Ohio State faced a massive challenge entering the 2025 season. Two of its most dominant interior defenders, Tyleik Williams and Ty Hamilton, had departed for the NFL, leaving a significant void at defensive
tackle. Into that gap stepped Kayden McDonald, and what unfolded over the course of the season was one of the most impressive breakout campaigns by a Buckeyes interior lineman in recent memory.
McDonald’s counting stats tell only part of the story. He finished the year with 65 tackles, 9 tackles for loss, and 3 sacks as a true breakout star on the defensive front. But raw numbers barely capture how disruptive McDonald truly was.
More than just a run stopper, he became a constant force at the point of attack, routinely collapsing pockets, clogging running lanes, and turning offensive plans upside down with his presence, all from the interior. Opposing units quickly learned that double-teams often weren’t enough, as McDonald’s strength, leverage, and explosiveness gave him the rare ability to make plays despite attention from multiple blockers.
Filling big shoes, and then some
Coming into the season, expectations for McDonald were high. But few projected him to ascend to the heights he ultimately reached. Tasked with replacing players like Williams and Hamilton, both high draft picks and impactful two-gap thumpers.
McDonald didn’t just fill a vacancy, he became one of the defining players on Ohio State’s defense. His blend of power, gap control, and surprising quickness allowed the Buckeyes to maintain one of the nation’s most feared run defenses.
That wasn’t an accident, it was a testament to his development, motor, and consistency over 14 games that often saw him leading the interior rotation in snaps.
McDonald’s impact didn’t go unnoticed. He was named the Big Ten Defensive Lineman of the Year, joining the likes of Caleb Downs and Arvell Reese in sweeping major defensive honors for Ohio State’s unit, a rare accomplishment for any team.
On many ballots, he also drew national consideration, earning acclaim as one of the country’s most disruptive interior defenders and landing on multiple All-American watch lists.
The Prospect Profile: NFL first-round upside
What may be even more telling than the awards and the statistics is how McDonald’s NFL Draft stock has skyrocketed over the course of the season. A player who many expected to return to Ohio State in 2026 became one of the country’s most highly regarded interior linemen.
By early 2026, McDonald had officially declared for the NFL Draft, and draft boards across the country project him as a first-round caliber prospect, and even potentially the first defensive tackle off the board.
At 6-3, 326 pounds, McDonald combines a physical frame with surprising quickness off the snap and impressive lateral agility for his size. Those traits, paired with elite contact balance and an innate ability to find the football, make him a coveted projection for NFL front offices looking for a three-down interior defender who can disrupt both run and pass schemes.
Beyond the box score
What separates McDonald from many interior prospects isn’t just his strength, it’s his eye for the ball and his relentless activity in tight quarters. Whether it was stuffing a back at the line or shooting a gap to force negative yardage, McDonald consistently changed the outlook of drives before they could gain momentum.
His presence allowed Ohio State’s linebackers and edge rushers to play freer, knowing the middle was anchored by an interior beast capable of collapsing pockets and redirecting rushes.
In a season full of standout defensive performances, McDonald’s may be the most underrated, until now. As a junior, he stepped out of the shadows of those who came before him and became a true force in the trenches, anchoring a stout Buckeye defensive line.
