Good morning, New York Giants fans! Here are the headlines you need to start your week.
‘The Coach Hated Him’ — Ex-NFL Scout Raises Eyebrows With Claim About Vikings HC Kevin O’Connell’s Feelings Towards J.J. McCarthy | Pro Football Network
“And if I wanted to speak for you in regard to J.J. McCarthy, you hated his guts as a player. You couldn’t (expletive) stand him,” Middlekauff insisted. “Because you were clearly the driving force for making him the third quarterback and helping the GM: ‘We gotta get this guy out of here. Fifth-round pick, I’ll drive him to the airport.’ Which is fine. You’re not the first or the last coach to feel that way toward
a QB.”
“It’s happened before and it will happen again. Then a couple of weeks later, when you’re starting Carson Wentz, who couldn’t hit water from the middle of the ocean and then J.J.’s making plays like that for (Matt) Nagy and Greg Roman you’re like, ‘Uh, no one is acting like this guy is Joe Montana, but this is way better than what we had.’”
What I’m hearing about Chargers-Broncos trade bitterness, why Jonathan Taylor stayed | The Athletic
But the Colts weren’t high on dealing Daniel Jones, who played well before his torn Achilles last year. Anecdotally, it appears players are better two years out from Achilles tears, and Jones tore his 11 months ago. Though he hasn’t played well lately, the hope is he will improve.
And Jones needs a quality running back in Jonathan Taylor, whom the Colts might have overvalued these past few weeks. League sources aren’t sure a deal of a second and fifth will be on the table for Taylor in March, so it could be easy to say Indy should have dealt him this past week.
But by trading players on expiring deals and keeping a quality running back like Taylor and a quarterback who could improve (but could also be released before the team pays him $38 million more), Dodds has created optionality for the next GM. That GM could be Dodds himself, who has been on short lists across the league the last few years, or it could be an outsider.
Giants’ Sneak Over Tush Push Call Remains a Head-Scratcher | Giants on SI
The numbers supported a tush push on 3rd-and-1, so why didn’t the Giants run it? We have some a theory.
Continued Giants growth requires John Harbaugh fourth down adjustments | Daily News
The Washington Commanders didn’t win Thursday’s game. The Giants lost it.
John Harbaugh and his staff have given this franchise a coaching advantage this season, but their decision-making fell short in their biggest game to date.
Teams lose in the NFL. The Giants still look like they’re going in the right direction. But Harbaugh needs to learn from his mistakes if the first-place Giants (5-3-1) intend to win the NFC East.
The coach’s conservative calls on fourth downs on offense in the fourth quarter stood out in particular:
Former Pro Bowler Donte Whitner says Jameis Winston should be cut for ‘Who Let the Dogs Out’ stunt | New York Post
“I’d cut Jameis Winston this morning,” Whitner said on ESPN’s “Get Up” on Friday. “It was so unrealistic. You have 10 other guys out there and guys on defense that are busting their butt every week, and it’s very hard and difficult to win a game in the National Football League. So, when you get up there – first and foremost, whoever says hut 1, hut 2, hut 3? That’s 1950s football!
“And then when you go into ‘Who Let the Dogs Out’? Are you serious? He’s clearly just trying to go viral on social media while they’re trying to win a football game. He’d get his pink slip this morning.”
There are plenty of reasons to believe these Giants have what it takes | New York Post
The weekend off for the Giants could have been a glorious respite if they had been able to hang on and beat the Commanders on Thursday night.
That did not happen and the 24-21 loss was their most agonizing and wasteful of the season.
From Big Blue View
- Tougher schedule ahead? NY Giants ‘don’t live in that scared world’
- Giants know why Dominic Zvada is missing kicks; now, can they fix it?
- Big Blue View mailbag: Kickoff rule, Rasul Douglas interception, more
Submit a question
Have a Giants-related question? E-mail it to bigblueview@gmail.com and it might be featured in our weekly mailbag.
BBV on social media
BBV on X: @BigBlueView
Ed Valentine on X: @Valentine_Ed
Threads: @ed.valentine | Bluesky: @edvalentine
BBV on Facebook: Click here to like the Big Blue View Facebook page
BBV on YouTube: Subscribe to the Big Blue View YouTube channel | Ed Valentine on YouTube (videos and interviews are now being posted here)
BBV on Instagram: Click here to follow our Instagram page













