The voting
Voting for this was pretty interesting. It initially looked like Waldy’s walk-off versus the Cubs was going to prevail. But then the 1-0 bullpen shutout roared back into contention, before overcoming the seven-run deficit mounted a challenge on the rails. At one point, indeed, there was a three-way tie between those contests, and I was unsure what to do. Fortunately, I got distracted yesterday by non-tenders and the Oviedo trade. By the time I’d got back to check, somebody had cast a deciding ballot,
to give the 7-run deficit victory by a single vote. So, whoever that last person to vote was… it’s all on you!
Below is how voting ended, at the point I deleted the poll, because I needed to start writing up the damn article! I note that all six candidates received at least one one, and I’m not sure we’ve ever had many categories won with a figure as low as 26% of votes. Goes to show the lack of clear contenders in this category, though I am pleased that, unlike 2025, we did not also need to have an additional category for Loss of the Year! Anyway, with all that said, onto the game!
Digging the hole
This was only the second time in franchise history the D-backs had come back from a deficit of seven runs, and you could argue this one was more dramatic. The previous occasion, in August 2022 (which, understandably, also won the Game of the Year category), the team’s Win Probability bottomed out at 2.7%, when the Phillies had the bases loaded with two outs in the top of the fourth, or when Josh Rojas grounded out to lead off the bottom half. But this year’s version had the seven-run deficit later, and Arizona’s WP was barely half that, at 1.4% as we went into the sixth inning. On the other hand, the 2022 version saw the D-backs score thirteen unanswered runs, rather than the bare minimum eight here.
It began with a rare stinker by Eduardo Rodriguez. Over his previous nineteen starts, he had a 2.29 ERA, and had gone less than five innings only once in that time. But tonight, he just didn’t have it, and couldn’t get through three frames. Rodriguez needed forty pitches to record two outs in the third before being lifted. The Cardinals sent eleven to the plate in the frame (including a pair of walks to future D-back, Lars Nootbaar), scoring five times. A two-run single off Philip Abner in the top of the fifth padded the score to 7-0. Though such was the state of the game by that point, that the additional pair of tallies only increased St. Louis’s win probability by 3.6 percent.
Fighting back
Things started to turn around for the Diamondbacks in the 6th. Three hits to start the frame got Arizona on the board, and they then took advantage of a lack of control from the Cardinals. The home side drew three walks, including two with the bases loaded, to make it 7-3. Sloppy defense helped Geraldo Perdomo to an inside-the-park homer in the seventh, a two-run “shot” that at 242 ft was Arizona’s shortest home-run in the Statcast era! A more conventional two-run home-run by Nolan Arenado in the eighth tied the game, and it remained there until the bottom of the tenth. With one out, Max Kepler doubled, scoring the Manfred Man for the wildest walk-off of the year.
While Kepler may have got the glory, let’s not forget the role played by Arizona’s bullpen pitching and defense. Philip Abner, Taylor Clarke, Ryan Thompson and Juan Morillo combined to throw 5.1 shutout innings, in a contest where every run mattered. It wasn’t easy. The Cards had men in scoring position in the 7th, 9th and 10th (obviously!) innings, but all were stranded. None was bigger than the tenth, when a lead-off hit gave St. Louis men on the corners with nobody out, and a renewed Win Probability of 67.7%. But Perdomo took full advantage of a base-running gaffe to turn a double-play, and that allowed Arizona to complete one of the greatest escapes in the history of the franchise.
What they said
- “All the credit to the coaches. We didn’t have enough energy until the sixth — until we pissed off Mac (First Base Coach Dave McKay). After that, I think we got some energy, and things started getting better.” — Geraldo Perdomo
- “Obviously, we needed it as a team. Just a well-fought game for us, just to come back like that was incredible. Arguably, our best win of the year, but just to see us — the way we fought and didn’t give in, we could have easily done that. We didn’t, so that was great.”— Nolan Arenado
- “What a great team win. I watched player after player make a sacrifice, and a commitment to one another to go out there and win inches all over the field. When it seemed like we were flatlined, we just gave ourselves a little bit of life… Everybody from that point forward fought to win a baseball game, and that’s what is super inspiring to me.” — Torey Lovullo
- “After spending most of the afternoon convincing everyone they were dead, the Diamondbacks objected vigorously once the burial arrangements had been finalized… For six innings, the Diamondbacks were left for dead. By the eighth inning, the deceased was sitting up in the gurney. By the tenth, it was walking around greeting fans.” — JustRonM guest recap
- And if you want the very definition of “a roller-coaster of emotions”, read the comments in the Gameday Thread over the course of this one!
Extended highlights
Previous winners
- 2025: 6/5, It’s alive! IT’S ALIVE!!!
- 2024: 3/30, Bee-movie with a happy ending vs. Los Angeles
- 2023: 9/16, 7-6 (13) vs. Cubs – The Longest Day + NLCS Game 7, 10/24 ‐ 4-2 @ Phillies
- 2022: 8/29: 7-run deficit? No problem!
- 2021: 4/25, 2-for-1 special vs. Atlanta
- 2020: 8/18 – Acing the A’s
- 2019: 9/24, The Never-Ending Story
- 2018: 4/2 vs. LAD – the longest night
- 2017: 4/2 – Opening Day comebacks
- 2016: 8/11 – 9-0 @ NYM – Slaying Thor
- 2015: 4/11 – Archie Bradley debut vs LAD, crushing Kershaw
- 2014: 5/17 – Killing Kershaw
- 2013: 4/3 – Diamondbacks 10, Cardinals 9 (16 inn)
- 2012: 4/8, Comeback from six down vs. San Francisco
- 2011: 9/27 vs. Dodgers, 10th-inning resurrection
- 2010: 8/11, Your Arizona Diamondback-to-back-to-back-to-backs, vs. MIL
- 2009: 6/7, the game without end, vs SDP
- 2008: 7/3: Matinee miracle vs. MIL
- 2007: 5/19, comeback vs. PIT













