Three years ago, I gave a grave warning that most dismissed as clickbait or alarmism: A lockout was coming to MLB in December 2026.
At the risk of asking the owners how many times they need to learn this lesson, I am not generally in the business of making predictions, but I will venture out on a limb and make a prediction today:
The owners are going to lock out the players (again) in December 2026 when the current collective bargaining agreement expires.
Last time, we opened the series, debunking a common
myth while highlighting those who will truly be impacted by the ongoing labor stoppage.
This time, we present an idea that would make baseball stronger and better for the next century. It’s fan-friendly and would be a generational change, transforming the landscape of American sport forever. Accordingly, this idea has no chance in hell of ever being implemented. Ever.
The owners would hate it. The players would hate it. The traditionalists in the media would hate it. But the fans would probably love it.
Unlike Manny Machado, verbally, I would be willing to wager my entire annual legal salary for the next five years against the notion that this idea would be implemented in the next 25 years. It’s such a slam dunk that it won’t happen. No one would book this action if they could, or if it were legal.
Building a Better World
The following thought exercise assumes that I can Quantum Leap into Commissioner Rob Manfred or engage in some Weekend at Bernie’s-style shenanigans where I have dictatorial power in baseball that somehow survives likely successful legal challenges and/or being reversed after I am summarily fired. Yes, under what I propose, I would still likely be sued by both a majority of the owners and the players’ association. I imagine Congressional subpoenas would be imminent, too, but we shall belabor this point for the actual substance of this article.
This idea would be the second thing I implement if I were Commissioner for a Day.
The first thing is to issue an order I would have written beforehand, having the 2017 World Series vacated.
There was no winner. The Houston Astros cheated. We have confessions, we have evidence, and we are not going to whitewash it anymore. No more stupid highlights where we pretend nothing bad happened. Nobody won; everybody lost. If I’m a commissioner for the day, I have to make the most of it.
Some teams spend; others don’t. Yes, you just had a team in Milwaukee that prides itself on frugality have one of the most dominant campaigns in recent memory, becoming the first so-called small-market team to win a championship since the Kansas City Royals did the feat in 2015, 11 years ago. Bully for them.
The Brewers have already let NLCS MVP and bane to Dodgers pitching Jake Bauers walk to Boston.
Some of MLB’s teams are perpetually bad, whether they spent a king’s ransom (hello, the Mets) or whether they spend bupkis (hello, the Angels), or whether they have delusions of grandeur in thinking they are better than what they are (hello, the Giants and the Reds). Considering the Brewers’ success, one might wonder if some other teams would try to at least mimic their model.
Earlier this year, Ken Rosenthal and C. Trent Rosecrans of The Athletic provided an answer at least from the perspective of the Cincinnati Reds:
“Why aren’t we the Brewers?”
In the first half of the season, Cincinnati Reds owner Bob Castellini posed that question in a meeting with his team’s top officials. President of baseball operations Nick Krall effectively pointed the finger right back at the owner.
To demonstrate the difference between how the Reds and Brewers operate, Krall presented a “laundry list” of trades Castellini did not approve, according to people briefed on the meeting who were granted anonymity because they were not authorized to speak publicly about a private matter.
Krall wanted to build a strong base of young talent, then enhance it by trading established players at peak value when they are still affordable and under club control. His plan was not unlike the one previous Reds administrations suggested when Castellini would ask what made another small-market team, the Tampa Bay Rays, successful.
Castellini, who turned 85 on Wednesday, has consistently balked at any such approach. He always devotes the Reds’ limited resources toward trying to compete at the major-league level, even if it means skimping on player development. His strategy has failed. The Reds have not won a playoff game since 2012. And now, as another lost season draws to a close in Cincinnati, his franchise is in limbo.
[Emphasis added.]
The way the naysayers/proponents for a hard salary cap argue, we have zombie teams that shuffle into forever, stuck in a perpetual state of now, never growing, never changing. Oddly enough, payroll, attendance, and record are corollary numbers, not causative numbers.
“The Coronavirus effectively created the current era; let’s see what it made besides the Dodgers dynasty,” was my original thought, so I went through the raw data for attendance (from ESPN), for payroll (from Spotrac), and for record (Baseball Reference).
Let’s rank all the current 30 MLB franchises over the past six years by these three figures and then average them out.
I decided to ignore television revenue for two reasons: the death of the regional cable system and the Dodgers’ media deal, even with all the Mark Walter news. Rather than try to sift through it, I rely on what I can empirically point to. The original idea to split the league in half was going to be entirely based on payroll, but I did not want to reward foolish spending. Using base payroll sans luxury taxes felt like the cleanest way to evaluate the teams on this metric, because it’s no secret that the Dodgers frequently pay luxury taxes.
A leaner league would need both winners (as evidenced by both record and payroll) and people showing up. It’s not a perfect set of metrics, but the goal was to get everything down to one number, league-wide for comparison, and then split the league in half.
Sixteen teams on one side, fourteen teams on the other, with at least two expansion clubs coming to create a 32-team sport of baseball. That idea was the crazy idea, largely inspired by the Premier League of English Football, and yes, a burgeoning scandal that popped on my radar. Admittedly, soccer/futbol isn’t my cup of tea (Earl Grey or otherwise), so when something from that area code pops up on my radar, you know it’s bad.
