Penalties played a decisive role in the New England Patriots’ opening drive against the Detroit Lions on Sunday, but it was a flag that wasn’t flown that generated the most discussion after the game: should Lions edge rusher Aidan Hutchinson been penalized for taking down Drake Maye and, along the way, injuring his ankle?
Before trying to figure out whether or not referee Clay Martin and his crew should have flown penalty flags, a look at the play in question.
Hutchinson quickly worked his way into the backfield on an apparent communication breakdown involving left tackle Will Campbell, and wrapped up Maye from behind as he was climbing the pocket. In doing so, he lifted his entire body off the ground and subsequently came down on Maye’s now-injured ankle.
Was Hutchinson’s form illegal, though, and should have been penalized as a hip-drop tackle? Not according to NFL rules Section 2, Article 18:
Article 18. Hip-Drop Tackle
It is a foul if a player uses the following technique to bring a runner to the ground:
– grabs the runner with one or both hands or wraps the runner with both arms; and
– unweights himself by swiveling and dropping his hips and/or lower body, landing on and/or trapping the runner’s leg(s) at or below the knee.
FOX rules analyst Mike Pereira gave a similar explanation on the air.
“Three things have to happen,” he explained. “You have to unweight yourself, swivel all around the back and land on the back of his leg below the knee. This was more of a horse collar-type pulled down from behind. [But] certainly not a horse collar penalty.”
The NFL agreed, as reported by ESPN’s Mike Reiss:
Walt Anderson, the NFL’s officiating rules analyst, confirmed Pereira’s explanation through a league spokesman, noting it was not a hip-drop tackle because there was no swivel or unweighting.
It was also not a foul for a horse collar tackle, as Pereira noted, because neither the collar nor the nameplate were grabbed. No penalty was called on the play by referee Clay Martin’s crew.
Mike Vrabel, who has been at odds with the officials multiple times so far this season, also saw nothing nefarious on the play.
“I don’t think it was [a hip-drop tackle],” he said on Monday. This comment follows up similar remarks made by Vrabel after the game on Sunday.
“I’m not going to assume there was something there,” he said. “However it happened, I don’t think it was anything intentional. I’m sure that it wasn’t. That’s part of the game.”
Neither Maye nor Hutchinson have since commented on the play, because both got injured. Whereas Maye suffered the aforementioned ankle injury, Hutchinson is believed to have suffered a torn ACL while celebrating the sack.













