We’re so close to a top 10! As the holidays approach, the 2027 Willie McCovey Memorial Community Prospect List grows, as we seek to rank the top 44 prospects in the San Francisco Giants organization.
Our latest vote was a landslide: 72 community members voted on the four-name ballot, and 53 of those voters chose one player. That player? Shortstop Gavin Kilen, who has been voted as the No. 8 prospect in the system. That’s a drop of one spot for Kilen, who debuted on the CPL at No. 7 a year ago.
Kilen,
a left-handed hitter, was taken by the Giants in the first round of the 2025 draft, with the 13th overall pick. His debut last year, in Low-A, was brief (10 games), limited by injuries, and not that great. Despite that, the Giants had Kilen — who played college ball for Tony Vitello at Tennessee — open the 2026 season with High-A Eugene.
He needed exactly one game to justify that decision. In the Emeralds’ season-opener, Kilen smashed not one, but two home runs, including a walk-off two-run shot. That kicked off an outrageous opening week for Kilen, who turned 22 in late March. Over his first five games at the level, he recorded 10 hits, five extra-base hits, and 10 runs batted in, while drawing three walks.
Eventually he came back to earth, but he maintained strong performance all the way to the All-Star break, hitting .282/.350/.462 for an .811 OPS and a 112 wRC+ in 78 games. That earned him a promotion to AA Richmond, though an injury limited him to just 33 games there. But he posted a five-game hitting streak to start his tenure in the Eastern League, and ended his stint there with a .297/.343/.469 slash line, resulting in identical overall numbers to his time in Eugene: an .811 OPS and a 112 wRC+.
As advertised, Kilen’s contact skills were among the best in the system. In addition to his .286 batting average across the two levels, he struck out just 14.2% of the time. His power was modest — he had 11 home runs in 492 plate appearances — but he showed a lot of line drive ability, as he hit 37 doubles on the year, which was tied for fifth in all of the Minor Leagues (interestingly, the Giants had four of the eight most prolific doubles hitters in the Minors this year).
Kilen has always been viewed a bit more as a high floor prospect than a high ceiling one, and both sides of that coin were shown this year. The contact skills certainly look like they can play at any level, and he’s defensively sound. On the other hand, he’s almost certainly headed for second base sometime between now and his MLB debut, is mediocre on the power front, and stole just one base this season. As is, he’s a quite good prospect … but if he can address one of those areas, he could become a very good one.
One of the questions entering 2027 is where Kilen will start. He played well in AA, but were his 33 games there enough for the Giants to feel comfortable moving him up to AAA? Logistically, that would be ideal, as it would allow he and Jhonny Level to play shortstop everyday, rather than split duties in AA. But it would also make sense if the Giants want him to get a little more seasoning in the Eastern League.
Either way, he’s in prime position to start making a case for a big league debut. If not at the beginning of the year, Kilen will certainly be in AAA at some point, and then he’s only one call away from the bigs, where the Giants currently have a few question marks at second base, his likely future position. He’s one to watch, that’s for sure.
Now let’s add to the list, and we’ve got some new names to vote on. As a reminder, voting takes place in the comment section now.
The list so far
- Josuar González — SS
- Jackson Flora — RHP
- Luis Hernández — SS
- Jhonny Level — SS
- Ramon Marquez — RHP
- Bo Davidson — OF
- Jacob Bresnahan — LHP
- Gavin Kilen — SS
Note: Clicking on the above names will link to the CPL where they were voted onto the list.
No. 9 prospect nominees
Carson Bolemon — 19.7-year old LHP — yet to debut
Argenis Cayama — 20.1-year old RHP — 4.87 ERA/4.27 FIP in Low-A (57.1 IP)
Trevor Cohen — 23.0-year old OF — .803 OPS/117 wRC+ in High-A (380 PA); .736 OPS/99 wRC+ in AA (228 PA)
Parks Harber — 25.1-year old 3B — .879 OPS/131 wRC+ in AA (298 PA); .739 OPS/98 wRC+ in AAA (250 PA)
Joniel Hernandez — 17.8-year old SS — .978 OPS/132 wRC+ in DSL (238 PA)
Dakota Jordan — 23.5-year old OF — .879 OPS/125 wRC+ in High-A (355 PA); .697 OPS/87 wRC+ in AA (88 PA)
Henry Lalane — 22.5-year old LHP — 2.74 ERA/2.63 FIP in Low-A (62.1 IP); 3.86 ERA/4.78 FIP in High-A (37.1 IP)
Keyner Martinez — 22.3-year old RHP — 4.61 ERA/4.77 FIP in Low-A (93.2 IP)
Note: Each player’s first name links to their Baseball-Reference page, and their last name links to their Fangraphs page. All stats are from the 2026 season.













