Slugger Eugenio Suárez is fresh off a season that saw him thwack 49 home runs and be valued at 3.8 fWAR (3.6 bWAR). He reached free agency at season’s end and signed a one-year deal to return to the Cincinnati Reds, the club that traded for him prior to the 2015 season – and the club for whom he thwacked 189 homers across 7 years previously in his career.
Despite the successes at the plate Suárez saw for the bulk of the 2025 season, the Reds managed to land him for just a $15 million guarantee for 2026,
well below the three-year, $63 million predicted by the fine folks at MLB Trade Rumors earlier in the offseason. Perhaps it was the high strikeout rate, or the suppressed offensive numbers Suárez put up in the tough hitting environment in Seattle, but it’s pretty clear something suppressed the now 34 year old slugger’s value enough that he landed in Cincinnati’s lap for a year.
It certainly could have had something to do with the nature of this particular free agent class, one that featured a number of high-caliber sluggers. Kyle Schwarber and Kyle Tucker, for instance, were out there on the open market, as were each of Pete Alonso, Josh Naylor, Bo Bichette, Alex Bregman, and Cody Bellinger for every team looking to add thump to their lineup. Suárez, it seems, got overlooked just enough by other teams for the Reds to be able to pounce for cheap, and there’s every chance that Geno gets to hit free agency next year – when there’s expected to be a much lighter supply of sluggers – with a bit more leverage.
But, what if the Reds have already positioned themselves to have a little leverage here, too?
Suárez, who’ll turn 35 years old in July, has somehow managed to make it to this point in a career that’s seen him hit 325 homers and accrue 33.1 fWAR without ever having been issued a Qualifying Offer. That’s largely due to the long-term contract extension he signed with the Reds the first time he was in town, one that kept him signed despite trades from Cincinnati to Seattle, Seattle to Arizona, and from Arizona back to Seattle along the way. Somehow, this past winter – at age 34 – Geno was a free agent for the first time, but since he’d been traded mid-season the Mariners were not able to issue him a QO at season’s end.
If he stays with Cincinnati for the duration of the 2026 season, though, the Reds could issue him a QO at season’s end, much the same way they did with Nick Martinez one winter ago. And given that Geno only found a one-year, $15 million market for his age-34 season after swatting 49 homers and posting 3.8 fWAR, it’s hard to see there being a significantly bigger market for him entering an age-35 season even if he completely replicates the production in 2026 that he did last year.
(By default, that fWAR mark it going to be much more difficult to get to since he’ll be asked to DH much, much more than he ever has, and therefore won’t get granted any value at all from his glove.)
Granted, next winter could see a free agent slugger class devoid of the franchise-altering names that were available this winter. For all their talents, Randy Arozarena, Seiya Suzuki, and George Springer entering his age-37 season don’t quite move the needle the way the previously mentioned group did. So, if Suárez does manage to go nuclear while playing another season in Great American Ball Park, there’s always the chance he finds richer pastures than what he’d get by simply accepting a QO from the Reds – something that’ll be akin to $23 million for the 2027 season. But even then, the Reds would get a draft pick out of the deal if Geno turned down the QO and found a better deal elsewhere.
So, there’s a chance Suárez could already be on a two-year, ~$38 million deal with the Reds, effectively, though there’s still a number of scenarios that let the Reds off that hook if they so desire.
Obviously, a poor year by Geno could allow the Reds to eschew even issuing him the QO at season’s end and allow him to simply reach free agency with no strings attached. That would effectively make it as if the Reds had a team option for him for 2026 that the declined with no buyout.
Things could very well go sideways for the Reds during the 2026 season, too, at which point they could trade Geno to someone else in July and escape even having to make these decisions. They could even decide to do that if things in town are going well, Ke’Bryan Hayes and Sal Stewart and Spencer Steer all hit well, and the fit simply doesn’t seem as obvious as it did this winter.
However, if the guy they turned to for his ability to sock baseballs over the fence continues to excel at that again in 2026 and they determine they want his gum-bubble ability back for a second year, well, that decision may well have already been made for them.
