So while we’re talking about how bad the defense was and how great the offense was in the San Francisco 49ers’ 46-40 winover the Dallas Cowboys, there’s still one thing to bring up: the officiating.
It was terrible.
Not like you can expect much more from a crew ran by John Hussey. Sorry to say, it probably wasn’t going to get much better, because if the 49ers didn’t get Hussey, they would have gotten Bill Vinovich. You can call one the lesser of the two evils, but it’s still evil. And don’t say we
didn’t see it coming:
And Hussey did just about what you’d expect from Hussey. But the league will want you to celebrate him for going down the street to make this game with a crew that hasn’t worked together. That will probably also be the excuse—if we ever get one (don’t count on it). Because after all, Hussey had to go to this game after all the air traffic control issues over the weekend. So he saved the day. What a hero.
Whatever.
Before we go any further, it’s important to note that officiating would NOT have been the reason the 49ers lost yesterday, even if it had happened. Dre Greenlaw not catching a gift interception would be why they lost. The lack of a pass rush would be why they lost. Deommodore Lenoir getting diced just as much as he was defending passes would be why they lost.
In fact, no need to be so granular. The defense would be why they lost. But the two aren’t mutually exclusive, and Hussey’s inconsistencies put the defense in a tougher spot.
We can go on and on about how badly that game was officiated. Some calls will get arguments; others won’t. For instance, Osa Odighizuwa got flagged early in the game for roughing the passer.
That’s a battle I’m not going to engage in. The call can go either way. It is the rules, and it looks like body weight. You can argue that he was braced with a free hand, but in real time? I’m not going to fault the crew for that one.
I will fault them for Brock Purdy taking a headshot later in the game after throwing the ball. Anytime the head moves from the QB after throwing the ball, it’s a roughing penalty. But not for Hussey and Brock Purdy. I tried to find video but couldn’t.
There’s also the blatant pass interference that was very one-sided. Here’s a good example:
If you’re going to do that, make sure you’re consistent. With this crew that’s asking an awful lot. Let’s move onto this gem of a phantom penalty:
Huh?
What, and I want a lot of dots after this because this is important……………
What the hell is that? I can understand a flag in the moment due to speed, but how does replay not remove that foul? How does the discussion during the ref show go on for this and no one can speak up to say “didn’t look violent.” Instead, a great play gets wiped, and a player is kicked for doing their job. I don’t know what’s more inconsistent, Hussey or the replay assist.
None of those calls are really surprising. What is surprising is this:
Ladies and gentlemen, that is a fumble. Was it recovered? Nope. Was it even reviewed? Nope.
Was there even a chance to have a recovery? Nope.
And this is where I wonder who is more at fault: Hussey or Kyle Shanahan. For a coach with some head-scratching challenges over the years. This no-challenge might be one of the more head-scratching ones of all. Or is it?
“We knew it was out,” Shanahan said in his post-game press conference. “That’s why I wanted to throw it [the challenge flag]. And I thought that we did have it, but somehow, a guy on their team was walking away with the ball.”
For the turnover to happen, the film has to show a clear recovery by the 49ers. While Shanahan thought Malik Mustapha recovered the ball, his analysts upstairs and the scene of the 49ers not walking away with the ball were enough for him to put the flag back into his pocket.
But if Mustapha had it, why did the Cowboys walk away with it?
“The refs were telling us to get up and stop fighting for it,” Fred Warner said, recalling the play. “Because they had the ball, and I was trying to fight. But I also didn’t want to get a penalty for trying to delay the game”
Makes sense. Here’s the play in question. Now, from the angle on the broadcast, I don’t know where the ball is in relation to the whistles—but that leads to my next question: why were the whistles blown? How did a referee not see that, and why was the beanbag thrown down? Why are they not fighting for control of the ball? Why is this not being reviewed anyway? How did this get so mucked up?
So if there’s no clear recovery—fine, that is understood, but the whistle shouldn’t have been blown in the first place until after they started untangling the pile and telling everyone to let go. At least, that’s how it looks from my point of view.
Truthfully, we won’t know who recovered the ball, but it could have been worth a challenge anyway. Given what we know, it’s doubtful the 49ers would have won the challenge, but it would have been worthwhile one, I suppose. It really shouldn’t have gotten to that point. Hussey’s crew should have seen the ball pop out and/or let the fumble and subsequent recovery happen.
But that’s not how they operate. Because of reasons. Knowing what you know, would you have thrown the challenge flag anyway, or would you have held off, knowing that it was a losing battle?













