when you are tasked with hanging on for dear life against George Kittle. Downs fell short of that challenge, but at least unlike the rest of his defensive teammates, he can still say he is learning all of this on the fly.
Still though, we really hyped Downs up over the offseason. We believed he was ready for this. On Sunday he wasn’t.
Stock Down: Cobie Durant
Caleb was one of two Cowboys defenders to get completely run over by San Francisco’s Kaelon Black as Cobie Durant was the other.
The Cowboys are never ready for the physical fight that is the 49ers. Never. It is a shame.
Stock Down: All linebackers
It was impossible to boil this down to just one.
San Francisco is very talented, but notably they are exceptionally well-coached. Kyle Shanahan had every Cowboys linebacker criss-crossing themselves all day with all of his uses of motion and play action.
On the second Deebo Samuel touchdown, literally 10 Cowboys players bought the fake and left Joey Porter Jr. on one side to take on what Tom Brady called a red wave.
You can’t get got every time.
Stock Down: KaVontae Turpin
He had a drop of a pass that landed squarely in his hands. How does that even happen?
Remember when Turpin was regarded to be a special teams ace, though? Remember when he was providing the team with an elite advantage?
Where is that? What is he offering that anyone else can’t from a return game standpoint? I will take any answer.
Stock Down: Brandon Aubrey
His only miss in this game was an extra point, but the point (no pun intended) is that he missed yet another kick.
We are sort of running out of excuses for Aubrey at this point. It can’t always be this, that, or whatever is convenient. He is the top-paid kicker in the NFL and he is in no way among the most reliable kickers in the league right now. His miss was an extra point as noted in this game. An extra point! At home! Indoors!
The Cowboys hardly lost because of that missed point, but these keep piling up.
Stock Up: Quinnen Williams
The Cowboys absolutely have a war daddy.
Quinnen Williams might be the best player on the Cowboys period right now. He did his best to singlehandedly save the team at the end as he forced a fumble that almost made the attempted rally actually possible.
It is legitimately impressive how Quinnen is not allowing the state of things to impact his effort. I suppose spending a ton of time with the New York Jets will harden you in that way.
Stock Up: George Pickens
Let’s state that the taunting penalty was silly. We all agree.
But wow what a game from George Pickens. He essentially was the entire offense for much of the game, at least before it got away from Dallas and they were playing catch up.
It is hard to wonder what could or would have happened if this performance came right before the trade deadline. It didn’t, though. And now he and Dallas are stuck with each other until contract negotiations that will surely be calm and easy.
Stock Up: LT Overton
In addition to Quinnen Williams the Cowboys also saw some force up front from one of their rookies in LT Overton, including an impressive batted pass.
If the Cowboys are ever going to find true and proper form in the future it is going to be because they develop a bevy of options along the defensive line. Hopefully Overton is a part of that future alongside Quinnen Williams and whoever else the Cowboys fan find between now and that hypothetical day.