So remake baseball and don’t do what Manchester United did; it seems easy enough for today’s exercise.
Personal Evolution of Baseball
Using 2026 to start, each of the three metrics I describe above is ranked from 1 to 30. Those values are averaged, which is the final column on the right. With these charts, they can be best displayed in landmark view.
As to the attendance rankings, not every team ended up playing 81 home games. You may see a team highlighted in red and look out of order. I presented the information as presented by ESPN, as some teams would have had a higher total had they played all 81 home games. Ultimately, the oddity did not change the final statistics enough to alter the rankings, but I kept them in to prevent anyone from thinking I got the data wrong.
For payroll, I also included both the average and median amounts compared to the luxury tax threshold. For schedule, I did not include any tiebreakers. If teams ended up with the same record, they all share the same rank for that metric.
As always, graphs appear best in landscape mode, and I did my best to make everything readable. The averages of the three metrics are like golf; the lower the score, the better. A perfect score on this scale is an average of 1; the lowest possible score is an average of 30.
Each tab will give you a snapshot of the past six years, one year at a time. The season’s champion is highlighted in orange, and the runner-up in silver. The important average of each metric is highlighted in green on the right.
Once I had reduced each season to a single number, I averaged all six seasons for every team to three decimal places in a separate chart. The lowest sixteen scores became the basis of what I will call the First Division of Major League Baseball (“Robinson”); the remainder became the Second Division of Major League Baseball (“Clemente”).
Using this methodology, there are several conclusions that leap off the page.
First, the Dodgers have been the clear cream of the crop in baseball over the past six seasons.
Second, of the sixteen survivors, I was genuinely surprised that both Milwaukee and Anaheim made the cut. I noted who ultimately won the World Series while compiling the data because I was preparing to defend a system that excluded the current champion. It turns out that fear was misplaced. The methodology awards points for paying salary, fans showing up, and teams doing well. Sometimes, the data genuinely is surprising.
Yes, Tampa and Cleveland have generally done well in degrees over the past six years, but ultimately, under these metrics you can’t run a ballpark with bubblegum and glue with modest attendance figures and expect to hang with teams that don’t. Remembering that an average of 30 is the lowest score on the scale, the Miami, Pittsburgh, and Oakland/Sacramento/Las Vegas organizations have a lot to answer for.
The Angels have been terrible for the last decade, but they pay, and their fans continue to show up. Note to Anaheim: Stop doing that. I have been arguing for years that teams don’t necessarily need to spend like the Dodgers, as in many cases they literally cannot, but that teams should spend like Atlanta or San Francisco. Yes, Milwaukee runs a lean ship, but their fans show up, and they win. The other teams in the Second Division cannot say the same.
As it stands, the system I proposed effectively abolishes the American and National Leagues. Instead, we have two segregated, sixteen-team leagues with two eight-team groupings based on geography for concurrent 154-game seasons, with unbalanced schedules and no interleague play outside of spring training.
- Robinson West
- Los Angeles Dodgers
- San Diego Padres
- San Francisco Giants
- Seattle Mariners
- Anaheim Angels
- St. Louis Cardinals
- Houston Astros
- Texas Rangers
- Robinson East
- New York Yankees
- Philadelphia Phillies
- Atlanta Braves
- Boston Red Sox
- New York Mets
- Toronto Blue Jays
- Milwaukee Brewers
- Chicago Cubs
- Clemente West
- Arizona Diamondbacks
- Colorado Rockies
- Las Vegas Athletics
- Cleveland Guardians
- Cincinnati Reds
- Chicago White Sox
- Kansas City Royals
- Expansion Team West
- Clemente East
- Baltimore Orioles
- Tampa Bay Rays
- Washington Nationals
- Pittsburgh Pirates
- Miami Marlins
- Detroit Tigers
- Minnesota Twins
- Expansion Team East
The playoffs are where this system shines. In the First Division, we have two rounds: a League Championship Series and a World Series, both seven games, consisting of the division winner facing the 2nd-place team of the other division.
The division winner would host all the games of the LCS, providing an incentive to win the division. The World Series would be as normal, with the two winners squaring off in a 2-3-2 format based on which team has the best overall record.
The First Division will also have an annual four-team tournament to determine who gets relegated to the lower league. The teams that finish last in their division will square off with the teams that finished next-to-last in the other division. The best-of-five Relegation Series, held entirely at the higher seed’s parks, operates under a single principle: “win and you’re in.”
The losers of these series are paired off in a final best-of-five series. The winner gets to stay in the First Division; the loser gets relegated. Every year, a single team from the First Division will get relegated.
Conversely, in the Second Division, the playoffs will be the same format as the World Series track described above: a four-team Promotion Tournament, with the West and East winners hosting the runner-up of the other division for potentially all seven games. The winners move on for the right both to be declared League Champion and to be promoted to the First Division.
The World is Yours*
The benefits of the proposed system are obvious. Gone are the days of futile baseball, because it’s either be competitive or lose millions of dollars in relegation. Bad teams in the second division would eventually have to shape up or fold. The drama writes itself.
