All AN eyes are, of course, on the A’s pitching and how the dynamic duo of Smith/Castro might be able to improve it on the quick. Most frontline SPs will be too pricey and back end SPs, while useful, won’t move the needle on bringing the A’s to relevance.
That’s why some hopes rest on internal talent such as Jack Perkins and Luis Morales, perhaps even Luis Medina making a return to the rotation — certainly much “plus stuff” rests in those 3 arms. But through the free agent and trade markets, perhaps a hidden
gem exists that is the perfect hybrid of “affordable” and “with sufficient upside”.
Patrick Sandoval
One of 5 pitchers suggested by Martin Gallegos in his recent speculative write up, Sandoval comes with the question marks associated with recovering from Tommy John surgery and returning to tepid results in 13 starts for the Red Sox: 1-7, 5.12 ERA, 4.09 BB/9 IP. These are the reasons he will be more affordable than Clay Holmes or Nick Martinez.
But Sandoval’s upside is significant and Medina is a good example of how someone can make a slow but full return to form following TJS. (Chris Bassitt is another — he also struggled with control initially but eventually blossomed into a front line SP.)
Even in a disappointing 2026, Sandoval struck out 73 batters in 70.1 IP and even though he made just 15 appearances he was credited with 1.3 fWAR. He also accrued 6.0 WAR in his 2022-23 seasons prior to the injury and was establishing himself as a legitimate mid-rotation SP.
It remains to be seen what kind of contract it takes to sign Sandoval, but it figures to be well in the A’s price range. There is risk, as there will be with anyone affordable, but the upside is evident and Sandoval recently turned 30 with relatively few miles in his left arm. Plus, someone who is familiar with him from their roads crossing in 2026 is none other than Taylor Smith.
Interestingly, many of the other possible ‘natural fits’ are also left-handed: Foster Griffin has been suggested by multiple MLBTR predictors and David Peterson is a possible ‘bounce back’ candidate whose underlying metrics were more favorable than his surface stats.
Brandon Woodruff
From the right side, Woodruff might be an interesting target in that he has all the upside you want in a target, but due to injury he hasn’t made more than 12 appearances in any season since 2022 (missing all of 2024), making just 32 total starts from 2023-26.
Yet he came back strong in 2026, posting a 2.98 ERA in 9 starts with K/9 IP and BB/9 IP rates of 9.33 and 1.99. He also was throwing only 91.8 MPH, waaaay down from his career average of 95.7 MPH. Red flag or he knows how to pitch in the low 90s and get outs? Who knows?
Woodruff would be a risky signing due to his injury history and current velocity, but there’s no denying his results both past and present. He has made 136 career stats and his career ERA is 3.10. Plus he has done so under the watchful eye of none other than Cam Castro, who probably has a very good idea of how much the A’s should or shouldn’t covet him.
No one’s first choice is to spend decent money on arms who have recently been injured, pitchers who have not shown they can stay on the mound, and yet if you’re chasing upside without a bottomless wallet this is your reality: you have to pursue pitchers who have something working against them.
How do you feel about these two as potential “high risk/high upside” grabs that might be within the A’s budget? And if not them, who?













