In the midst of the offseason teardown effort by the Cardinals’ front office, they looked to take advantage of opportunities that they’d have available with openings across the roster. The Cardinals opted to give Dustin May a 1-year 12.5 million-dollar contract with the purpose of re-establishing his career and trying to maximize whatever trade value he would generate in 66% of the regular season. The Cardinals managed to get 21 starts, 109 IP, and a 4.38 ERA with a 3.15 FIP-level performance and managed to strike
out 23.1% of batters. The Redbirds were then able to flip Dustin May and JoJo Romero to the Milwaukee Brewers on deadline day to return to high-upside outfield prospects Josiah Ragsdale and Alexander Frias.
Those who cover the Cardinals or are around the organization believe they might try to repeat the success they had this season. With their large investments in the implementation of tech, as well as in other areas of nutrition and facilities. The new front office is checking off boxes that prospective free agents are looking for when selecting their next destination. One of the other elements that will boost their reputation is that over the last few seasons, the Cardinals have become one of the best teams at keeping pitchers healthy and on the field. If I recall correctly, Andre Pallante was the first starting pitcher to be placed on the injured list in the last 2 seasons, back in August. The almighty dollar always will have the final say, but these are things that current big leaguers want in addition to financial compensation: to know that wherever they’re going, they have access to the best facilities, the best chance to improve, and the best chance to stay on the field.
I have compiled a list of 8 names by casting a net across the league to see what options could match the criteria or be viable targets that might benefit from a change of scenery or a different organizational opportunity. I’ll start with the pending free agents, as they would represent the least amount of challenge to acquire. I’ll then move on to players who are entering their final season of team control and thus be relatively inexpensive in terms of acquisition cost so as not to mortgage the future. Finally, I’ll take a shot at some veteran guys with either big money or big question marks around them. Let’s have some fun!
Free Agents
Casey Mize
Mize posted a 2.70 ERA in 16 starts before being dealt to the San Diego Padres at this year’s trade deadline. Unfortunately for him, the deal didn’t work out as planned, joining the fray. He posted a 7.46 ERA in 10 starts in San Diego, where his HR rate spiked through the roof! One obvious advantage of bringing Mize to St. Louis is that the cavernous Busch Stadium would let a slightly above-average fly-ball pitcher like Mize thrive. When you look at park-adjusted HR rates, it’s no surprise that Busch Stadium would’ve yielded the best batted ball results this season for Mize. The strikeouts were another issue after he moved to SoCal, where he was striking out nearly a batter per inning; in Detroit he only struck out 25 batters in 44.2 IP in SD. That’s an atrocious K rate. FanGraphs Ben Clemens projects for a 2-year 34 million dollar contract.
Kris Bubic
Injuries have been a pretty consistent theme of Bubic’s last couple of seasons, but the guy is also highly effective when he’s on the mound. The Cardinals LOVE their lefty pitchers with good changeups, and that’s Bubic’s game. After a deal at the deadline sent Bubic from KC to LA, he has made a few appearances out of their bullpen and hasn’t allowed a run during the regular season after joining the Dodgers. Bubic made 20 starts in 2025 to the tune of a 2.55 ERA in 116.2 IP and was named an All-Star for his first-half contributions. He reminds me a little bit of Matthew Liberatore, where the fastball is bad, but the off-speed stuff is really good; the difference being that Bubic has figured out how to make it work with that arsenal and find legitimate success. Neither of the free-agent options is really going to fire anyone up, but they can positively contribute to a big-league staff on a 1-year pillow deal for roughly 12-15 million. I’d expect Bubic to be one of the more heavily considered candidates this offseason cycle. Ben Clemens of FanGraphs projects a 2-year, $ 34 million contract for Bubic.
Trades (Arbitration eligible)
Tanner Houck
Now we’re gonna get into the more interesting stuff. Tanner Houck came back from injury at the end of September and pitched in a big-league game. That matters in terms of him having a normal offseason to get ready for next year. The last couple of seasons have been mostly washed out due to injury, but in addition to my previous point, perhaps a homecoming for Houck would be something that could help get him back on track. A graduate of Collinsville High School and the University of Missouri, Houck is a local product with some really interesting pitch movement characteristics. A guy coming over from Boston with a Sinker/Sweeper mix that has battled injuries and used to feature a high-octane 4-seam fastball, sound familiar? In 2024, Houck produced a 3.12 ERA and a 3.32 FIP in 178.2 IP, producing a 3.8 fWAR season!
Why would Boston move on from Houck? MLBTR came out with their arbitration estimates, and Houck is projected for a 4.1 million dollar salary in 2027. When you consider that they’ll already be returning Crochet, Tolle, Suarez, Oviedo, and Bennett. 4.1 million seems a little rich for a 6th starter with injury questions.
