Another Sunday, another opener against a lineup that I do not like the White Sox facing.
In tense but rewarding fashion, my worries went for naught, as an explosive six-run sixth inning broke the spell of Dodgers pitching on the Sox offense, leading them to a 6-4 comeback win that pushes the Sox back to a season-best six games better than .500, at 38-32.
If things go well, we are perhaps a week or two out from the 2026 White Sox surpassing their entire record-setting win total from 2024. Get out your
pots and pans, folks.
I spent the entire first half of the game waffling over whether Will Venable’s planning and execution of the opener/bulk man strategy was well-conceived. I’m on the record as being extremely skeptical of the current coaching staff’s preoccupation with seemingly arbitrary platoon matchups. Erick Fedde has a reverse platoon split this season, and has been more or less neutral over the course of his career. If you stripped the names away and purely showed me the numbers, I probably would have said that using an opener was a pointless endeavor.
But as some of my colleagues pointed out, the typical scenario doesn’t account for the fact that the run of lefty hitters this would be employed against includes Shohei Ohtani, MLB RBI leader Andy Pages, Freddie Freeman, Max Muncy, Kyle Tucker and former Top 3o prospect Dalton Rushing, almost in that order. The worst hitter in that group is second in the NL in rWAR. It’s a gauntlet straight out of Out of the Park Baseball.
Still, I thought that if Fedde, who entered the game with a 4.69 ERA (roughly 10% worse than league average), is going to take the bulk of the innings for the afternoon, it probably doesn’t matter whether he starts the game on the mound or appears in the fourth inning — he’s still going to have to get through that modern-day Murderer’s Row twice.
The latter is what we got. Bryan Hudson was tasked with handing the opening trio of Ohtani, Pages and Freeman. For the second straight week, a Sox opener failed to fully justify the platoon advantage. Freeman is undoubtedly worse against lefties than righties. That knowledge was still of little comfort when the future Hall-of-Famer drilled one into the right field bleachers for a 1-0 Dodgers lead:
Fortunately, most of my concerns turned out to be moot. The fact that Fedde only had to face Ohtani and Freeman once in his 3 1/3 innings of work gave the Sox offense critical time to engineer yet another thrilling comeback.
Part of why it happened is that Sean Newcomb was pretty nasty, and he continues to live up to the $4.5 million deal he signed last offseason. The only baserunner he allowed in 2 1/3 innings was self-inflicted, striking out four of the other six batters he faced. Getting Freeman out this time to conclude that stretch set up Fedde to finally enter the game to face Mookie Betts with one out in the fourth inning. When it looked like the Sox were on the verge of falling into an early hole, Newcomb was outstanding in keeping the Dodgers offense at bay long enough for Sox hitters to settle in.
While the Sox had to expend a lot of brainpower trying to navigate the opposing lineup with the state of their pitching staff, the Dodgers had no such concerns. Emmet Sheehan came out dealing for the former Brooklynites, sitting 95 mph on his rising heather and commanding three secondary pitches quite well. He lasted until the fifth inning before allowing a base knock, a double down the line from Colson Montgomery.
Through five innings, we were looking at a grand total of two hits for the Sox over their prior 18 innings. Sheehan looked untouchable.
In perhaps another vindication of the opener strategy, it was the third time through the lineup that turned out to be Sheehan’s undoing. Sheehan’s control took just the slightest dip as his pitch count climbed, and after hitting the ball hard into outs the first time through, Sox hitters simply didn’t miss when they got their third look. They homered three times in the sixth inning, chasing Sheehan from the ballgame and turning a 1-0 deficit into an improbable 6-1 lead.
As has often been the case this spring, the critical spark for the Pale House came courtesy of Sam Antonacci, who led off the sixth by slamming his second home run of the season, and the first one that actually flew over the fence. It wasn’t a cheap one — at 105 mph and 415 feet, Statcast tells us that it would’ve left the yard in every ballpark in The Show.
It wasn’t just Antonacci that suddenly began seeing Sheehan like he got a new pair of glasses. Momentum built, as Miguel Vargas smoked a single and double at triple-digit velocities. Benintendi’s double gave the Sox a 2-1 lead, and Colson Montgomery subsequently doubled it. Sheehan had already failed to sneak fastballs by Colson earlier in the game to the tune of that postgame show-cancelling double, and the Sox shortstop didn’t miss even in the slightest again, with his towering blast also breaking 400 feet.
Finally, Chase Meidroth joined the party with an opposite field wall-scraper, his sixth longball of 2026. It was the first oppo homer of Meidroth’s career — all 10 of his previous dingers had come to the pull side. At the end of the inning, it was a 6-1 Sox lead, and the Dodgers lineup had to deal with Grant Taylor.
While I initially thought from his pitch mix that Fedde probably would not even pitch in a traditional bulk man — how funny that phrase would have felt a decade ago — role. He threw pretty much no fastballs his first time through the order, relying almost entirely on his sweeper and changeup. That’s not the pitch mix of someone who’s concerned about establishing the fastball in order to take advantage of their secondary stuff the second and third time through the order.
To some degree, that was a correct assessment. Fedde finished with 2 2/3 innings of work, just an out more than what Newcomb recorded as an “opener.” But despite allowing three hits and two walks in his brief time in the game, Fedde got outs where it counted. The grand sixth inning comeback simply would not have been possible had he not displayed the guts to keep his team in the game.
The Dodgers did have an opportunity to mount a comeback against Taylor. Dalton Rushing came home to score after a double to lead off the inning, but that was the only baserunner that Taylor ceded.
It seems worth noting that the Sox coaching staff seems to be stepping up the 24-year-old’s workload as of late. The Dodgers tacked on another run on a Mookie Betts dinger during Taylor’s second inning of work, swelling his ERA all the way up to 2.18. It’s third time in his last four outings that Taylor has been trusted to work multiple innings, bringing his innings total to 36 2/3 on the season, on pace to fall a few innings short of the stated goal of a century.
Despite today’s bumpy outing, his strikeout-to-walk ratio of 51:9 remains impeccable.
Los Angeles relievers largely did their job in keeping Sox bats quiet the rest of the way. After lefty Jack Dreyer was victimized by Meidroth, Blake Treinen and Jonathan Hernandez took care of business in the seventh and eighth. That left the ball in the hands of Seranthony Domínguez to close things out.
I suffered a few moments of true despair as Domínguez issued a four-pitch walk to begin the inning and the dread of a full last-minute recap rewrite arrived like a sudden thunderstorm. As the clouds crept closer with a double and a four-pitch walk, infield defense bailed out the team for what feels like the 10th time this year. A heads up 4-6 putout on a sliding snag up the middle by Chase Meidroth got the Sox within an out, and Domínguez managed to shut the door with a dramatic punchout of Freddie Freeman to secure the dramatic victory and series win.
That makes consecutive series wins against two of the three occupants of first place in the National League. It may be safe to say that critics can no longer point to the state of the AL Central in writing off the potential of this Sox squad. Bob Nightengale reported today that Chris Getz and Co. may be aggressive at the trade deadline. If these South Siders can pull off another two wins in the Bronx against the Yankees, it may be time to take the training wheels off and commit to the idea that they could actually do something in 2026, arriving early or no.
That first game in New York begins at 6:05 p.m. CT, with the South Siders off tomorrow before starting their road trip with a bona fide ace-off as Gerrit Cole steps up for the Yankees against the unstoppable Davis Martin. It’ll be followed up by old friend Carlos Rodón, and with Tarik Skubal lined up to go for Detroit on Friday, the Sox are ready for perhaps their single most challenging week of the season. Win or lose, we’ll see you there!