In order to balance the leagues, expansion teams would first start playing in the Second Division. First, it’s cheaper. Expansion teams in the current system are anticipated to pay at least $2 billion in expansion fees for the privilege of being a likely punching bag for the next few seasons. Here, expansion in the lower division comes with room to grow, rather than imminent fear of relegation.
The long, drawn-out summers of futility would be a thing of the past…unless you’re a bottom feeder in the Second Division. In which case, maybe expansion seeder cities are cultivated to pick up the pieces. If competitive baseball can’t happen in Miami (outside of the World Baseball Classic), Pittsburgh (outside of when the Savannah Bananas visit), or Denver (outside of when the Dodgers visit), then I am sure the good people of Oakland, Montreal, Portland, or San Juan are more than willing to stand up.
The minor leagues would exist as they are now. The draft would proceed with the First Division going first, with a week to sign everyone drafted before the Second Division picks, using the same method. No undrafted free agents could be signed until after both Drafts. Admittedly, this portion of the idea has the least amount of thought put into it.
Personally, I am fine with the current system, but if the owners are going to unleash Armageddon to pad their balance sheets, discussing a better way is required.
Pulling the Strings
Where would the pushback occur? Everywhere.
The owners most opposed to this proposal are the very owners who are generally too cheap to field competitive teams now. You can suddenly throw over $50 million at Dustin May of all people, but that die is pretty much cast. The owners that are most likely to drive the sport into the figurative ditch would fight their investments being worth less than other Major League teams. Equity in the face of privilege feels like oppression.
Also, I could imagine the pushback from skinflint clubs.
“We can’t spend like the Dodgers! If you just look at the attendance and the records over the last six years, your supposed numbers would tell a different story!”
Not being afraid to test the data, I checked, and there is one major change: Anaheim no longer makes the cut, and Cleveland does. Does this testing of the hypothesis change my mind?
Honestly, no, for a simple reason: players don’t play for free. Removing the salaries from the metrics makes it seem like the franchises are much closer together than they actually are. For as much as I have mocked the Toronto Blue Jays over the past couple of years, even if they are a mid-tier franchise, one cannot claim that they are not more successful than Detroit or Baltimore.
Fans show up, and money is being invested in the team. Propaganda about stating fan desire for a hard salary cap can’t belie this fact, and we are certainly unlikely to see any of the skinflint owners (James Dolan in Cleveland and John Fisher in Sacramento come to mind) publicly address why they run such comedically minuscule payrolls.
The players would be opposed to this system, as I have arguably created a system that bifurcates the players’ union in a move that Rob Manfred can only dream of. If implemented, the MLBPA would likely split into two separate organizations because there is now a giant economic fault line between the haves and have-nots. This system would likely mimic the economic models of the English Premier League and the English Championship League.
Finances in English football effectively work on a logarithmic scale, per Sousa Football Agents:
The Premier League and the EFL Championship share the same [financial] pyramid, but financially they’re two different worlds. England’s top flight has expanded its ability to shop for players anywhere on the planet, while second-tier clubs keep pouring most of their resources into chasing a promotion that could change everything for them.
The gap isn’t new, but it’s grown a lot over the last decade. In 2014/15, Premier League clubs brought in a combined £3.3 billion, compared to £548 million for the Championship. Ten years later, in 2024/25, those numbers climbed to £6.8 billion and £942 million.
The Premier League, in other words, more than doubled its revenue. The Championship grew too, just at a much slower pace. A decade ago, the top flight was generating roughly six times more than the second tier; today that gap has passed seven times.
[Emphasis added.]
I would imagine that the same dynamic would unfold here, just more pronounced. The goal isn’t to have everyone spend like the Dodgers; the goal is to have everyone spend like the Giants or the Mariners.
Player contracts would likely need to have escape clauses when relegated or escalator clauses when promoted. Salaries would likely balloon in the First Division and plummet in the Second Division as the bulk of money and attention would flow upward. Where before we have managed chaos, here we would have high drama as the literal stakes would be quite personal.
If you had asked me when I thought of this essay series whether my proposal would create a system that arguably creates the purest model of free market capitalism by accident, I would have laughed. Hence, the mild delay. I had to come to terms with what I had done. Oh bother. If only there were a song for this level of unintentional goof.
We needed something with a little more heft than the ending theme of Curb Your Enthusiasm. Baka Mitai translates into “like a fool / I look like a fool.” Kidding aside, while baseball-fan me would be excited by this system I have dreamed up, I cannot and will not pretend that there would not be consequences.
Expanding the Horizon
The truth is the creation of this system would be a tacit admission that baseball is fundamentally broken. I disagree that it is, regardless of how much tripe MLB puts out to act as propaganda to serve as leverage against the MLBPA, but that’s the fun of thought experiment essays like this one: exploration without consequences.
Here’s the one kicker of this article that will happen at some point: expansion. Commissioner Manfred has stated that once the Athletics’ and Rays’ situations were worked out, focus would shift to expansion. Two new teams are coming, at some point. Next time, we will discuss possible venues and who we should get and who we will likely get.













