The news that every Pirates’ fan was waiting for is finally official as Brandon Lowe has formally denied the Pirates’ qualifying offer and will elect to test free-agency.
Seen as a long shot from the beginning, Lowe and the Pirates did not come to terms on the qualifying offer that they extended following the conclusion of the regular season, giving Lowe the freedom now to explore other opportunities. The Pirates’ qualifying offer for Lowe was a one-year contract worth $23.15 million for the 2027
season. Although it was a substantial pay increase for Lowe from his 2026 campaign, ($11.5 million) he is likely seeking a multi-year contract. At 32-years old this is likely the last time that Lowe can bet on himself for a big money contract over multiple seasons.
General Manager Ben Cherington commented on his conversations with Lowe last week at the General Managers Meetings in Las Vegas.
“I think Brandon and [his wife] Madison had a great experience in Pittsburgh, and it would be a great outcome if he was a Pirate next year,” Cherington said. “And that’s what we’ve communicated. We’ve agreed to take it a step at a time. I’m sure there will be another conversation at some point soon. It’s been a few days, probably, since I’ve had one, but the conversations have been both with Brandon directly at the end of the season and with his agents.”
There is still a world where Lowe and the Pirates can come to terms on a contract, but the clock is likely ticking much faster on this deal than it would’ve in years past. Because the CBA is expiring on December 1, and MLB owners are trending toward a lockout, players will likely want to get deals done by the end of November if possible.
Still though with the chips stacked against them, the Pirates do have a chance at bringing Lowe back to Pittsburgh. He is certainly their top priority of the offseason and should be willing to throw whatever they can at Lowe. The Silver Slugger award winner had a very successful season in Pittsburgh in 2026. He hit .260 with an .824 OPS, 35 home runs and 96 RBIs. He also improved leaps and bounds as a defender, and was a Gold Glove finalist for the first time in his career and posted a +12 fielding run value. Lowe in his lone season with Pittsburgh hit more home runs in a single season than any other Pirates’ second baseman before him.
There are of course several factors that could see Lowe sign elsewhere. You always have to wonder how much money the Pirates are willing to spend. Although there’s been flashes lately of owner Bob Nutting being more willing to pay players, historically the Pirates have been a bottom of the league team in terms of payroll. Not to mention the market they play in does not compare to New York, Los Angeles or Philadelphia.
Lowe had All-Star numbers in 2026 and yet was not voted onto the team. Is that because he wasn’t receiving enough national attention in Pittsburgh, or was Ozzie Albies just that much better than him? Would Lowe have been an All-Star if he played for New York, Atlanta or LA? There’s no doubt Lowe has to be thinking about these factors when it comes to deciding where to sign, as there should be plenty of suitors for the best power hitting second baseman in baseball.
If Lowe were to sign elsewhere for $50 million or more, the Pirates would receive a 2027 Draft pick between the first round and Competitive Balance Round A. If he were to sign elsewhere for under $50 million, the compensation pick would come after Competitive Balance Round B.










