It took a top-100 prospect to acquire Johan Oviedo last winter, when Craig Breslow brought him to Boston along with Tyler Samaniego and Adonys Guzman in exchange for Jhostynxon Garcia and Jesus Travieso. So far, that trade has been a loss for both teams.
Password really struggled in his first meaningful exposure to big league baseball with the Pirates last year. That wasn’t all that surprising. Sure, he was a top-100 prospect. But the vast majority of top-100 prospects don’t reach their potential.
And, even before the trade, there were plenty of reasons to suspect that Garcia wouldn’t. On the Boston side of the ledger, the deal didn’t work out any better, as Oviedo threw just 3.2 innings before once again succumbing to a major injury, something he’s been wont to do in his short career.
So you might not think it’s a big deal that, not even one year later, Craig Breslow appears to be cutting his losses. Last night, he traded Oviedo to the Arizona Diamondbacks in exchange for a player-to-be-named-later and Luke Dotson, a towering left-handed reliever who pitched in A ball last season, and who, according to Baseball America, “has a chance to develop into a low leverage reliever” if he adds velocity.
I’m not going to pretend to be some kind of pitching whisperer and bitch about this trade on the basis of Oviedo’s potential. (Though, for what it’s worth, our own Jake Roy is some kind of pitching whisperer, and he liked him.) But I will say this: I am extremely confused about this trade.
As of yesterday, Oviedo was probably either the Red Sox sixth or seventh starter, depending on how you felt about Tanner Houck. And in 2026, your sixth or seventh starter is a really important part of your ballclub. Your sixth or seventh starter will pitch for your team — and probably a lot. Hell, with the frequency at which pitchers get injured in spring training these days, I’d say the pitcher who begins the spring as the sixth starter has close to a 50/50 shot of making the opening day roster by the end of spring, merely because so many arms in front of him will have gone down in the Florida sun.
And in Oviedo’s case, not only was he your sixth or seventh starter, but he was also someone with big league experience in the bullpen. Yes, he once again got injured, and maybe they really didn’t like what they saw in his medicals. And, yes, he was out of options, meaning he couldn’t really be stashed away in AAA (though, again, that’s where his experience as a bullpen arm comes in — they wouldn’t necessarily need to stash him in AAA). But Oviedo is essentially still the exact same guy they traded for last winter. He’s a tantalizing fireballer with the physical traits Breslow loves, but one with little track record who would initially be relied on for little more than depth.
With Sonny Gray and Oviedo now gone (along with Connelly Early before them) the starting pitching depth, which was a such a strong point for the the Red Sox last season, has been decimated. After Houck, we’re now looking at… Cutter Krawford as the seventh starter, I guess? The same Kutter Crawford who has not pitched in two years, is now 31-years-old, and gave up the most homers in the league the last time he did take the mound?
Even if Breslow has lost all hope in ever being able to develop Oviedo, I can’t figure out why he would make this deal now, as opposed to in the spring, when (a) the Red Sox may need him to step into the rotation after a few injuries, or (b) plenty of other teams will be looking for back-of-the-rotation arms to fill holes.
Craig Breslow appears to now believe that he can find pitchers as easily as I can find the nearest Dunkin’ Donuts. He better make a few quick coffee runs before the Red Sox next take the field.













