Welcome back to the Arrowhead Pride Mailbag! Throughout the season, keep watching The Feed for an opportunity to submit your questions about the Kansas City Chiefs!
The Chiefs turned in their best offensive performance in years with a 35-13 victory over the Atlanta Falcons in Week 10. Let’s see what’s on our readers’ minds before hosting the flailing Arizona Cardinals on Sunday.
Joel Thorman asks:
How much playing time will Emmett Johnson see down the stretch if Kenneth Walker is healthy?
When the Blogfather (who has
done so much to advance my writing career at Arrowhead Pride) submits a question, it goes straight to the top.
This is really a hard one because the Chiefs have never had two top talents at running back simultaneously in the Andy Reid era. Isiah Pacheco and Jet McKinnon did have a nice timeshare in 2022, with Pacheco doing the first-down and second-down work and McKinnon coming in for obvious passing downs. However, Johnson does not have the pass protection chops McKinnon boasted to work in a pure pass-down back role. He also can rumble for much more damage between the tackles than McKinnon could in Kansas City.
I will be surprised if Walker suits up against Arizona with a short week looming. But Johnson has too much talent to go back to a reserve role after he returns. The best thing the Chiefs can do going forward is put the two in a true timeshare, even if that is not what Walker signed for top dollar in free agency to do. The ability to keep both running backs fresh as defenses get tired is probably the best thing Kansas City can do for the offense.
I expect Walker to sit against Arizona before probably returning to a bell cow role on Thanksgiving after what will likely be two heavy workloads for Johnson. When the schedule settles down, I expect the eventual 60/40 split favoring the veteran.
5crawfishdinners asks:
How much time does a receiver really need to be productive in our offense? Seems we always hear how long it takes to learn our offense yet Josh Downs seemed to do pretty good with just one week of practice. Starting to think that’s just an excuse for receivers that just aren’t that good.
I think too much is made of it. If a receiver has talent, he can get the system. Downs clearly knew what he was supposed to do in his limited work Sunday. Perhaps in a more competitive game, they would have gone to him more.
When DeAndre Hopkins came to the Chief at the 2024 trade deadline, I believe he was in such decline that he simply could not take on the role Kansas City needed, no matter how spectacular his best moments looked. Even so, he caught eight passes for 82 yards and two touchdowns in his second game in red and gold.
People also forget how quickly Kadarius Toney seemed to be working into the Chiefs’ offense when he arrived via trade in 2022 before (predictably) injuring his hamstring in his third game. His second game in Kansas City saw four receptions for 57 yards and a touchdown — ultimately his second-best offensive performance as a Chief.
I don’t think it’s that the scheme is impossible to learn as much as Toney not having what it took to be an NFL receiver in any system and Hopkins facing a firm ceiling on how much he could handle. Downs is the best position any acquisition has had to really take off in season.
Don’t be surprised if Downs is limited again in the game plan this weekend before seeing a very high weekly snap count starting in Buffalo.
Swaf asks:
Will Josh Downs take more of Xavier Worthy’s snaps moving forward?
Downs will primarily do his damage out of the slot, where Worthy has only aligned on 22% of his routes. But the newest Chiefs receiver will probably have an effect on how much work is left for the third-year pro in a disappointing season.
Truthfully, Worthy needs to look over his shoulder at rookie Cyrus Allen, who ran a perfect outside route for a deep touchdown Sunday — the type of play Worthy teased the potential for coming out of college. Downs taking work in the slot also led to Rashee Rice getting more downfield work on Sunday — and the player generally relegated to a gadget receiver reeled in a 50-yard reception in Atlanta.
Obviously, it would be better for the Chiefs if Worthy was dependably making such plays and using his speed to truly take the lid off of defenses. But early on, the presence of Downs appears set to give Allen and Rice opportunities to do the job that Worthy so far has not been able to.
I expect the Chiefs to give Worthy plenty of chances to get on track against the Cardinals. But if he turns in another game to forget, I could see his workload cut drastically in Buffalo.
HychHype asks:
I don’t want to be pessimistic but is what we’ve seen in the past two weeks more about who the Chiefs have played (Jets, Falcons) or are they finally rounding into form as they prepare to play the better teams (Buffalo, San Francisco, etc.). I hope it’s the latter, lol.
I try not to overreact too much to wins or losses. There are several things that make me skeptical about how unstoppable the Chiefs looked in the second half against the Falcons. To start with, Atlanta had the misfortune of playing an international contest the week before and not coming home to the bye. In the week between returning from Madrid and facing the Chiefs, they traded starting safety Jessie Bates and center Ryan Neuzil. There were definitely times on Sunday the team looked like it was missing integral pieces of communication on both sides of the ball.
However, a team can only play the competition in front of them. A significant criticism of the Chiefs, even in winning seasons, has been playing down to the competition. I expected one of the last two games to end up being a frustrating down-to-the-wire affair with Kansas City needlessly letting an inferior team hang around. Both times, the Chiefs pulled no punches and turned in dominant second halves.
If they had done the same in Denver in Week 8, they probably would be 9-1, with the division all but wrapped up and the conversation about level of competition looking very different.
We will see what they look like against some of the tougher teams coming up. However, we have also seen the Chiefs underwhelm in the regular season in such situations — only to come out on top of some of those same teams when the games matter in January.
waye6589 asks:
What does it typically take for Andy to fire an assistant coach like special teams coordinator Toub? The penalties, the lack of production, the onside kick, the lack of development, and the punt returner issue coming up again have to be making his seat warm.
I believe Toub has reached a level of detrimental to the team not seen since Bob Sutton ran Kansas City’s defense. Nothing about the third unit inspires much confidence. It’s hard to have faith in anything but a chip-shot field goal attempt. The Chiefs have never seemed a threat on the new kickoff rule that Toub helped design. When a good return actually happens, a penalty call is the default expectation.
I am not sure Kansas City’s front office has done Toub much help. They probably should have made the call above him by now simply to stop putting Harrison Butker out there for kicks. Also, the Chiefs have not added any college players with significant punt return experience — either via late-round pick or undrafted free agency — in the last few draft cycles. After a decade of talent such as De’Anthony Thomas, Tyreek Hill and Mecole Hardman in the return game, Toub has fielded far inferior options the past two seasons.
That said, his coaching looks sloppy. He has not adjusted to how expensive Kansas City’s roster has become, which has left him unable to depend on the same players year after year as he once did. The Chiefs simply cannot afford the roster space to keep players like former (nominal) linebacker Dorian O’Daniel in-house to fill special teams with dependable talent.
Hopefully, it does not take a playoff collapse to end Toub’s era as it did for Sutton. I do think the Chiefs will have some major special teams changes this offseason. Even if Butker finishes the season as Kansas City’s kicker, I do not predict he will be brought back at a non-guaranteed $5.7 million salary in 2027. Punter Matt Araiza will be eligible for restricted free agency after the season, and the Chiefs will either need to tender him an estimated $3.8 million contract offer or allow him to test the market. Who knows how many more one-year contracts the Chiefs will give out to 37-year-old long snapper James Winchester.
With the potential for high player turnover, I think there is a decent chance of a new coordinator next season.
Thank you for reading this week’s Arrowhead Pride Mailbag! With a short week, we will not have a mailbag before the Chiefs face the Buffalo Bills on Thanksgiving night. Watch in the feed for a chance to submit your questions before the Chiefs face the Las Angeles Rams in Week 13’s edition of “Thursday Night Football.”