Clarke Schmidt
Schmidt has only topped 30 starts once in his career, and that occurred in 2023. He’s managed to make 3o total over the previous 3 seasons, combining for a 3.07 ERA in 164 IP and a 24.8 K% during that time; analysts have always liked the stuff associated with Schmidt, and if you think back to Jordan Montgomery, the Cardinals have had success with plucking injury-plagued starters from New York and getting the most out of them. Again, the premise of Schmidt’s availability could be centered around not wanting to pay his projected 4.5 million dollar salary and there being too many options ahead of him with Schlittler, Cole, Fried, Warren, Rodon, and Weathers. That doesn’t even factor in young guns looking for opportunity like Elmer Rodriguez or Carlos LaGrange, so the opportunity exists to pry Schmidt away from the Bronx.
Shane McClanahan
Shane McClanahan is the drug I just can’t seem to quit, it seems. A guy with true Cy Young upside who has battled injuries every year since 2022. Entering his walk year as a Tampa Bay Ray, that usually means it’s time to start figuring out where he goes next. Chaim Bloom was a member of the Rays org when McClanahan was selected and debuted; the familiarity is there, and the stuff is back this season, pitching 118 IP and producing a 3.36 ERA and a 3.50 FIP.
To me, McClanahan (6.6 million arb projection) makes too much sense, and I might try to expand any deal to include veteran back-end bullpen pieces such as RHP Griffin Jax (5.7 million arb projection) and/or LHP Garrett Clevinger (3.7 million arb projection). You could accomplish your primary goals in one fell swoop and add tangible upside that could lead to a return to the postseason or be flippable assets that postseason teams covet at the deadline. Could you flip an Andre Pallante (7.5 million arb projection) who is coming off a big year, with an additional year of control, and he does something “weird” that the Rays love to target? Again, it makes all the sense in the world to me.
Trades (Veteran bouncebacks)
Luis Severino
This one is a real toss-up in my eyes because he has not been bashful about his frustrations pitching in Sacramento. The stuff is still really good; the results, like any starter who has taken the mound in the hitter’s haven that is the Sacramento Sutter Health Park. Still averaging about 97 on his fastball and striking out better than a batter per inning this season before an injury in May cost him the rest of the year. In 2024, he parlayed a 1-year deal in Queens, making 31 starts pitching to a 3.91 ERA and a 4.21 FIP. He likely will never be what he was in 2017-‘18 when he posted back-to-back 5 fWAR seasons, but at just 32 years old, the Cardinals could still get a really strong season out of him, and Busch Stadium would help aid in the HR issues he’s experienced at “Coors Field West,” as I call it. Because of the financial component, the A’s would either have to settle for a lesser package in return or, less likely, kick in money to enhance the return. But Severino in the past has performed like a front-of-the-rotation starter and could be a number 1 on the Cardinals staff.
Spencer Strider
Still just 27 years old, Spencer Strider has seen his career somewhat derailed by injuries over the last handful of seasons. We know from reporting that Strider was dangled at the trade deadline to the Texas Rangers in exchange for Jacob DeGrom before the deal was nixed by DeGrom due to his NTC (pesky things). That being said, that means that Strider is available and can be pried from Alex Anthopoulos; perhaps they’re exhausted with their reliance on Strider’s inability to stay healthy. At 2 years, with 44 million remaining and a club option in 2029 for another 22 million, it’s a bargain-rate price for a Sonny Gray deal, except it would be Gray when he was 7 years younger. Strider, when healthy, strikes out the world 32.8 K% lifetime, has a career 3.86 ERA and 3.28 FIP. If Chaim Bloom could pair him with Liam Doyle at the top of the Cardinals rotation for the next 2-3 seasons and add in Cintje, Franklin, etc., you can start to see how a legit playoff rotation can start to take shape. I have no idea what Anthopoulos would ask for in return for Strider; there’s no guarantee he will stay healthy or be as effective after numerous injuries. As far as the raw talent, execution, and both in-season and playoff experience of the potential talents that could be available this offseason, Strider might be the most intriguing candidate, and the return would dictate whether or not the risk would make sense.
I know fans are weary of an extended time without postseason baseball in St. Louis, after already missing the last 4 years and finishing under .500 in back-to-back seasons, and the last thing most fans want to hear is that they’re still trying to be cautious and not push too soon before this next wave has fully arrived (Rodriguez, Jesus Baez, Doyle, Cintje, Franklin, Molina, Santana). We’ve already seen Joshua Baez, Bernal, and Mathews break through to the big club.
This offseason, roster investment will likely center around pitching additions like a Dustin May-type and a couple of veteran bullpen arms; they might also look for a veteran left-handed journeyman infielder who can work into the 3rd base picture. I don’t expect a splash there, given internal options that already exist both short- and long-term; think about a left-handed version of Ramon Urias, like a Nicky Lopez or Josh Rojas. I know, I know, what does that actually accomplish? Don’t shoot me, I’m just relaying what I’ve heard. I know some very loud, prominent voices in the comments desire a significant upgrade in center field, and I don’t see that as particularly likely this offseason either, unfortunately.
-Thanks for reading













