Dave Dombrowski and the Phillies front office correctly assessed that Matt Strahm was not actually good in 2025. He carried a shiny ERA at 2.74 over 62.1 innings that season but showed major red flags. His fastball velocity declined by a mile per hour, which led to a declining strikeout rate, a spike in his walk rate, and Strahm being forced to shift his mix significantly. He dropped his four-seam fastball usage from 53% in 2024 to 38% in 25, throwing more sliders and cutters to keep hitters off balance.
It worked but wasn’t very sustainable, so the Phillies shipped him to the Kansas City Royals, who were not up to speed on his red flags and needed a left-handed arm.
Alex Vesia has pitched in many big games for the Los Angeles Dodgers over the years and has been a top left-handed option in Dave Roberts’ bullpen but carries similar red flags. His strikeout rate dropped a few ticks, although a 31.2% K% is ridiculous still. The spike in walks is harder to justify, going from 9.3% to 13.5%. His fastball velocity also dropped half a tick even though he’s only 30.
The worry here with his age-31 season coming is that Vesia is sneakily closer to the wrong side of the aging curve than you think, especially with the 31 added postseason appearances since 2021. Specifically in the last three Dodgers postseason runs, Vesia has pitched in a combined 226 games. It both shows his durability but also that he might be closer to a sharp decline, which is common for good non-closer relievers in their 30s.
It’s easy to be cautious about buying the future dip.
What about signing Luis Robert… to play right field?
One word that is thrown around with Luis Robert Jr. is “upside,” and it’s difficult to imagine that applying to Luis Robert in the year 2026. Over the last three seasons, Robert has played 271 games with an OPS+ of 88 with clear chasing and strikeout problems to sell out for power. He still accumulated 3.6 bWAR in that time because he provides defensive value and isn’t an albatross with the bat. Still, the term “upside” doesn’t align with reality.
Also, yes, I wrote a piece about how he was such a perfect fit in 2024.Hilarious stuff.
If you’re wrong once, just try again, Luis Robert Jr. makes sense but in a different light. He could be what Adolis Garcia was supposed to be for them last year.
The Phillies signed Adolis Garcia last off-season to provide impressive right-field defense and to provide power with a better approach. Garcia certainly provided elite right-field defense with a cannon but did not produce at the plate, hitting just .195 with a .599 OPS. On top of that, he played in just 67 games because of a season-ending lat injury.
If the Phillies are shopping for one-year deal candidates for the outfield, Robert is probably a good bet to make when compared to the rest of the one-year free agent options.
Robert does not have the same cannon attached to his shoulder but he is a good candidate to play right field next season. He’s never been a bad center fielder but is closer to average out there with how much range is required at the position. Moving to right would give a team significant defensive range in a corner, which is becoming more and more common for teams.
At the plate, he can hit a few dingers still but carries an approach that should keep him hitting no higher than 6th and that’s probably generous. He will chase and has not crushed fastballs enough to make up for the poor swing decisions.
With all of that said, it’s still fair to project him as roughly a slightly below league average hitter with a strong glove in right field as a regular. That sounds like what they envisioned Adolis Garcia being last season only that Robert is not physically cooked.
The other potential one-year options include Tyrone Taylor, who is coming off an impressive offensive season in just 97 games but has never established himself as a regular. Randal Grichuk played way above his head last season and is 35. Cedric Mullins and Daulton Varsho cannot hit. Taylor Ward looked cooked after going to Seattle. Lane Thomas looked solid for the Royals and Braves but is not very good defensively which limits how often you can play him.
There is another elephant in the room, Robert has not stayed healthy in his career. There is no way to predict or guarantee health on anyone but Robert is a safe candidate to assume won’t stay healthy. The Phillies might be one of the teams who can best shelter him, both matchup-wise and health-wise.
They will probably look for Harper to play roughly 30 games of right field next year, with Schwarber playing more first base. That frees up the DH spot for veterans like Trea Turner and JT Realmuto but also gives the Phillies an easier path to dealing with an injury-prone player. They can rest Robert against tougher matchups and to help preserve his body better. Injuries might still happen but injury luck is also sometimes random.
With the other options being terrible, if Luis Robert is looking for a one-year prove-it contract and the Phillies either cannot or will not sign one of Teruaki Sato, Randy Arozarena, or Seiya Suzuki, it’s probably the best bet to make to help raise their floor.
Will he help them raise their ceiling? Probably not, that’s not who he is anymore. They need floor raisers and he can help provide them that.













